[QUOTE="Hoobinator"]But according to Vandal that sort of criticism and a low score means the reviewer misunderstood the game entirely. He's basically dismissing wholesale valid criticism and refuses to acknoeledge that people could see Too Human as effectively a flawed game.
subrosian
Since when have Vandal and I been the same person :| ?
Most of the negative reviews simply said "bad controls" or "bad camera", or "I died a lot". Many of them even said negative things about Mr. Dyack himself, which is frankly more than a little concerning when these same reviewers later claim to be more "credible" than the people who've actually beaten the game. The GS video review, for example, had broken armor pieces flashing red... if they knew that meant "broken" they would have repaired their gear.
Chances are they missed that, which does raise the point that they "didn't get it". I think it's more than fair to call Too Human misunderstood - to say that one audience will really enjoy it, while a casual player will find themselves facing a difficult game with a steep learning curve, one where how they are playing is not going to be in line with why the fans enjoy it.
Hell, the same could be said of Ikaruga - it's difficult, and it's about mastery rather than completion - but I wouldn't call Ikaruga a bad game. Of course, Ikaruga has fewer technical flaws than Too Human, and has a tutorial :P. But please, I've asked you nicely twice already - DO NOT make a judgment on what *I say* based on what *someone else* says. My opinions have rarely if ever been accurately represented by others.
I never called you Vandal.:| I was merely clarifying what me and Vandal are arguing about, that is all. And like I said right from the very first post 'TO VANDAL' was that some of the reviews were mistaken in parts. I agreed with that from the off. So don't try to make me understand any mistakes, I know them full well after spending seven hours constantly barraged with them.
OK, we'll stop talking now in this thread, since everytime I post a reply to you, you seem to think I'm putting what Vandal says into your mouth. Not true.
Log in to comment