Alan Wake looks better than Unchrted 2 or not ?

No lol.

Alan Wake isn't even the best looking game on 360.

No lol.

Alan Wake isn't even the best looking game on 360.

Chutebox

Then what is?

No lol.

Alan Wake isn't even the best looking game on 360.

Chutebox

when you say something like "next gen dynamic volumetric lighting" you automatically lose. Brainkiller05

[QUOTE="Chutebox"]

No lol.

Alan Wake isn't even the best looking game on 360.

Ravensmash

[QUOTE="Chutebox"]

No lol.

Alan Wake isn't even the best looking game on 360.

Esnedon

Then what is?

no it does not. I am a PS3 fanboy so whatever I say is fact.

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Arach666"]No,Alan Wake looks good but not as good as Uncharted 2.MajorGamer531

How so, when in most aspects like scale, foliage and lighting, Uncharted 2is so far behind ?

Well, i would like some expaination and comment on my post, a well backed up opinion, that is

Foliage? Did you really list foliage? And no Alan Wake's lighting is not better, they are pretty much the same.

UC2 has way higher res and far more detailed environmental texturing.

Yes, why ? Because Uncharted 2 has nearly none, and what it has looks plastic, should never be mentioned ?

I mean you would not mention foliage as a Crysis perk ? Really ?

Uncharted 2 looks better, but not by a huge margin imo.

[QUOTE="MajorGamer531"]

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

How so, when in most aspects like scale, foliage and lighting, Uncharted 2is so far behind ?

Well, i would like some expaination and comment on my post, a well backed up opinion, that is

theseekar

Foliage? Did you really list foliage? And no Alan Wake's lighting is not better, they are pretty much the same.

UC2 has way higher res and far more detailed environmental texturing.

Yes, why ? Because Uncharted 2 has nearly none, and what it has looks plastic, should never be mentioned ?

I mean you would not mention foliage as a Crysis perk ? Really ?

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="MajorGamer531"]

Foliage? Did you really list foliage? And no Alan Wake's lighting is not better, they are pretty much the same.

UC2 has way higher res and far more detailed environmental texturing.

Zero_epyon

Yes, why ? Because Uncharted 2 has nearly none, and what it has looks plastic, should never be mentioned ?

I mean you would not mention foliage as a Crysis perk ? Really ?

Yes, i like the best lighting, scale and real forests more than just crisper resolution and textures, but with vastly smaller places like coriddors, no dynamic volumetric lgithing and almost zero foliage and no real forests at all

As i have already said, none of these games can be called graphics king, simply because both have ups and downs, and is up to each of us decide what is more important

For me Alan Wake perks are the most important by far and i like the art a lot better too

I felt like Alan Wake did a fantastic job of covering its technical shortcomings and ended up looking great. Uncharted 2 just looks fantastic. Little things like high res textures and vsync go a long way.

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

Yes, why ? Because Uncharted 2 has nearly none, and what it has looks plastic, should never be mentioned ?

I mean you would not mention foliage as a Crysis perk ? Really ?

theseekar

Yes, i like the best lighting, scale and real forests more than just crisper resolution and textures, but with vastly smaller places like coriddors, no dynamic volumetric lgithing and almost zero foliage and no real forests at all

As i have already said, none of these games can be called graphics king, simply because both have ups and downs, and is up to each of us decide what is more important

For me Alan Wake perks are the most important by far and i like the art a lot better too

This is getting anoying. Uncharted 2 is far more open then corridors (village lvs anyone). The only ppl who claim this havent played. Also Kevin-v Already commented in sw saying alan wakes graphics were mehRespawn-d

1. Link ?

2. Who on earth is Kevn-V, and why his opinion would ever be above my own two eyes and simple facts directly proven from videos i have posted

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"]This is getting anoying. Uncharted 2 is far more open then corridors (village lvs anyone). The only ppl who claim this havent played. Also Kevin-v Already commented in sw saying alan wakes graphics were mehtheseekar

1. Link ?

2. Who on earth is Kevn-V, and why his opinion would ever be above my own two eyes and simple facts directly proven from videos i have posted

[QUOTE="MajorGamer531"]

Foliage? Did you really list foliage? And no Alan Wake's lighting is not better, they are pretty much the same.

UC2 has way higher res and far more detailed environmental texturing.

Yes, why ? Because Uncharted 2 has nearly none, and what it has looks plastic, should never be mentioned ?

I mean you would not mention foliage as a Crysis perk ? Really ?

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"]This is getting anoying. Uncharted 2 is far more open then corridors (village lvs anyone). The only ppl who claim this havent played. Also Kevin-v Already commented in sw saying alan wakes graphics were mehtheseekar

1. Link ?

2. Who on earth is Kevn-V, and why his opinion would ever be above my own two eyes and simple facts directly proven from videos i have posted

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"] Interesting since you ignore alan wakes blurry, low res, poorly animated gameplay but boast it's lighting and foliage and claim ownage.Respawn-d

Yes, i like the best lighting, scale and real forests more than just crisper resolution and textures, but with vastly smaller places like coriddors, no dynamic volumetric lgithing and almost zero foliage and no real forests at all

As i have already said, none of these games can be called graphics king, simply because both have ups and downs, and is up to each of us decide what is more important

For me Alan Wake perks are the most important by far and i like the art a lot better too

This is getting anoying. Uncharted 2 is far more open then corridors (village lvs anyone). The only ppl who claim this havent played. Also Kevin-v Already commented in sw saying alan wakes graphics were mehRespawn-d

Ok then, post a Uncharted 2 video that shows a PLAYABLE area more open and big then the below

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

Lets see who has played both games, and who has not

You dont understand how big and open AW is or how detailed and thick forests are, that is why you think my U2 comments are off

Well, watch the videos above and post one from U2 then, not on rails, actual playable and walkable / explorable areas, not running on a rail with a train for exmaple

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"]This is getting anoying. Uncharted 2 is far more open then corridors (village lvs anyone). The only ppl who claim this havent played. Also Kevin-v Already commented in sw saying alan wakes graphics were mehtheseekar

1. Link ?

2. Who on earth is Kevn-V, and why his opinion would ever be above my own two eyes and simple facts directly proven from videos i have posted

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

Yes, why ? Because Uncharted 2 has nearly none, and what it has looks plastic, should never be mentioned ?

I mean you would not mention foliage as a Crysis perk ? Really ?

xscrapzx

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"]This is getting anoying. Uncharted 2 is far more open then corridors (village lvs anyone). The only ppl who claim this havent played. Also Kevin-v Already commented in sw saying alan wakes graphics were mehZero_epyon

1. Link ?

2. Who on earth is Kevn-V, and why his opinion would ever be above my own two eyes and simple facts directly proven from videos i have posted

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"]This is getting anoying. Uncharted 2 is far more open then corridors (village lvs anyone). The only ppl who claim this havent played. Also Kevin-v Already commented in sw saying alan wakes graphics were mehZero_epyon

1. Link ?

2. Who on earth is Kevn-V, and why his opinion would ever be above my own two eyes and simple facts directly proven from videos i have posted

Here is a video showing part of the area.

Link

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"]This is getting anoying. Uncharted 2 is far more open then corridors (village lvs anyone). The only ppl who claim this havent played. Also Kevin-v Already commented in sw saying alan wakes graphics were mehZero_epyon

1. Link ?

2. Who on earth is Kevn-V, and why his opinion would ever be above my own two eyes and simple facts directly proven from videos i have posted

Yes, i know, but that is not a big open area, again you walk in tiny paths, and see only a tiny portion of the thing at once

Plus the scale is not even close to AW biggest places

Ok guys time to end this madness

Yeahh last gen lighting right :roll:

You have never played this game TC

TC you are the only one saying this. AW is a great looking game but it doesn't look better than Uncharted 2. You sound like a broken record in your comments going on about foliage. I'll take better textures, animations, physics, and character models over volumetric lighting and foliage any day. This reminds me of the one time pansola tried to argue that bc MW2 looks slightly better on 360 and using one line in a GT's review about level detail that MW2 looks better than KZ2 and Uncharted 2 and that therefore 360 has graphics king is oh so powerful and it went on for pages and everyone just laughed at him. Is that you in there pansola?

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

1. Link ?

2. Who on earth is Kevn-V, and why his opinion would ever be above my own two eyes and simple facts directly proven from videos i have posted

theseekar

Yes, i know, but that is not a big open area, again you walk in tiny paths, and see only a tiny portion of the thing at once

Plus the scale is not even close to AW biggest places

[QUOTE="xscrapzx"][QUOTE="Zero_epyon"] Interesting since you ignore alan wakes blurry, low res, poorly animated gameplay but boast it's lighting and foliage and claim ownage.Zero_epyon

I would definitely not say poor, since I played both back to back, but UC2's is better.

Lol...no. UC2 looks far better than Alan Wake.

TC you are the only one saying this. AW is a great looking game but it doesn't look better than Uncharted 2. You sound like a broken record in your comments going on about foliage. I'll take better textures, animations, physics, and character models over volumetric lighting and foliage any day. This reminds me of the one time pansola tried to argue that bc MW2 looks slightly better on 360 and using one line in a GT's review about level detail that MW2 looks better than KZ2 and Uncharted 2 and that therefore 360 has graphics king is oh so powerful and it went on for pages and everyone just laughed at him. Is that you in there pansola?

jyoung312

Yes, of course, like i would take foliage, weather effects, physics, huge scale, open places and lighting over some crisper textures/resolution of U2 anyday

That is called having an opinion, and everyone has one

This is a multiplayer map:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h18xSnpPbyk

[QUOTE="jyoung312"]

TC you are the only one saying this. AW is a great looking game but it doesn't look better than Uncharted 2. You sound like a broken record in your comments going on about foliage. I'll take better textures, animations, physics, and character models over volumetric lighting and foliage any day. This reminds me of the one time pansola tried to argue that bc MW2 looks slightly better on 360 and using one line in a GT's review about level detail that MW2 looks better than KZ2 and Uncharted 2 and that therefore 360 has graphics king is oh so powerful and it went on for pages and everyone just laughed at him. Is that you in there pansola?

theseekar

Yes, of course, like i would take foliage, weather effects, physics, huge scale, open placesand lighting over some crisper textures/resolution of U2anyday

That is called having an opinion, and everyone has one

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

1. Link ?

2. Who on earth is Kevn-V, and why his opinion would ever be above my own two eyes and simple facts directly proven from videos i have posted

theseekar

Yes, i know, but that is not a big open area, again you walk in tiny paths, and see only a tiny portion of the thing at once

Plus the scale is not even close to AW biggest places

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="jyoung312"]

TC you are the only one saying this. AW is a great looking game but it doesn't look better than Uncharted 2. You sound like a broken record in your comments going on about foliage. I'll take better textures, animations, physics, and character models over volumetric lighting and foliage any day. This reminds me of the one time pansola tried to argue that bc MW2 looks slightly better on 360 and using one line in a GT's review about level detail that MW2 looks better than KZ2 and Uncharted 2 and that therefore 360 has graphics king is oh so powerful and it went on for pages and everyone just laughed at him. Is that you in there pansola?

Respawn-d

Yes, of course, like i would take foliage, weather effects, physics, huge scale, open placesand lighting over some crisper textures/resolution of U2anyday

That is called having an opinion, and everyone has one

Sorr, but Uncharted 2 has almost zero foliage, no real forests, no huge weather effects on foliage, no dynamic volumetric lighting, and tiny tiny scale and places, extremely limited and closed comparing to AW that packs some vast open areas

Alan Wake

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

.

Uncharted 2

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hztQX3xgZMo

.
.

Ok, now compare the scale, open world and actual playable area possibilities in both
Uncharted 2 is sitll in a tiny place, by your very own video

Ifthat is the biggest Uncharted 2 place, then Alan Wake is 100x bigger and more open by the above videos

Again, besides the farm can you provide an example of this "vast and widely open" gameplay from alan wake that's 100X bigger than UC2?Zero_epyon

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related(after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DlH1yvVMYMg&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aj1CB-1ZYPw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFxpHvlPi1g&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oAc9WsGstUc&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GGubLxgL1Ec
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lp0-5rE4JqY&feature=related

If I see the word foliage again in this thread...

[QUOTE="jyoung312"] [QUOTE="Respawn-d"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="jyoung312"]

TC you are the only one saying this. AW is a great looking game but it doesn't look better than Uncharted 2. You sound like a broken record in your comments going on about foliage. I'll take better textures, animations, physics, and character models over volumetric lighting and foliage any day. This reminds me of the one time pansola tried to argue that bc MW2 looks slightly better on 360 and using one line in a GT's review about level detail that MW2 looks better than KZ2 and Uncharted 2 and that therefore 360 has graphics king is oh so powerful and it went on for pages and everyone just laughed at him. Is that you in there pansola?

theseekar

Yes, of course, like i would take foliage, weather effects, physics, huge scale, open placesand lighting over some crisper textures/resolution of U2anyday

That is called having an opinion, and everyone has one

If I see the word foliage again in this thread...

BigBoss154

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="jyoung312"] [QUOTE="Respawn-d"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

Yes, of course, like i would take foliage, weather effects, physics, huge scale, open placesand lighting over some crisper textures/resolution of U2anyday

That is called having an opinion, and everyone has one

Zero_epyon

I have played Uncharted 2, the real problem is that most people here have not played Alan Wake, because they dont have a 360

[QUOTE="jyoung312"]

TC you are the only one saying this. AW is a great looking game but it doesn't look better than Uncharted 2. You sound like a broken record in your comments going on about foliage. I'll take better textures, animations, physics, and character models over volumetric lighting and foliage any day. This reminds me of the one time pansola tried to argue that bc MW2 looks slightly better on 360 and using one line in a GT's review about level detail that MW2 looks better than KZ2 and Uncharted 2 and that therefore 360 has graphics king is oh so powerful and it went on for pages and everyone just laughed at him. Is that you in there pansola?

theseekar

Yes, of course, like i would take foliage, weather effects, physics, huge scale, open places and lighting over some crisper textures/resolution of U2 anyday

That is called having an opinion, and everyone has one

Come on guys Alan Wake is a very good looking game but Uncharted 2 looks better.

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

Yes, of course, like i would take foliage, weather effects, physics, huge scale, open placesand lighting over some crisper textures/resolution of U2anyday

That is called having an opinion, and everyone has one

theseekar

Sorr, but Uncharted 2 has almost zero foliage, no real forests, no huge weather effects on foliage, no dynamic volumetric lighting, and tiny tiny scale and places, extremely limited and closed comparing to AW that packs some vast open areas

Alan Wake

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

.

Uncharted 2

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hztQX3xgZMo

.
.

Ok, now compare the scale, open world and actual playable area possibilities in both
Uncharted 2 is sitll in a tiny place, by your very own video

Ifthat is the biggest Uncharted 2 place, then Alan Wake is 100x bigger and more open by the above videos

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"]

[QUOTE="theseekar"] I would rather have all of the above. Its called uncharted2theseekar

I have played Uncharted 2, the real problem is that most people here have not played Alan Wake, because they dont have a 360