Battle of the Sky Games: Skyward Sword vs. Skyrim, which will be better?

Oblivion beats all current Zelda games.Robbazking

:lol:

Wish I could say Zelda but I don't have much faith. I have a feeling its going to continue the N64 feel of TP. While Skyrim is going to be bigger and better in just about every way. I won't miss Zelda for anything, I have no doubt it will still be a very fun, very polished game, but the glory days of Zelda could be over...locopatho

You disgrace your avatar! :x lol :P....seriously though...:|

[QUOTE="locopatho"]Wish I could say Zelda but I don't have much faith. I have a feeling its going to continue the N64 feel of TP. While Skyrim is going to be bigger and better in just about every way. I won't miss Zelda for anything, I have no doubt it will still be a very fun, very polished game, but the glory days of Zelda could be over...NaveedLife

You disgrace your avatar! :x lol :P....seriously though...:|

[QUOTE="locopatho"]Wish I could say Zelda but I don't have much faith. I have a feeling its going to continue the N64 feel of TP. While Skyrim is going to be bigger and better in just about every way. I won't miss Zelda for anything, I have no doubt it will still be a very fun, very polished game, but the glory days of Zelda could be over...Shinobishyguy

[QUOTE="Heil68"][QUOTE="charizard1605"] You *know* it isn't entirely out of the question 8)Arach666

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"]

[QUOTE="locopatho"]Wish I could say Zelda but I don't have much faith. I have a feeling its going to continue the N64 feel of TP. While Skyrim is going to be bigger and better in just about every way. I won't miss Zelda for anything, I have no doubt it will still be a very fun, very polished game, but the glory days of Zelda could be over...locopatho

[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"]Is this becasue it's on the wii?

Shinobishyguy

skyrim, never liked zelda, never will

da_illest101

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="locopatho"] Indirectly.locopatho

[QUOTE="locopatho"]

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"] So the wii's incapable of making a masterpiece of a game...Shinobishyguy

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="locopatho"] Don't know who said that, certainly wasn't me :)

locopatho

A skyward sword is like only good for enemies that jump, and I don't know about rimming the sky... I suppose I'd take the sword.

haven't we had this thread a couple times already over the last few months? Zelda sure doesn't seem to command alot of respect around here. But maybe it never did?

Can't wait until the end of this year when Skyward Swords owns the lot of ya :D

(i have faith!)

Zelda sure doesn't seem to command alot of respect around here. But maybe it never did?

Can't wait until the end of this year when Skyward Swords owns the lot of ya :D

(i have faith!)

blahzor

Zelda just won greatest game franchise on SW, so I'm sure people here like it.

I think Zelda has this one.

[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"] thats kind of what it sounds like you're implying. Because it's on the wii it's incapable to ever being a masterpiece.Shinobishyguy

Skyward sword will be 90% rehash from older Zelda games and will still score higher because everyone overrates zelda games despite the fact that its aged. Skyrim will still be the better game though.

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"]

[QUOTE="locopatho"] Well its good I set you straight then isn't it?locopatho

Who cares, when's the next Dynasty Warriors coming out? :P

My opinion is biased seeing as i havent played a zelda game nor do i plan to, but yeah my vote goes for Skyrim. Dante2710

Why would you not give them a chance? That is just a strange attitude to have. I gave Halo a chance, turns out its pretty fun and is one of few games I miss my 360 for. I gave the MGS series a chance (just played them over a year ago for the first itme) and its one of my favorite series out there. I suggest you do the same for what is my favorite seires of all time.

Skyrim, Elder Scrolls is one of my favorite series

Skyrim by far. I am getting tired of all the Nintendo franchises.

[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"] So what is it going to take for Skyward sword to impress? Should they just scrap it all together and start work on Zelda for Project cafe?

Shinobishyguy

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="locopatho"] I don't know what you talking about, I'm always happy to talk about Zelda but not to defend or explain stuff I didn't say :Plocopatho

I don't understand how someone can rip on Zelda for still being a free roaming world with dungeons and such with similar combat, when TES is going to be a big world, with leveling and similar combat and such. I mean they both are adding to the series but neither are breaking from their confines that much. Nor should they, for the most part. Zelda has always had a great style, and while they could throw in some interesting things and change stuff up a bit, I hope they never go to far from its roots.

I don't understand how someone can rip on Zelda for still being a free roaming world with dungeons and such with similar combat, when TES is going to be a big world, with leveling and similar combat and such. I mean they both are adding to the series but neither are breaking from their confines that much. Nor should they, for the most part. Zelda has always had a great style, and while they could throw in some interesting things and change stuff up a bit, I hope they never go to far from its roots.

NaveedLife

And I don't understand how people misunderstand me so much when I talk about Zelda... :?

Im a fan like ....

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="locopatho"] I don't know what you talking about, I'm always happy to talk about Zelda but not to defend or explain stuff I didn't say :Plocopatho

Isn't this the same company that made SMG2 so magical?

Skyrim looks incredible so far. Skyward Sword isn't really that impressive from what has been shown.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

I don't understand how someone can rip on Zelda for still being a free roaming world with dungeons and such with similar combat, when TES is going to be a big world, with leveling and similar combat and such. I mean they both are adding to the series but neither are breaking from their confines that much. Nor should they, for the most part. Zelda has always had a great style, and while they could throw in some interesting things and change stuff up a bit, I hope they never go to far from its roots.

locopatho

And I don't understand how people misunderstand me so much when I talk about Zelda... :?

Im a fan like ....

lol well please help me understand! :P

The way I see it, is that you are mad that Zelda has not undergone some radical change, but neither has many series, including TES with Skyrim.

The games are not similar. I will buy and enjoy both, for different reasons.

[QUOTE="blahzor"]

Zelda sure doesn't seem to command alot of respect around here. But maybe it never did?

Can't wait until the end of this year when Skyward Swords owns the lot of ya :D

(i have faith!)

Thefatness16

Zelda just won greatest game franchise on SW, so I'm sure people here like it.

Skyrim baby! Skyrim has dragons and screaming vikings, and radiant storytelling. Radiant storytelling > blonde person in green outfit running around with a sword that has something to do with the sky.

Skyrim looks incredible so far. Skyward Sword isn't really that impressive from what has been shown.

Big_Pecks

When did Nintendo say Miyamoto was "heavily involved"?

AmayaPapaya

Also check this interview, good info about how they came to making the game, they say Miyamoto is the one who said to use WM+.

lol well please help me understand! :P

The way I see it, is that you are mad that Zelda has not undergone some radical change, but neither has many series, including TES with Skyrim.

NaveedLife

I want the core Zelda design to stay the same, but to get bigger better and more bad ass! (to quote Cliffy B :P)

I want Hyrule to be massive, tons of NPCs and sidequests and exploration (like Oblivion) not small and sterile and N64ish like TP.

I want cities and villages to be big. Assassin's Creed has spoiled me here, but at least bigger then a couple of enterable buildings on a couple of screens...

I want tons of enemies wandering about, like Dead Rising or what have you. How about SEEING Ganon's giant armies instead of just hearing about them!?

I want more items, weapons, magic, horses and whatnot. More hidden treasure and secrets and just funny wacky stuff: Oblivion, you can find a dead goblin under a bridge with loads of wine bottles and a suicide note! Or make poison out of plants, coat arrows in it and hunt deer, then sell the meat. Or find a spell taht allows you to walk on water and run about on lakes. Just random fun variety and interactivity.

Not really for Wii, but ideally HD graphics, orchestra surround sound, top quality voice acting would be good.

Dungeons are fine, core design is fine, story is fine, just scale everything the **** up and stop reminding me of Ocarina in the worst possible way!

Thats my Zelda rant, I hope you enjoyed it, though you probably disagree as does everyone else ever :P

Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword vs The Elder Scrolls Skyrim

>Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword

>Legend of Zelda.

Skyward Sword, by far.

skyward sword will be better by a country mile.