Bands you don't get the appeal of?

[QUOTE="UbiquitousAeon"]

Yes, that was very much in the discussion. In fact, that was the basis of my entire argument. It's you who had a hard time figuring it out something very, very simple. I'm done though. There's no point in talking to you, I'll be sure to remember this in the future. You give me a headache.

LJS9502_basic

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]

[QUOTE="UbiquitousAeon"]

Yes, that was very much in the discussion. In fact, that was the basis of my entire argument. It's you who had a hard time figuring it out something very, very simple. I'm done though. There's no point in talking to you, I'll be sure to remember this in the future. You give me a headache.

UbiquitousAeon

[QUOTE="UbiquitousAeon"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"] No. The discussion on my end was not about different structures. I said all songs had structure. Period. You can read over my posts. I have not deviated from that stance once. You did contradict yourself a few times regarding structure. *shrugs* The posts show that....

LJS9502_basic

[QUOTE="MistressMinako"][QUOTE="chicknfeet"]Nothing wrong with liking them :P. I like N-Sync. To each their own LJS9502_basic

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="UbiquitousAeon"]And I agreed with you that all songs had structure, I never once said that any of the songs mentioned in this discussion had no song structure. That's just what you put into my mouth. What I actually did say was that some song structures are more repetitive than others, then you went on with your nonsense and now were here, where you still think your high and mighty. LJS, you are the contradiction. UbiquitousAeon

Nope. Once you agreed with my posts.....you pretty much gave me the argument.LJS9502_basic

Nope. Once you agreed with my posts.....you pretty much gave me the argument.LJS9502_basic

WOW, can't believe I just read every post of your guys' argument for the last few pages. I thought for sure there would be at least some form of resolve at this point......I'm ******* exhausted.. lol

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Nope. Once you agreed with my posts.....you pretty much gave me the argument.UbiquitousAeon

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Nope. Once you agreed with my posts.....you pretty much gave me the argument.Lethargika

WOW, can't believe I just read every post of your guys' argument for the last few pages. I thought for sure there would be at least some form of resolve at this point......I'm ******* exhausted.. lol

[QUOTE="Lethargika"]

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Nope. Once you agreed with my posts.....you pretty much gave me the argument.LJS9502_basic

WOW, can't believe I just read every post of your guys' argument for the last few pages. I thought for sure there would be at least some form of resolve at this point......I'm ******* exhausted.. lol

*snatches cookie* NOM NOM NOM.......k Im ready for another 20 rounds......:)

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="Lethargika"]

WOW, can't believe I just read every post of your guys' argument for the last few pages. I thought for sure there would be at least some form of resolve at this point......I'm ******* exhausted.. lol

Lethargika

*snatches cookie* NOM NOM NOM.......k Im ready for another 20 rounds......:)

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Nope. Once you agreed with my posts.....you pretty much gave me the argument.Lethargika

WOW, can't believe I just read every post of your guys' argument for the last few pages. I thought for sure there would be at least some form of resolve at this point......I'm ******* exhausted.. lol

I stopped posting for a reason.

Anything I don't already listen to.

[QUOTE="Lethargika"]

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Nope. Once you agreed with my posts.....you pretty much gave me the argument.RobboElRobbo

WOW, can't believe I just read every post of your guys' argument for the last few pages. I thought for sure there would be at least some form of resolve at this point......I'm ******* exhausted.. lol

I stopped posting for a reason.

Well I guess there are people out there who find pleasure in beating dead horses.

[QUOTE="Lethargika"]

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Nope. Once you agreed with my posts.....you pretty much gave me the argument.LJS9502_basic

WOW, can't believe I just read every post of your guys' argument for the last few pages. I thought for sure there would be at least some form of resolve at this point......I'm ******* exhausted.. lol

"I think you are confusing melody with what that song he linkied did. Yes a melody will repeat but not with only a chord or two....which is what the linked song did.

Because when all is said and done if we consider the melody to be repetitive then all songs are repetitive. However, I wasn't talking about melody...and the repetition should not be constant even with that said. One of the worst offenders for repetition is AC/DC....all their songs are alike but even they don't repeat such a minor chord/progression continually in a short space of time."

Me:

"The Cure is far too strophic. Many of their songs are nothing but verse and chorus, repeated over and over. There's minor variations in the composition, but nothing that saves it from repetition. I used to listen to them a lot back in the day, they aren't a bad band, but yeah I'm going to have to call them out as repetitive."

You:

Then as I said....all songs are repetitive. However, the song linked was repetitive for almost the first minute....and then the change up was repeated.

Song structure...which you are talking about is in every song. It's even used in cIassical music. Structure will repeat....but that is not what I meant when I called that song repetitive. Did you listen to it?You think I didn't know this? A musician of 12 years?

Me:

Maybe all the songs you listen to, but not ALL songs are repetitive in the same way as others. There are many bands that use more sophisticated structure and lots of change throughout the songs. Here's a few examples:


---------------
Now to end it once and for all.

Me:

"If there are 20 or so DIFFERENT sections in one song, versus 2 sections that repeat over and over in another song. Which one is less repetitive? It's that ****ing simple. That was my argument, yet you took it completely out of context and did nothing but provoke me this whole time."

Again, Compare it to:

"Maybe all the songs you listen to, but not ALL songs are repetitive in the same way as others. There are many bands that use more sophisticated structure and lots of change throughout the songs. Here's a few examples:"


So therefor YOU ARE WRONG!

The Cure is in fact much more repetetive than the songs I listed due to its overly conventional song structure.

So therefor YOU ARE WRONG!

UbiquitousAeon

Either we consider structure to make all songs repetitive OR we can't use structure as a means of calling a song repetitive. Because according to your argument all songs are repetitive. I have not said that either. Just the start of the linked song was repetitive. And to me...it was. You cannot win an argument over opinion....ever.

You copied all that for nothing.:lol:

You still are arguing two different things....

I never changed my stance on the argument. Sorry dude, but I think that horse is liquefied from all the beating you're giving it. UbiquitousAeon

Oh...and you avoided answering my question. Do songs have structure or not? Because that is and has been my stance since the beginning.LJS9502_basic

.

I've said what I wanted to, it's you who has been arguing out of context this whole time. I was never arguing against your point about song structure. My point from the very beginning was that some songs have a higher complexity in terms of structure than others. It's clearly written in my previous posts, I have no idea where you're getting your information from. But it sure as hell isn't helping your case. :lol:

[QUOTE="UbiquitousAeon"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Oh...and you avoided answering my question. Do songs have structure or not? Because that is and has been my stance since the beginning.imaps3fanboy

I've said what I wanted to, it's you who has been arguing out of context this whole time. I was never arguing against your point about song structure. My point from the very beginning was that some songs have a higher complexity in terms of structure than others. It's clearly written in my previous posts, I have no idea where you're getting your information from. But it sure as hell isn't helping your case. :lol:

UbiquitousAeon

.

RobboElRobbo

[QUOTE="UbiquitousAeon"]

I've said what I wanted to, it's you who has been arguing out of context this whole time. I was never arguing against your point about song structure. My point from the very beginning was that some songs have a higher complexity in terms of structure than others. It's clearly written in my previous posts, I have no idea where you're getting your information from. But it sure as hell isn't helping your case. :lol:

LJS9502_basic

yea

yea

imaps3fanboy

just for good measure

[QUOTE="chessmaster1989"]

[QUOTE="RobboElRobbo"]

LJ, why do you never admit you're wrong? Your favorite band in the whole wide world is a ton more repetitive than Amon Amarth. The song I posted is in fact repetitive, but the majority of their songs aren't.

LJS9502_basic

Yes, this is very true... The Cure is a much more repetitive band than AA...

I've listened to songs by The Cure before. Imo they're repetitive. Does AA have some level of reptitition as well? Yes, but I think they are a significantly more interesting and fun-to-listen-to band than The Cure.

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="chessmaster1989"]

Yes, this is very true... The Cure is a much more repetitive band than AA...

chessmaster1989

I've listened to songs by The Cure before. Imo they're repetitive. Does AA have some level of reptitition as well? Yes, but I think they are a significantly more interesting and fun-to-listen-to band than The Cure.

I like Paramore... *looks around confused*

Oleg_Huzwog

[QUOTE="RobboElRobbo"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]A good argument does not rely on ad hominem attacks.

LJS9502_basic

Point out where this was a good argument. :|

Well, at least Robbo did a good job of arguing his point. ;)

I like Paramore... *looks around confused*

I stopped posting for a reason.

RobboElRobbo

You's beens trolled son. :P

Foo Fighters

[QUOTE="DEVILinIRON"]

[QUOTE="JonnyEagle"] In what way?

Guppy507

[QUOTE="Haziqonfire"][QUOTE="Oleg_Huzwog"]

I like Paramore... *looks around confused*

Engrish_Major

**** just gotreal in this thread.

I like Paramore. Maybe it's cuz the singer chick is hot.

Never liked Dave Matthews Band. Annoying.

Ke$ha needs to go away, someplace far far away, like someplace where she ceases to live and her "music" never exists.

Nickelback, most scream-o and Justin Bieber.

I like Paramore. Maybe it's cuz the singer chick is hot.

Never liked Dave Matthews Band. Annoying.

Ke$ha needs to go away, someplace far far away, like someplace where she ceases to live and her "music" never exists.

meteo_ryte

I like Paramore. Maybe it's cuz the singer chick is hot.

Never liked Dave Matthews Band. Annoying.

Ke$ha needs to go away, someplace far far away, like someplace where she ceases to live and her "music" never exists.

meteo_ryte

[QUOTE="meteo_ryte"]

I like Paramore. Maybe it's cuz the singer chick is hot.

Never liked Dave Matthews Band. Annoying.

Ke$ha needs to go away, someplace far far away, like someplace where she ceases to live and her "music" never exists.

JonnyEagle