I notice that a lot of people in the media are pointing fingers at Obama for this disaster. So my question is, does he deserve this or are they doing it for political gain, rather then the benefit to the country?
This topic is locked from further discussion.
I notice that a lot of people in the media are pointing fingers at Obama for this disaster. So my question is, does he deserve this or are they doing it for political gain, rather then the benefit to the country?
People want o blame the BP executives (b/c they are the highest ranking employees in the company...they are in charge)
**if** (big if) you follow that logic, then it is only fair to blame Obama an equal amount
The US gov just gave them a ****ing safety award
-the have gone through countless inspections by US Gov employees
-the US gov was in charge of making sure BP followed regulations and was operating in a safe manner
-Obama is the highest ranking employee in the company known as the US gov.
I don't really blame either though
Not much. Just that special vague responsibility that comes from just being President. wstfldThis. He'll pay for mistakes that aren't his, like all presidents do.
None. What they hell could he do to prevent it?cd_romhe could have made sure the inspectors were doing their jobs, he could have aided the rig when it was on fire, he could have looked at the situation sooner then two weeks after it became a catastrophe, he could have used the in place plan that the gov had for this kind of situation, and last but not least he could always do something more then a press release. i voted partial
[QUOTE="wstfld"]Not much. Just that special vague responsibility that comes from just being President. supercubedude64This. He'll pay for mistakes that aren't his, like all presidents do. governmental inspectors are part of his administration as he is administrating the government
[QUOTE="supercubedude64"][QUOTE="wstfld"]Not much. Just that special vague responsibility that comes from just being President. surrealnumber5This. He'll pay for mistakes that aren't his, like all presidents do. governmental inspectors are part of his administration as he is administrating the government
And how does an inspector go about inspecting every foot of pipeline nearly a mile beneath the surface of the ocean all across the gulf? Because this pipe isn't the only pipe... The are dozens of them... Which makes thousands of miles of pipe...
governmental inspectors are part of his administration as he is administrating the government[QUOTE="surrealnumber5"][QUOTE="supercubedude64"] This. He'll pay for mistakes that aren't his, like all presidents do.Buttons1990
And how does an inspector go about inspecting every foot of pipeline nearly a mile beneath the surface of the ocean all across the gulf? Because this pipe isn't the only pipe... The are dozens of them... Which makes thousands of miles of pipe...
X-ray vision.I am not sure there really is anyone to blame for it... I would say BP, but even then it seems less like slack and poor maintenence and more like a semi freakish accident.
People just want someone to blame, when the constructions and way we usually do things fail.
*sigh*
It is howver a really bad situation, I feel really bad when the US was asking around the world for help, but none of us had any way to be of any real help :\ It is too deep, and needs specialised equipment that is fare more then just rare.
governmental inspectors are part of his administration as he is administrating the government[QUOTE="surrealnumber5"][QUOTE="supercubedude64"] This. He'll pay for mistakes that aren't his, like all presidents do.Buttons1990
And how does an inspector go about inspecting every foot of pipeline nearly a mile beneath the surface of the ocean all across the gulf? Because this pipe isn't the only pipe... The are dozens of them... Which makes thousands of miles of pipe...
if youre going to have safty inspectors they need to be held accountable for their inspection as does their bossgovernmental inspectors are part of his administration as he is administrating the government[QUOTE="surrealnumber5"][QUOTE="supercubedude64"] This. He'll pay for mistakes that aren't his, like all presidents do.Buttons1990
And how does an inspector go about inspecting every foot of pipeline nearly a mile beneath the surface of the ocean all across the gulf? Because this pipe isn't the only pipe... The are dozens of them... Which makes thousands of miles of pipe...
...I had a point to make but I can't stop staring at your signature. I think I could watch that for hours.
Wow, completely not related.... I'm commenting one aspect of the very nature of blaming Obama in which some posts in this thread are included. Very related indeed :)[QUOTE="Osaka-06"]I love how some right wingers immideatly point the finger at Obama and the government for not reacting swiftly enough but at the same time whine about the government being too big and having too much authority.Chutebox
[QUOTE="rawsavon"]I am not really into the blame game (for either BP or the the US gov.) -but I do blame the Gov. for reacting too slowly. -they left it up to a company to handle for far too long ChuteboxIt's still BP doing everything. The White House is just going to send lawyers there to see if anything criminal was done and send them (just did this) a bill BP has to pay.
IMO, once it starts negatively affecting the US it is time for the Gov to step in and take charge (to protect our interests)
Wow, completely not related....[QUOTE="Osaka-06"]I love how some right wingers immideatly point the finger at Obama and the government for not reacting swiftly enough but at the same time whine about the government being too big and having too much authority.Chutebox
how exactly is that unrelated?
I am not really into the blame game (for either BP or the the US gov.) -but I do blame the Gov. for reacting too slowly. -they left it up to a company to handle for far too long rawsavon
well BP wasn't even gonna try top kill, until they were told to
I love how some right wingers immideatly point the finger at Obama and the government for not reacting swiftly enough but at the same time whine about the government being too big and having too much authority.Osaka-06Wow, completely not related.... I'm commenting one aspect of the very nature of blaming Obama in which some posts in this thread are included. Very related indeed :)The problem is you have the nature part completely wrong. The type of legislation to take care of these oil spills has been around since the mid-90's.
Wow, completely not related....[QUOTE="Chutebox"]
[QUOTE="Osaka-06"]I love how some right wingers immideatly point the finger at Obama and the government for not reacting swiftly enough but at the same time whine about the government being too big and having too much authority.LastCaveMan
how exactly is that unrelated?
Because this isn't big Government. This is fixing a disaster that happened effecting American people.[QUOTE="rawsavon"]I am not really into the blame game (for either BP or the the US gov.) -but I do blame the Gov. for reacting too slowly. -they left it up to a company to handle for far too long LastCaveMan
well BP wasn't even gonna try top kill, until they were told to
I think their engineers pretty much knew nothing was going to solve this (beyond a second well)[QUOTE="LastCaveMan"][QUOTE="Chutebox"] Wow, completely not related....
Chutebox
how exactly is that unrelated?
Because this isn't big Government. This is fixing a disaster that happened effecting American people. That's just semantics and your argument doesn't hold any water at all. You could claim the same thing about health care or any other process that uses government resources. And to that other guy. Time doesn't affect values and ideals.None really, he hadno way of predicting this disaster. I think it has been a bad idea letting BP handle trying to stop the spill for so long, but it is their mess to contain and they 'should' be best equiped and prepared to stop something like this. The real question is why is BP still allowed to even drill for oil, they don't exactly have the greatest track record.
[QUOTE="Chutebox"][QUOTE="LastCaveMan"]Because this isn't big Government. This is fixing a disaster that happened effecting American people. That's just semantics and your argument doesn't hold any water at all. You could claim the same thing about health care or any other process that uses government resources. And to that other guy. Time doesn't affect values and ideals. Okay buddy lol, I'll leave it alone.how exactly is that unrelated?
Osaka-06
[QUOTE="LastCaveMan"][QUOTE="rawsavon"]I am not really into the blame game (for either BP or the the US gov.) -but I do blame the Gov. for reacting too slowly. -they left it up to a company to handle for far too long rawsavon
well BP wasn't even gonna try top kill, until they were told to
I think their engineers pretty much knew nothing was going to solve this (beyond a second well)yeah and Obama knows theirs nothing he can do, but people still expect him to for the cameras anyway - it works the same way.
[QUOTE="rawsavon"][QUOTE="LastCaveMan"]
well BP wasn't even gonna try top kill, until they were told to
I think their engineers pretty much knew nothing was going to solve this (beyond a second well)yeah and Obama knows theirs nothing he can do, but people still expect him to for the cameras anyway - it works the same way.
I hope that this 90% fix can hold until August (when the second well can be completed) They ****ed up cutting the pipe on which to place the 'top cap' though (it is jagged, which does not allow for a tight seal) -it is just so difficult to work that far down http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/2010/0604/Top-cap-on-BP-oil-spill-not-tight-enough-as-crude-keeps-spewing[QUOTE="LastCaveMan"][QUOTE="Chutebox"] Wow, completely not related....
Chutebox
how exactly is that unrelated?
Because this isn't big Government. This is fixing a disaster that happened effecting American people.Not big government? so YOU paying for the mess someone else has created, is not big government?
None really, he hadno way of predicting this disaster. I think it has been a bad idea letting BP handle trying to stop the spill for so long, but it is their mess to contain and they 'should' be best equiped and prepared to stop something like this. The real question is why is BP still allowed to even drill for oil, they don't exactly have the greatest track record.
SaintLeonidas
Their an international company...IE British Petroleum, theres nothing we can really do to stop them short of denying them American Drilling rights.
Because this isn't big Government. This is fixing a disaster that happened effecting American people.[QUOTE="Chutebox"][QUOTE="LastCaveMan"]
how exactly is that unrelated?
LastCaveMan
Not big government? so YOU paying for the mess someone else has created, is not big government?
We aren't going to pay for it, BP is. They have already been billed 69 million (just partial payment) which has to be paid by July 1st. Look, people know we need the government is some situations. Repubs do want government but they don't want them taking over business, etc etc etc.[QUOTE="Chutebox"][QUOTE="LastCaveMan"]Because this isn't big Government. This is fixing a disaster that happened effecting American people. And to that other guy. Time doesn't affect values and ideals.how exactly is that unrelated?
Osaka-06
What does that have to do with anything? How are values or ideals being affected back in the mid 90's about a plan of how gov't can subdue major oil spills from happening?
[QUOTE="LastCaveMan"][QUOTE="Chutebox"] Because this isn't big Government. This is fixing a disaster that happened effecting American people.Chutebox
Not big government? so YOU paying for the mess someone else has created, is not big government?
We aren't going to pay for it, BP is. They have already been billed 69 million (just partial payment) which has to be paid by July 1st. Look, people know we need the government is some situations. Repubs do want government but they don't want them taking over business, etc etc etc. Which will be passed on to consumers as higher pricing....;)Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment