[QUOTE="Teenaged"]
[QUOTE="KC_Hokie"]Bigotry involves hate. If you really hate gays when you express your opinion...yea that's bigotry.
Saying you simply support traditional marriage certainly isn't hatred and therefore not bigotry. You can have a different opinion without being hateful.
KC_Hokie
I dont know about you but if I did meet a person that really thought black people are inferior and should be slaves, I would be pissed at him/her. If that does qualify as being a bigot then there certainly must be different types of bigots, and the word carries no definite negative meaning whatsoever, because I think that the hate towards said person is justified and reasonable.Besides that, based on a definition I'm using (since OT likes definitions) there is no mention of hate (although I had the same impression as you about the word). Based on the definition, I think it relies on whether or not each side's stance (in general; not just what they believe but what role they'd like their views to play as well) is reasonable. If it is reasonable as a whole then the definition doesnt apply because if a stance is reasonable and logical then it cant be characterised as obstinate. If someone would like to stick to the "superiority" part, then every time someone thinks they are right with 100% confidence then they could be called a bigot, which doesnt make sense. So obviously "superiority" doesnt refer to simply thinking you are right.
My point is, there's a lot of interpretation to be made on the definition itself.
My take is that based on how I used the word "stance" earlier, there definitely are people that are against gay-marriage that dont deserve to be called bigots. And those, imo, would be those who simply disagree without wishing to impose their views via laws.
But it does apply imo to the rest who do wish that. And I'm willing to bet, the outrage coming from people who are pro-gay marriage is due to that group, not the other. Unfortunately, maybe sometimes the frustration makes people attack the first anti-gay marriage group as well.
Not sure what slavery has to do with a modern day belief.Again, you can be pro traditional marriage with no hatred involved; therefore, no bigotry.
You can also be a pro-gay marriage bigot due to hatred and intolerance of another opinion.
Bigotry can work both ways because it's based purely on hate and not rational.
Why does it have to do with modern day belief? Its an opinion someone can have whether you think it is relevant in our times or not.Did you read past the first line of my post?
Intolerance though doesnt necessarily entail being hateful or irrational, so being intolerant of a view doesnt necessarily equate to being a bigot.
Log in to comment