[QUOTE="worlock77"][QUOTE="cee1gee"] what constitutes a real scientist
cee1gee
Well for starters one who's working in an actual field of science.
all science is really just theory anywayJesus says:
This is not what I envisioned.
This topic is locked from further discussion.
Well, if he added two suns and drawed a trollface in the sky with stars, then maybe. If he was capable of creating humans then I think he would be more than capable of creating mountain with the text "I'm god. U mad bro?"
all science is really just theory anywaycee1geeNo, it is a lot more than just colloquial theory. It is billions of facts.
[QUOTE="worlock77"][QUOTE="cee1gee"] what constitutes a real scientist
cee1gee
Well for starters one who's working in an actual field of science.
all science is really just theory anywayYou might want to learn a bit about scientific theory. Far too many people completely misunderstand the term.
[QUOTE="worlock77"][QUOTE="cee1gee"] what constitutes a real scientist
cee1gee
Well for starters one who's working in an actual field of science.
all science is really just theory anyway dude wtf are you doing[QUOTE="cee1gee"][QUOTE="worlock77"]Well for starters one who's working in an actual field of science.parkurtommoall science is really just theory anyway dude wtf are you doing Speaking the truth!
This is absurd. If you could prove God existed with empirical evidence, then it would remove every aspect of faith from the religion. I mean you can't believe in something if you know its real! God in that sense would just seen as a powerful space alien or something.
I tend to demand proof before believing in something as big as god. It's just evident as hell to me that one doesn't exist. Why we are here can be explained without a god, there is no evidence for a god so why should I believe in god? It's not like I'm insanely ignorant about it and what god are you refering to by the way? Just a god? the christian god? the Muslim god? I mean how are you so sure your god is the correct one? The only difference is atheists take it one step further by not believing in any of the gods.
The proof required would be very simple, all it would take is for god to come and say hello and show himself.
There is really no reason to believe in a god of any sort outside of what a book and groups of people tell you. There has been no physical evidence of miracles ever in the history of man, and everything we have replicated with science and the right conditions has shown us time and time again a lot of crazy stuff can happen when the elements are just right.
Outside of a book there is no reason to believe a god created anything. The only real evidence needed is physical evidence. Unless some event occurs which cannot be explained or replicated in any way, there is no reason to believe a god exists.
I know I'm at risk of setting up a strawman with this topic, but here goes... To those who deny the existence of God on the basis of lack of empirical evidence irrefutably showing it, what kind of evidence would you need to see before you believed? Evidence that you could not see yourself explaining away with something else. Quite frankly I'm under the assumption that the message "GOD EXISTS" could be coded into the DNA of every living organism and it would be explained away via coincidence, ancient trolling aliens, or people looking at DNA wrong before the scientific community accepted it. But that's why I'm asking you guys, out of curiosity, what you would accept. Or are you under the assumption that the existence of God is unprovable making the "I need proof" argument moot?NuclearNerd
Because a neutral person needs proof of the existence of something, anything, before they can accept it as fact.. Your reasoning is based on twisting evidence around your conclusion you already made, not vice versa. No rational person would take your word that you can fly like Superman with out seeing evidence of it, this pretty much goes with any kind of supernatural or extreme case in the end.
The sheer quantity of evidence needed to prove the existence of a specific god would be so monumental than you wouldn't be able to fit all of it into a forum post.
The problem with that is "the burdon of proof". If I say "there's a cupcake on this table" I have to prove to you that there is a cupcake there. If you can't see it, touch it, or smell it, and I have no evidence at all that it's there then you have every right to conclude that there is no cupcake. The problem with you saying athiests "pull that card" is that it's like me saying "prove this cupcake doesn't exist" without putting a cupcake on the table. You can't prove it doesn't exist if it's not there to disprove. If you say "there's nothing there to disprove" you just get told it IS there and that it's up to you to disprove it's not there even though you have no evidence to suggest it's there to disprove. It's not a card. It's logic. And that's the beauty of God and religion. It bypasses logic. God (for arguments sake) doesn't exist, therefore He can't be disproven, which means He also can't be proven, which means He can't be disproved; it's a circle where nothing gets done but the people who believe in the nothing get away with it because there's no contradictory evidence to suggest anything else. Even now I'm going around in circles. :PI'm an atheist but I was raised as a Christan. It's not really the fact that we can't prove that god exists that makes me an atheist. We also can't prove that god doesn't exist either so I find it funny when other atheists pull that card. So I don't demand any proof of god.
I'm an atheist because religion in general sounds like a fairy tale to me. A fairy tale that many of us are raised to believe and we end up not knowing anything else. When it comes to Christianity I'm not very keen on following a 2000 year old book that has most likely been altered a LOT from the original texts by the Romans and what not. We live in such a little fragment of humanity, how do you KNOW the bible is true and so is you're god?
Pikdum
btw I'm not being offensive by saying it bypasses logic (imperial/tangible evidence) or by calling it nothing (no physical presence).
to me religion is kinda a cult any way you look at it.some of us have no reason to think into him being real some people are arrogant about it some arnt. till we die even then we may never know but you cant prove or disprove no matter what the argument will always be flawed
Ahh, this is why I have faith. God is real, and he works through natural means. He doesn't need some black hole to open up to make his will happen on Earth. Imagine Earth as a great plan he has had in motion for billions of years. He can plan for natural events, and plan for miracles. This is the part where people say, well then I don't really have a choice, but in truth you do. Imagine God is your best friend. He knows you so well, that he knows what you are going to do next. He knows what everything and everyone is going to do next, so he plans for it. He truly is all powerful and all knowing.There is really no reason to believe in a god of any sort outside of what a book and groups of people tell you. There has been no physical evidence of miracles ever in the history of man, and everything we have replicated with science and the right conditions has shown us time and time again a lot of crazy stuff can happen when the elements are just right.
Outside of a book there is no reason to believe a god created anything. The only real evidence needed is physical evidence. Unless some event occurs which cannot be explained or replicated in any way, there is no reason to believe a god exists.
Wasdie
[QUOTE="Wasdie"]Ahh, this is why I have faith. God is real, and he works through natural means. He doesn't need some black hole to open up to make his will happen on Earth. Imagine Earth as a great plan he has had in motion for billions of years. He can plan for natural events, and plan for miracles. This is the part where people say, well then I don't really have a choice, but in truth you do. Imagine God is your best friend. He knows you so well, that he knows what you are going to do next. He knows what everything and everyone is going to do next, so he plans for it. He truly is all powerful and all knowing.There is really no reason to believe in a god of any sort outside of what a book and groups of people tell you. There has been no physical evidence of miracles ever in the history of man, and everything we have replicated with science and the right conditions has shown us time and time again a lot of crazy stuff can happen when the elements are just right.
Outside of a book there is no reason to believe a god created anything. The only real evidence needed is physical evidence. Unless some event occurs which cannot be explained or replicated in any way, there is no reason to believe a god exists.
Darkainious
So if God knows everything that is going to happen then everything that happens has been predetermined. If that's the case then free will doesn't exist.
The problem with that is "the burdon of proof". If I say "there's a cupcake on this table" I have to prove to you that there is a cupcake there. If you can't see it, touch it, or smell it, and I have no evidence at all that it's there then you have every right to conclude that there is no cupcake. The problem with you saying athiests "pull that card" is that it's like me saying "prove this cupcake doesn't exist" without putting a cupcake on the table. You can't prove it doesn't exist if it's not there to disprove. If you say "there's nothing there to disprove" you just get told it IS there and that it's up to you to disprove it's not there even though you have no evidence to suggest it's there to disprove. It's not a card. It's logic. And that's the beauty of God and religion. It bypasses logic. God (for arguments sake) doesn't exist, therefore He can't be disproven, which means He also can't be proven, which means He can't be disproved; it's a circle where nothing gets done but the people who believe in the nothing get away with it because there's no contradictory evidence to suggest anything else. Even now I'm going around in circles. :P[QUOTE="Pikdum"]
I'm an atheist but I was raised as a Christan. It's not really the fact that we can't prove that god exists that makes me an atheist. We also can't prove that god doesn't exist either so I find it funny when other atheists pull that card. So I don't demand any proof of god.
I'm an atheist because religion in general sounds like a fairy tale to me. A fairy tale that many of us are raised to believe and we end up not knowing anything else. When it comes to Christianity I'm not very keen on following a 2000 year old book that has most likely been altered a LOT from the original texts by the Romans and what not. We live in such a little fragment of humanity, how do you KNOW the bible is true and so is you're god?
DigitalExile
btw I'm not being offensive by saying it bypasses logic (imperial/tangible evidence) or by calling it nothing (no physical presence).
Can I just say, it is possible to prove to yourself God exists. Everyone could find out for themselves if they wanted. "Ask and ye shall recieve, knock and it shall be opened unto you."Ahh, this is why I have faith. God is real, and he works through natural means. He doesn't need some black hole to open up to make his will happen on Earth. Imagine Earth as a great plan he has had in motion for billions of years. He can plan for natural events, and plan for miracles. This is the part where people say, well then I don't really have a choice, but in truth you do. Imagine God is your best friend. He knows you so well, that he knows what you are going to do next. He knows what everything and everyone is going to do next, so he plans for it. He truly is all powerful and all knowing.[QUOTE="Darkainious"][QUOTE="Wasdie"]
There is really no reason to believe in a god of any sort outside of what a book and groups of people tell you. There has been no physical evidence of miracles ever in the history of man, and everything we have replicated with science and the right conditions has shown us time and time again a lot of crazy stuff can happen when the elements are just right.
Outside of a book there is no reason to believe a god created anything. The only real evidence needed is physical evidence. Unless some event occurs which cannot be explained or replicated in any way, there is no reason to believe a god exists.
worlock77
So if God knows everything that is going to happen then everything that happens has been predetermined. If that's the case then free will doesn't exist.
Just because you know your friend well enough to know he is going to make a stupid decision and go to jail doesn't mean he couldn't have made the right choice.[QUOTE="worlock77"][QUOTE="Darkainious"] Ahh, this is why I have faith. God is real, and he works through natural means. He doesn't need some black hole to open up to make his will happen on Earth. Imagine Earth as a great plan he has had in motion for billions of years. He can plan for natural events, and plan for miracles. This is the part where people say, well then I don't really have a choice, but in truth you do. Imagine God is your best friend. He knows you so well, that he knows what you are going to do next. He knows what everything and everyone is going to do next, so he plans for it. He truly is all powerful and all knowing. Darkainious
So if God knows everything that is going to happen then everything that happens has been predetermined. If that's the case then free will doesn't exist.
Just because you know your friend well enough to know he is going to make a stupid decision and go to jail doesn't mean he couldn't have made the right choice. That's not knowing your friend will go to jail, that's making a well informed assumption, there is a big difference.[QUOTE="worlock77"][QUOTE="Darkainious"] Ahh, this is why I have faith. God is real, and he works through natural means. He doesn't need some black hole to open up to make his will happen on Earth. Imagine Earth as a great plan he has had in motion for billions of years. He can plan for natural events, and plan for miracles. This is the part where people say, well then I don't really have a choice, but in truth you do. Imagine God is your best friend. He knows you so well, that he knows what you are going to do next. He knows what everything and everyone is going to do next, so he plans for it. He truly is all powerful and all knowing. Darkainious
So if God knows everything that is going to happen then everything that happens has been predetermined. If that's the case then free will doesn't exist.
Just because you know your friend well enough to know he is going to make a stupid decision and go to jail doesn't mean he couldn't have made the right choice.Me knowing that my friend is an idiot and does idiotic things is a bit different from some mystical being knowing exactly every event that will happen for billions of years. Beside, you said "plan", that God has a great plan in motion. I don't plan for my idiot friend to do idiotic things, he just does them since he's an idiot.
[QUOTE="Wasdie"]Ahh, this is why I have faith. God is real, and he works through natural means. He doesn't need some black hole to open up to make his will happen on Earth. Imagine Earth as a great plan he has had in motion for billions of years. He can plan for natural events, and plan for miracles. This is the part where people say, well then I don't really have a choice, but in truth you do. Imagine God is your best friend. He knows you so well, that he knows what you are going to do next. He knows what everything and everyone is going to do next, so he plans for it. He truly is all powerful and all knowing.There is really no reason to believe in a god of any sort outside of what a book and groups of people tell you. There has been no physical evidence of miracles ever in the history of man, and everything we have replicated with science and the right conditions has shown us time and time again a lot of crazy stuff can happen when the elements are just right.
Outside of a book there is no reason to believe a god created anything. The only real evidence needed is physical evidence. Unless some event occurs which cannot be explained or replicated in any way, there is no reason to believe a god exists.
Darkainious
Do you have anything to support your position, or are you just going to recite a bunch of poetic-sounding niceties in an attempt to make your position seem better? I can do that too, you know. Ahhh, this is why I don't have faith, because there is beauty in tangible existence. Everything from astral events to the simple interactions of animals with their environment is a sign of natural beauty, and our scientific progress and superior cognition has allowed us to understand it all to a surprising degree. The idea that a simple folding of the cerebellum, an evolutionary quirk and the result of hundreds of millions of years of natural selection, could result in such a vast knowledge and mastery over natural processes is simply amazing. And yet we still can't plan for natural disasters because of the complexity of natural processes and natural selection that are the result of billions of years of evolution, geology, and even some forces we do not yet understand, but are beginning to at again a surprising pace. And through it all, we have freedom. We are the masters of our own lives, and we are the masters of the events of this planet, and while that brings great responsibility it also brings tremendous opportunity for exploration and growth. Sure, the world is uncertain, sure we can't be certain of pretty much anything, but that also leaves a universe of limitless possibilities just waiting to be explored by gifted beings such as ourselves. We don't need any mythological beings controlling our destiny because our destiny is too full of potential to be limited by some esoteric plan, it's there for us to seize and control.
Also, one final footnote, I have heard a lot of very smart people discuss the contradiction between divine plans and free will, I have yet to see any of them rememdy such a contradiction. If someone knows everything that will happen in my life and has even planned all the eents in my life, then I have no control over my life.
Just because you know your friend well enough to know he is going to make a stupid decision and go to jail doesn't mean he couldn't have made the right choice.[QUOTE="Darkainious"][QUOTE="worlock77"]
So if God knows everything that is going to happen then everything that happens has been predetermined. If that's the case then free will doesn't exist.
worlock77
Me knowing that my friend is an idiot and does idiotic things is a bit different from some mystical being knowing exactly every event that will happen for billions of years. Beside, you said "plan", that God has a great plan in motion. I don't plan for my idiot friend to do idiotic things, he just does them since he's an idiot.
Ok, but you might plan to help him after he's out of jail. God doesn't just know you pretty good. I believe he is literally the father of your spirit. He had billions of years to get to know you real well. It's tricky to try and imagine what a perfect being is like, because he has some serious advantages over the rest of us. God operates on a higher level. Also I don't believe in a Hell per-say, but a place of misery for people who knowingly oppose God, even after they have proof. Everyone else would receive varying degrees of glory.[QUOTE="worlock77"][QUOTE="Darkainious"] Just because you know your friend well enough to know he is going to make a stupid decision and go to jail doesn't mean he couldn't have made the right choice.Darkainious
Me knowing that my friend is an idiot and does idiotic things is a bit different from some mystical being knowing exactly every event that will happen for billions of years. Beside, you said "plan", that God has a great plan in motion. I don't plan for my idiot friend to do idiotic things, he just does them since he's an idiot.
Ok, but you might plan to help him after he's out of jail. God doesn't just know you pretty good. I believe he is literally the father of your spirit. He had billions of years to get to know you real well. It's tricky to try and imagine what a perfect being is like, because he has some serious advantages over the rest of us. God operates on a higher level. Also I don't believe in a Hell per-say, but a place of misery for people who knowingly oppose God, even after they have proof. Everyone else would receive varying degrees of glory.That's nice, but you completely avoided my point.
[QUOTE="DigitalExile"]The problem with that is "the burdon of proof". If I say "there's a cupcake on this table" I have to prove to you that there is a cupcake there. If you can't see it, touch it, or smell it, and I have no evidence at all that it's there then you have every right to conclude that there is no cupcake. The problem with you saying athiests "pull that card" is that it's like me saying "prove this cupcake doesn't exist" without putting a cupcake on the table. You can't prove it doesn't exist if it's not there to disprove. If you say "there's nothing there to disprove" you just get told it IS there and that it's up to you to disprove it's not there even though you have no evidence to suggest it's there to disprove. It's not a card. It's logic. And that's the beauty of God and religion. It bypasses logic. God (for arguments sake) doesn't exist, therefore He can't be disproven, which means He also can't be proven, which means He can't be disproved; it's a circle where nothing gets done but the people who believe in the nothing get away with it because there's no contradictory evidence to suggest anything else. Even now I'm going around in circles. :P[QUOTE="Pikdum"]
I'm an atheist but I was raised as a Christan. It's not really the fact that we can't prove that god exists that makes me an atheist. We also can't prove that god doesn't exist either so I find it funny when other atheists pull that card. So I don't demand any proof of god.
I'm an atheist because religion in general sounds like a fairy tale to me. A fairy tale that many of us are raised to believe and we end up not knowing anything else. When it comes to Christianity I'm not very keen on following a 2000 year old book that has most likely been altered a LOT from the original texts by the Romans and what not. We live in such a little fragment of humanity, how do you KNOW the bible is true and so is you're god?
Darkainious
btw I'm not being offensive by saying it bypasses logic (imperial/tangible evidence) or by calling it nothing (no physical presence).
Can I just say, it is possible to prove to yourself God exists. Everyone could find out for themselves if they wanted. "Ask and ye shall recieve, knock and it shall be opened unto you."Can I just say, I find your arguments to be quite specious. Would you care to offer any real proof? ANyone can prove to themselves anything they please, that doesn't mean it is verifiably correct. We are talking about scientific proof, results that can be repeated and independently verified.
Imagine if he really did that, that'd be epicmaybe if god came down from the heavens and smited some people and said "do you believe in my now?" i would believe in him.
needled24-7
Also, one final footnote, I have heard a lot of very smart people discuss the contradiction between divine plans and free will, I have yet to see any of them rememdy such a contradiction. If someone knows everything that will happen in my life and has even planned all the eents in my life, then I have no control over my life.
theone86
It's an contradiction that is based on the assumption that free-will is random and unpredictable. I havn't seen anyone prove that.
[QUOTE="theone86"]
Also, one final footnote, I have heard a lot of very smart people discuss the contradiction between divine plans and free will, I have yet to see any of them rememdy such a contradiction. If someone knows everything that will happen in my life and has even planned all the eents in my life, then I have no control over my life.
alexside1
It's an contradiction that is based on the assumption that free-will is random and unpredictable. I havn't seen anyone prove that.
No it isn't. It's a contradiction based on the idea that God has some great plan, that he knows everything that every person is going to do ever. If that is true then our lives are pre-determined and free will does not exist, we are merely playing out a role that has been written for us.
Can I just say, it is possible to prove to yourself God exists. Everyone could find out for themselves if they wanted. "Ask and ye shall recieve, knock and it shall be opened unto you."DarkainiousAh, as in my example, you've just said there's an invisible cup cake in front of us with no way to prove it to anyone else but yourself.You can beliee what you want but for this particular belief of yours to be justified/tangible/taken seriously you must have some sort of tangible or emperical evidence to back it up.
I meant "nothing" because it is intabgible. Certainly the "idea" of God exists, but ideas are not tangible. "Nothing" can certainly be a variable, such as "0+1=1", but it has no tangible/empircal value in terms of the question or the answer.Isn't it contractory by calling something nothing?
alexside1
[QUOTE="theone86"]
Also, one final footnote, I have heard a lot of very smart people discuss the contradiction between divine plans and free will, I have yet to see any of them rememdy such a contradiction. If someone knows everything that will happen in my life and has even planned all the eents in my life, then I have no control over my life.
alexside1
It's an contradiction that is based on the assumption that free-will is random and unpredictable. I havn't seen anyone prove that.
I'm sitting here at my desk thinking of doing something. There are different factors influencing my decision, some in favor and some not. A few minutes from now I will decide between one of two options. Yes, there are factors influencing me, but I am still making a conscious choice. Now, if there is a god and he has planned my entire life out, then I am not going to make a conscious choice. I will think I am making a conscious choice, but in reality that choice has been made for me long before I was even born. I think there's a debate as to how free free will actually is, but I don't know how you make the argument that having god plan your life for you allows for as much choice as a deity-free life does.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment