Alan Wake looks better than Unchrted 2 or not ?

I have played Uncharted 2, the real problem is that most people here have not played Alan Wake, because they dont have a 360

theseekar

i've played both...you can check my gamertag or psn id if you like. its always nice to display them, as it provides instant proof of games i've played (something which you have yet to provide). alan wake looks nice, but i certainly wouldn't put it above uncharted 2. in all honesty, i would place assassin's creed 2 above AW. its far more open world, and i think it packs better visuals.

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"] Ha! He's never played UC2. This thread, although entertaining, needs to die already.

Zero_epyon

I have played Uncharted 2, the real problem is that most people here have not played Alan Wake, because they dont have a 360

Ok, but that is just your opinion

The problem is that some people here try to suggest Uncharted 2 looks better overall and in general, which is rather funny, because has tiny scale comparing, no forests and no dynamic volumetric lighting

The very second lv in the game has Drake running tho tropical forests. Respawn-d

You call some roots painted on the ground and some leaves and tree trucks stuckaround the tiny paths wallsa ..... forest ?

Well, play Alan Wake, to see how a real forest is, forests are usually a bit more open than tiny tiny coriddors

Sorr, but Uncharted 2 has almost zero foliage, no real forests, no huge weather effects on foliagetheseekar

Ifthat is the biggest Uncharted 2 placetheseekar

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

I have played Uncharted 2, the real problem is that most people here have not played Alan Wake, because they dont have a 360

theseekar

Ok, but that is just your opinion

The problem is that some people here try to suggest Uncharted 2 looks better overall and in general, which is rather funny, because has tiny scale comparing, no forests and no dynamic volumetric lighting

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

I have played Uncharted 2, the real problem is that most people here have not played Alan Wake, because they dont have a 360

theseekar

Ok, but that is just your opinion

The problem is that some people here try to suggest Uncharted 2 looks better overall and in general, which is rather funny, because has tiny scale comparing, no forests and no dynamic volumetric lighting

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

Sorr, but Uncharted 2 has almost zero foliage, no real forests, no huge weather effects on foliageshinrabanshou

Ifthat is the biggest Uncharted 2 placetheseekar

I mean in his opinion, when i played Uncharted 2, i always felt like i was playing in a tiny coriddor thatsome times open to a tiny room, that is all

The train areas were totally on rails too

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

I have played Uncharted 2, the real problem is that most people here have not played Alan Wake, because they dont have a 360

theseekar

Ok, but that is just your opinion

The problem is that some people here try to suggest Uncharted 2 looks better overall and in general, which is rather funny, because has tiny scale comparing, no forests and no dynamic volumetric lighting

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"] Well I've played both. On the same Tv with the same resolution. UC2 wins.Respawn-d

Ok, but that is just your opinion

The problem is that some people here try to suggest Uncharted 2 looks better overall and in general, which is rather funny, because has tiny scale comparing, no forests and no dynamic volumetric lighting

You call some roots painted on the ground and some leaves and tree trucks stuck around the tiny paths walls a ..... forest ?

Well, play Alan Wake, to see how a real forest is, forests are usually a bit more open than tiny tiny coriddors and pack real foliage, not a tree per mile and walls everywhere

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

[QUOTE="theseekar"]You have a disturbing paraphilia for teh foliage.

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

Ifthat is the biggest Uncharted 2 placetheseekar

I mean in his opinion, when i played Uncharted 2, i always felt like i was playing in a tiny coriddor thatsome times open to a tiny room, that is all

The train areas were totally on rails too

You should learn the actual definition of on-rails.

I think this may come in useful for the TC for identifying all the different foliage types in Alan Wake.

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"] Well I've played both. On the same Tv with the same resolution. UC2 wins.Zero_epyon

Ok, but that is just your opinion

The problem is that some people here try to suggest Uncharted 2 looks better overall and in general, which is rather funny, because has tiny scale comparing, no forests and no dynamic volumetric lighting

GOW3 is as confined and tiny in places as Uncharted 2, you are on a path, always

In fact GOW3 feels a bit more restricted even, the only area i think was a bit big was the place the kings held the chain, but that was just a bigger room, like the puzzle room with the waterfalls

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

Ok, but that is just your opinion

The problem is that some people here try to suggest Uncharted 2 looks better overall and in general, which is rather funny, because has tiny scale comparing, no forests and no dynamic volumetric lighting

theseekar

You call some roots painted on the ground and some leaves and tree trucks stuck around the tiny paths walls a ..... forest ?

Well, play Alan Wake, to see how a real forest is, forests are usually a bit more open than tiny tiny coriddors and pack real foliage, not a tree per mile and walls everywhere

Haha wow I go to bed and the wake up to the same thread but with 300 more replies telling him he's wrong.

Thread of the year anyone?

Haha wow I go to bed and the wake up to the same thread but with 300 more replies telling him he's wrong.

Thread of the year anyone?

Gxgear

Haha wow I go to bed and the wake up to the same thread but with 300 more replies telling him he's wrong.

Thread of the year anyone?

Gxgear

Yes, 300 posts

but none that actually proves why Uncharted 2 would be better

Especially since it has tiny scale, and no volumtric dynamic lighting or thick real forests

(not Uncharted 2 tiny paths with walls and a "forest" pinned around, as some call it)

[QUOTE="Gxgear"]

Haha wow I go to bed and the wake up to the same thread but with 300 more replies telling him he's wrong.

Thread of the year anyone?

Zero_epyon

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="Gxgear"]

Haha wow I go to bed and the wake up to the same thread but with 300 more replies telling him he's wrong.

Thread of the year anyone?

jyoung312

Crysis has forests and make it the best looking game around (adding to the scale and volumtric lighting of course, which things Alan Wake also use)

So, what is your point ?

[QUOTE="jyoung312"][QUOTE="Zero_epyon"] In the running.theseekar

Crysis has forests and make it the best looking game around (adding to the scale and volumtric lighting of course, Alan Wake also use)

so this has forests and foliage http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfpEOmWBCcQ&feature=related does that make it graphics king and better than uncharted 2

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

Ok, but that is just your opinion

The problem is that some people here try to suggest Uncharted 2 looks better overall and in general, which is rather funny, because has tiny scale comparing, no forests and no dynamic volumetric lighting

theseekar

You call some roots painted on the ground and some leaves and tree trucks stuck around the tiny paths walls a ..... forest ?

Well, play Alan Wake, to see how a real forest is, forests are usually a bit more open than tiny tiny coriddors and pack real foliage, not a tree per mile and walls everywhere

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"] Would you stop saying Uncharted2 has no forests. The Second lv of the game takes place in tropical forest. Respawn-d

You call some roots painted on the ground and some leaves and tree trucks stuck around the tiny paths walls a ..... forest ?

Well, play Alan Wake, to see how a real forest is, forests are usually a bit more open than tiny tiny coriddors and pack real foliage, not a tree per mile and walls everywhere

I honestly cant wait to hear the excuses that erupt from seekar's mouth when KZ3 (with confirmed 10x larger environments) comes out.nervmeister

10x the KZ2 areas, would still make it about Uncharted 2 size, KZ2 is one of the most limited in space games i have ever played, definatly a lot worst than U2

[QUOTE="nervmeister"]I honestly cant wait to hear the excuses that erupt from seekar's mouth when KZ3 (with confirmed 10x larger environments) comes out.theseekar

10x the KZ2 areas, would still make it about Uncharted 2 size, KZ2 is one of the most limited in space games i have ever played, definatly a lot worst than U2

Yes, 300 posts

but none that actually proves why Uncharted 2 would be better

Especially since it has tiny scale, and no volumtric dynamic lighting or thick real forests

(not Uncharted 2 tiny paths with walls and a "forest" pinned around, as some call it)

theseekar

I'll quote it for your benefit.

Look, Mr Seeker, we can all see that no matter what anyone says, that you wont change your opinion. You have already made up your mind, much like other people here have made up their minds and wont change.

-

HERE IS THE ISSUE:

The VAST MAJORITY says: UC2 is the better looking game.

The TINY MINORITY says: Alan Wake is the better looking game.

Do you really think that you can turn the tides, in this place, by talking about such simple things as "apparent openness" and "foilage"?

-

ALAN WAKE is not an open-world game. It has big environments in select places... otherwise you are stuck to a narrow path.

UNCHARTED 2 is not an open-world game. It has big environments in fewer select places... otherwise you are stuck to a narrow path.

-

ALAN WAKE is a one-trick pony. The entire game is set in the same setting, with VERY LITTLE deviation from the norm. It honestly gets boring, visually, seeing the same thing for the 12 hours it takes to finish.

UNCHARTED 2 delivers in a vast array of different environments. Snow, jungle, cities, villages, trains, temples, caves and other landmarks. It looks incredible in each location.

-

You like to talk about foilage, great:

ALAN WAKE has nice foilage, SOME of which is interactive, as you have shown in videos.

UNCHARTED 2 has nice foilage,when the environment calls for it, SOME (but less) is interactive:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6KehMGb9i50

-

ALAN WAKE has awkward animations in both gameplay, and (more noticeably) in cut-scenes. It sometimes gets to the point that its unintentionally funny.

UNCHARTED 2 has great, procedural animations throughout.

-

ALAN WAKE uses volumetric lighting, which looks better at night than at day.

UNCHARTED 2 uses dynamic lighting that looks good in both dark places and bright:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pfGop3t9f9Y

-

ALAN WAKE has low resolution textures in majority.

UNCHARTED 2 has high resolution textures in majority.

-

ALAN WAKE has average character models.

UNCHARTED 2 has excellent character models.

-

ALAN WAKE features prominent screen tearing

UNCHARTED 2 has no tearing.

-

ALAN WAKE is at 540p

UNCHARTED 2 is at 720p

-

What else is there to comment on other than that you will NEVER change your mind regardless... posting this was probably the biggest waste of my time anyway.

RockyNando

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

You call some roots painted on the ground and some leaves and tree trucks stuck around the tiny paths walls a ..... forest ?

Well, play Alan Wake, to see how a real forest is, forests are usually a bit more open than tiny tiny coriddors and pack real foliage, not a tree per mile and walls everywhere

Zero_epyon

[QUOTE="nervmeister"]I honestly cant wait to hear the excuses that erupt from seekar's mouth when KZ3 (with confirmed 10x larger environments) comes out.theseekar

10x the KZ2 areas, would still make it about Uncharted 2 size, KZ2 is one of the most limited in space games i have ever played, definatly a lot worst than U2

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"] Would you stop saying Uncharted2 has no forests. The Second lv of the game takes place in tropical forest. Respawn-d

You call some roots painted on the ground and some leaves and tree trucks stuck around the tiny paths walls a ..... forest ?

Well, play Alan Wake, to see how a real forest is, forests are usually a bit more open than tiny tiny coriddors and pack real foliage, not a tree per mile and walls everywhere

So, can you prove Uncharted 2 has real forests ? Go ahead then, post a video

Here is AW

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

theseekar

you have an internet connection...it would take you five minutes to create a PSN id and put this to rest.

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

You call some roots painted on the ground and some leaves and tree trucks stuck around the tiny paths walls a ..... forest ?

Well, play Alan Wake, to see how a real forest is, forests are usually a bit more open than tiny tiny coriddors and pack real foliage, not a tree per mile and walls everywhere

theseekar

So, can you prove Uncharted 2 has real forests ? Go ahead then, post a video

Here is AW

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

You call some roots painted on the ground and some leaves and tree trucks stuck around the tiny paths walls a ..... forest ?

Well, play Alan Wake, to see how a real forest is, forests are usually a bit more open than tiny tiny coriddors and pack real foliage, not a tree per mile and walls everywhere

theseekar

So, can you prove Uncharted 2 has real forests ? Go ahead then, post a video

Here is AW

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"] You clrealy havent even touched uncharted 2. If you have state your psn id and Ill do a searchRespawn-d

So, can you prove Uncharted 2 has real forests ? Go ahead then, post a video

Here is AW

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"] You clrealy havent even touched uncharted 2. If you have state your psn id and Ill do a searchjyoung312

So, can you prove Uncharted 2 has real forests ? Go ahead then, post a video

Here is AW

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

?

I though you were joking

Haze has a billion times worst graphics, lighting and less detailed foliagethan Alan Wake, and is still in closed spaces, imagine that

Try Crysis, it has huge foliage like Alan Wake, huge scale like Alan Wake and dynamic volumetric next gen lighting like Alan Wake

You mean Haze looks better than Crysis now ? Well, good luck with that !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[QUOTE="jyoung312"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

So, can you prove Uncharted 2 has real forests ? Go ahead then, post a video

Here is AW

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

theseekar

?

I though you were joking

Haze has a billion times worst graphics than Alan Wake, and is still in closed spaces, imagine that

Try Crysis, it has huge foliage like Alan Wake, huge scale like Alan Wake and dynamic volumetric next gen lighting like Alan Wake

You mean Haze looks better than Crysis now ? Well, good luck with that !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"] You clrealy havent even touched uncharted 2. If you have state your psn id and Ill do a searchRespawn-d

So, can you prove Uncharted 2 has real forests ? Go ahead then, post a video

Here is AW

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

?

I though you were joking

Haze has a billion times worst graphics, lighting and less detailed foliagethan Alan Wake, and is still in closed spaces, imagine that

Try Crysis, it has huge foliage like Alan Wake, huge scale like Alan Wake and dynamic volumetric next gen lighting like Alan Wake

You mean Haze looks better than Crysis now ? Well, good luck with that !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

theseekar

Yeah, good luck with that.

[QUOTE="Respawn-d"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

So, can you prove Uncharted 2 has real forests ? Go ahead then, post a video

Here is AW

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

Zero_epyon

I dont own Uncharted 2, i only own Demon Soul, NG Sigma and FF13, i only rent so short games and i dont generally go crazy over simplistic shooters

But i do have the trophies, some of them anyway, still would be too much connecting my PS3 just because you want proof i have one, it is extremely silly

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

?

I though you were joking

Haze has a billion times worst graphics, lighting and less detailed foliagethan Alan Wake, and is still in closed spaces, imagine that

Try Crysis, it has huge foliage like Alan Wake, huge scale like Alan Wake and dynamic volumetric next gen lighting like Alan Wake

You mean Haze looks better than Crysis now ? Well, good luck with that !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

shinrabanshou

Yeah, good luck with that.

Its effects, lighting, scale and foliage are the closest thing you can get on consoles by miles

Never said it looks as good as Crysis on a super PC though, you said that

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="Respawn-d"] You never play online.................. :roll: You have never taken the time to connect you gaming system to a FREE service that offers demos, online play, ect. theseekar

I dont own Uncharted 2, i only own Demon Soul, NG Sigma and FF13, i only rent so short games and i dont generally go crazy over simplistic shooters

But i do have the trophies, some of them anyway, still would be too much connecting my PS3 just because you want proof i have one, it is extremely silly

I would love to see proof TC has played these games. Chances are we'll be waiting a *long* time for it.

Real shame, as it would put any debate to rest about TC actually playing the game he's criticizing.

TC could simply create a PSN ID and the trophies should sync right to it.

[QUOTE="jyoung312"][QUOTE="theseekar"]

So, can you prove Uncharted 2 has real forests ? Go ahead then, post a video

Here is AW

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOBN04saU4I&feature=related- (after 1:30 minute)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAM_gx5qH8g&feature=related

I never play online, so my PS3 is not connected or have a PSN id

theseekar

?

I though you were joking

Haze has a billion times worst graphics, lighting and less detailed foliagethan Alan Wake, and is still in closed spaces, imagine that

Try Crysis, it has huge foliage like Alan Wake, huge scale like Alan Wake and dynamic volumetric next gen lighting like Alan Wake

You mean Haze looks better than Crysis now ? Well, good luck with that !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[QUOTE="theseekar"]

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"] You know even if he's not lying he could easily create one and pop the game in for 10 secs.Sollet

I dont own Uncharted 2, i only own Demon Soul, NG Sigma and FF13, i only rent so short games and i dont generally go crazy over simplistic shooters

But i do have the trophies, some of them anyway, still would be too much connecting my PS3 just because you want proof i have one, it is extremely silly

I dont know, seeker is my name when i enter PS3 menu, if that is what you mean, but since i never connect PS3, how could the trophy data be on the net ?

[QUOTE="Zero_epyon"][QUOTE="Respawn-d"] You never play online.................. :roll: You have never taken the time to connect you gaming system to a FREE service that offers demos, online play, ect. theseekar

I dont own Uncharted 2, i only own Demon Soul, NG Sigma and FF13, i only rent so short games and i dont generally go crazy over simplistic shooters

But i do have the trophies, some of them anyway, still would be too much connecting my PS3 just because you want proof i have one, it is extremely silly

I would love to see proof TC has played these games. Chances are we'll be waiting a *long* time for it.

Real shame, as it would put any debate to rest about TC actually playing the game he's criticizing.