[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]
[QUOTE="blaze_adeel"]Allah is the most merciful to those who believe in Him and his last PROPHET MUHAMMAD (PBUH)Harisemo
I find it amazing how nobody is actually challenging my actual argument... :|
I don't care what the Qur'an says... I am trying to discuss the fact "All-Merciful" (even to those who believe vs. those who don't) contradicts eternal punishment. On top of the fact Allah created the universe as a "muslim" (one who submits to Allah), and everyone in it already is in submission, they just don't realize it. The idea that giving a person one chance at figuring these things out (i.e. a single life) and then punishing them for eternity because they failed to realize (especially if they were never exposed to an Abrahamic religion before) it is logically unsound. If Islam and the Qur'an are "right" and "perfect" then this contradiction wouldn't exist.
there is no contradiction at all mate. God is all merciful and the message is clear. You can't murder someone and expect God to let you go coz he is "All Merciful". God is also just and justice will surely be served. You were already warned what the punishment will be and the merciful God was merciful enough to show you the path and also merciful enough to forgive you if you had asked for forgiveness but you spent your whole life in complete denial. This is not rocket science you're trying to figure out. As for people who were never exposed to Islam, God does not punish those who werent warned. God mentions in Quran there wasnt a single town he destroyed prior to giving them a warning andthose who never recieved the warning will surely be forgiven.
All-Merciful doesnt mean God will be happy with you no matter what you do. I don't see whats so hard to understand here
This is a very common line, and it never makes any sense no matter how many times it's used.
If anyone who was not warned is forgiven, but someone who was warned might not be forgiven, then what is the value in warning someone? If I am not warned, I am guaranteed forgiveness; if I am, then I am not. Why would I prefer to be not guaranteed forgiveness than to be guaranteed forgiveness? By warning someone, you are effectively placing them in danger, danger they would have never been in had you not done so.
Log in to comment