NFL Union's All-Time Team- Watch for the Part 2 Thread soon.

Alrith, ttbh wins this one.

Next Position: Guard, 8-10 players

Larry Little

Tom Mack

Gen Upshaw

Bruce Matthews

Joe DeLamielleure

Mike Munchak

Billy Shaw

Lou Creekmur

Forrest Gregg

John Hannah

Ngamer i believe you have a lot of tackles on your list- Yary, Dierdorf, Munoz, Slater.

Sorry about that, here's my real list :D

Gene Upshaw

Joe DeLamielleure

Bill Shaw

John Hannah

Walt Kiesling

Mike Munchak

Rayfield Wright

Larry Little

Tom Mack

Bruce Matthews (he played every line position, but honored as a guard)

Well, you both used at least one person who I would consider a tackle instead of a guard(Wright, Gregg, and Creekmur), but it's easily fixable because you both listed 10 people. Removing the above names from the lists, I lean towards Ngamer for going waaay back in the file and pulling out Walt Kiesling.

Both are good though.

Maybe to get more responces we should extend the time limit to 48 hours. And NGamer gets my vote and the winthetombradyhate

I think you're right. If we don't get 5 lists in 24 hours, the deadline will extend to 48 hours.

That being said, congrats to Ngamer, let's move on.

Next position: Kick/Punt Returners, 6 players

• Desmond Howard
• Tim Brown
• Claude Gibson
• George McAfee
• Lynn Chandnois
• Gale Sayers

• Desmond Howard
• Gale Sayers
• Michael Bates
• Billy "White Shoes" Johnson
• Rick Upchurch
• Deion Sanders

Mel Gray

Desmond Howard

Rick Upchurch

Vai Sikahema

Billy "White Shoes" Johnson

Ron Smith

This was a tough one:?

Brian Keith Mitchell

Mel Gray

Deion Sanders

Eric Metcalf

Desmond Howard

Cecil Turner

Alright, only 3 positions to go. I was going to save this next one for last, but we need something to draw some interest before we hit Tackles.

Next position: Runningbacks(including Fullbacks, Halfbacks, and the like), 8-10 players

RB:

Walter Payton

Gale Sayers

Barry Sanders

Emmitt Smitth

Jim Thorpe

Jim Brown

Marcus Allen

earl Campbell

Tony Dorsett

Eric Dickerson

Doak Walker

Marcus Allen

Barry Sanders

Tony Dorsett

Walter Payton

Emmitt Smith

Jerome Bettis

Gale Sayers

Eric Dickerson

Jim Brown

O.J. Simpson

Jim Brown

O.J. Simpson

Emmitt Smith

Eric Dickerson

Gale Sayers

Walter Payton

Earl Campbell

Marcus Allen

Thurman Thomas

Barry Sanders

any list without Emmitt Smith fails. Oh and i refuse to put OJ, sick bastard.

Emmitt Smith

Jim Brown

Walter Payton

Tony Dorsett

Erick Dickerson

Earl Campbell

Gale Sayers

Barry Sanders

Marcus Allen

Thurman Thomas

• Jim Brown
• O.J. Simpson
• Emmit Smith
• Bo Jackson
• Barry Sanders
• Tiki Barber
• Jerome Bettis
• Walter Payton
• Eric Dickerson
• Thurman Thomas

• Marcus Allen
• Thurman Thomas
• Eric Dickerson
• Emmitt Smith
• Walter Payton
• Jim Brown
• Earl Campbell
• John Riggins
• Roger Craig
• Barry Sanders

I'm having a hard time deciding this one. Sayers' dominance was so short-lived, I don't think he belongs on a list of the Top 10 All-Time. But I have the most issues with the other 2 lists that don't include him(lack of OJ on one, presence of Tiki on the other).

I think I'm going to go with Ngamer as my middleground.

I'm having a hard time deciding this one. Sayers' dominance was so short-lived, I don't think he belongs on a list of the Top 10 All-Time. But I have the most issues with the other 2 lists that don't include him(lack of OJ on one, presence of Tiki on the other).

I think I'm going to go with Ngamer as my middleground.

wallymartin

Would Marshall Faulk have counted? I'm not sure how the rules work...

[QUOTE="wallymartin"]

I'm having a hard time deciding this one. Sayers' dominance was so short-lived, I don't think he belongs on a list of the Top 10 All-Time. But I have the most issues with the other 2 lists that don't include him(lack of OJ on one, presence of Tiki on the other).

I think I'm going to go with Ngamer as my middleground.

Ngamer05

Would Marshall Faulk have counted? I'm not sure how the rules work...

Doesn't have anything to do with the rules, I'm just stating my opinion on the matter.

Alright, looks like Bobbles takes the cake.

Next Position: Offensive Tackles, 8-10 players

Art Shell

Bob St. Clair

Ron Mix

Bob "Boomer" Brown

Lou Groza

Ron Yary

Jackie Slater

Anthony Munoz

Dan Dierdorf

Mike McCormack

Art Shell (Although his coaching sucks)

Lou Groza (Also a KICKER, an OT Kicker... not something you see everyday)

Dan Dierdorf

Bob St. Clair

Bob Brown

Mike McCormack

Roosevelt Brown

Anthony Munoz

Jackie SLater

Ron Mix

Art Shell

Roosevelt Brown

Bob "Boomer" Brown

Frank Kinard

Jackie Slater

Anthony Munoz

Dan Dierdorf

Mike McCormack

Lou Groza

Ron Mix

• Art Shell
• Ron Yary
• Dan Dierdorf
• Forrest Gregg
• Roosevelt Brown
• Bob Fry
• Matt Stinchcomb
• Jon Stinchcomb

My pick goes to sfgiantsfan.wallymartin

Alright, sfgiantsfan gets it.

Last position: Linebackers, 10-12 of them

Lawrence Taylor

Bill George

Dick Butkus

Mike Singletary

Harry Carson

Ted Hendricks

Sam Huff

Ray Nitschke

Joe Schmidt

Nick Buoniconti

Jack Ham

Willie Lanier

• Lawrence Taylor
• Dave Wilcox
• Bill George
• Jack Ham
• Harry Carson
• Dick Butkus
• Bobby Bell
• Sam Huff
• Nick Buoniconti
• Ray Nitschke

Dick Butkus

Lawrence Taylor

Mike Singletary

Ray Nitschke

Joe Schmidt

Jack Lambert

Bill George

Dave Wilcox

Nick Buoniconti

Sam Huff

Harry Carson

Jack Ham

Hmm I got suspended 2 days and yall haven't voted yet. That's good.

Dick Butkus

Laurence Taylor

Mike Singletary

Joe Schmidt

Jack Lambert

Nick Buoniconti,

Sam Huff

Bill George

david Wilcox

Jack Ham

Ray Nitschke

That's because we didn't have 5 lists. Now we do, so let's vote.

Somebody else go first this time.

I will cast the first vote and it will be for Wally's list. He included all of the necessary players and then added Derrick Thomas, who was one of the best linebackers of his time and maybe even one of the greatest all time.