GameSpot Bayonetta Review 9.0 (360) 8.0 (PS3) - Keep it here or face suspension

meaning both versions are very high quality games.IronBass

[QUOTE="Wasdie"]

[QUOTE="Idream2010"]

why?

carlisledavid79

I'm actually also going to ask you why as well there carlisledavid76. This is one of those rare cases where graphical bugs and horrible preformance takes away fro the overall quality of the game. I don't know why you would willingly buy the version that is going to feel a lot less finished and less of a game.

90% of multiplats a few graphical hicups here and there aren't anything to worry about, but I've seen the differences myself. The game in areas looks completely different than the 360 version and the framerate is just horrible. For an action title this is really going to detract from the experiance.

if thats the case, rent the pS3 version and see if you can tolerate it.

So in a nutshell, I guess this means I get the 360 version over the PS3 one..

[QUOTE="IronBass"] meaning both versions are very high quality games.aaronmullan

Yet you bashed the 360 version of Dragon Age and praised the PS3 version.

Hmm, why the change in tune? Oh yes, it's been the 360 version is superior here and by a whole point, not a half of one.

i have been a reader for awhile, and I do know that if this was the other way around you would see this thread about doubled and alot more fireworks. I give Lemmings credit for that.

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"] What some people here aren't exactly getting.aaronmullan

Yet you bashed the 360 version of Dragon Age and praised the PS3 version.

Hmm, why the change in tune? Oh yes, it's been the 360 version is superior here and by a whole point, not a half of one.

I don't remember you sticking up for the 8.5 Dragon Age, so why do it with the 8.0 Bayonetta? Hmm...

Nevermind, I know. ;)

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"] What some people here aren't exactly getting.aaronmullan

Yet you bashed the 360 version of Dragon Age and praised the PS3 version.

Hmm, why the change in tune? Oh yes, it's been the 360 version is superior here and by a whole point, not a half of one.

well this more though, the other only had a .5 difference. this a Whole point.

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"] Nope. I said that DA:O on the 360 was the inferior version and it was so inferior it needed a score difference. Same thing here, son. No change in tune here, boyo.BioShockOwnz

I don't remember you sticking up for the 8.5 Dragon Age, so why do it with the 8.0 Bayonetta? Hmm...

Nevermind, I know. ;)

Also

Nevermind, I know. ;)

BioShockOwnz

Teh conspiracy :o

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

Yet you bashed the 360 version of Dragon Age and praised the PS3 version.

Hmm, why the change in tune? Oh yes, it's been the 360 version is superior here and by a whole point, not a half of one.

Idream2010

well this more though, the other only had a .5 difference. this a Whole point.

[QUOTE="Idream2010"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"] Nope. I said that DA:O on the 360 was the inferior version and it was so inferior it needed a score difference. Same thing here, son. No change in tune here, boyo.aaronmullan

well this more though, the other only had a .5 difference. this a Whole point.

well not as great indeed as dragon age

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"][QUOTE="Idream2010"]

well this more though, the other only had a .5 difference. this a Whole point.

Idream2010

well not as great indeed as dragon age

[QUOTE="Idream2010"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"] Indeed. But it still got AA. AA = Great the last time I checked :Paaronmullan

well not as great indeed as dragon age

I can see now why Bioshockownz made his post about you now.

i have been a reader for awhile, and I do know that if this was the other way around you would see this thread about doubled and alot more fireworks. I give Lemmings credit for that.

Idream2010

[QUOTE="Idream2010"]

i have been a reader for awhile, and I do know that if this was the other way around you would see this thread about doubled and alot more fireworks. I give Lemmings credit for that.

CanYouDiglt

yep it is what it is. Lems deserve credit here.

[QUOTE="Idream2010"]

i have been a reader for awhile, and I do know that if this was the other way around you would see this thread about doubled and alot more fireworks. I give Lemmings credit for that.

Wait, did Gamespot change the PS3 review from 8.5 to 8.0 after publishing?! Lol, professional.

Didn't Sony state that they were going to help to try to fix the problems? I guess it wasn't enough and I guess the next time Sony says they're going to help out on other multiplats with problems, it might not mean much.

[QUOTE="Idream2010"]

i have been a reader for awhile, and I do know that if this was the other way around you would see this thread about doubled and alot more fireworks. I give Lemmings credit for that.

Wait, did Gamespot change the PS3 review from 8.5 to 8.0 after publishing?! Lol, professional.

dommeus

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"][QUOTE="Idream2010"]

well not as great indeed as dragon age

Idream2010

I can see now why Bioshockownz made his post about you now.

Didn't Sony state that they were going to help to try to fix the problems? I guess it wasn't enough and I guess the next time Sony says they're going to help out on other multiplats with problems, it might not mean much.

gago-gago

[QUOTE="Idream2010"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"] Two different genres, so you can't really compare.aaronmullan

I can see now why Bioshockownz made his post about you now.

you are right, of course.

[QUOTE="dommeus"]

Wait, did Gamespot change the PS3 review from 8.5 to 8.0 after publishing?! Lol, professional.

Giancar

[QUOTE="Giancar"][QUOTE="dommeus"]

Wait, did Gamespot change the PS3 review from 8.5 to 8.0 after publishing?! Lol, professional.

dommeus

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]

I don't remember you sticking up for the 8.5 Dragon Age, so why do it with the 8.0 Bayonetta? Hmm...

Nevermind, I know. ;)

Also

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

Nevermind, I know. ;)

Teh conspiracy :o

Who here hasn't had a typo in something they were writing up? It happens.

It was far more important for GS to correct the mistake, to make sure the posting matched the reviewers intended score as soon as possible, then to let it slide and just say, "well, its not like anybody would know". Covering up the mistake by pretending it wasn't, would be the far worse breach of professional ethics, than simply making a mistake. Mistakes happen in any professional environement and things are kept professional by correcting them as soon as possible, and to make sure the report says what it was originally intended to.

again completely impressed with Lemmings, maybe 2010 will be a softer kinder gentler year.

I think everyone saw this coming, 360 seems to really be the version to get if you have both consoles and no preference in controllers.

As someone who regularly rails on cows, I do have to say that lemmings are really not inherently more "mature". They are just not obsessively brand loyal in the utterly bizzare super-extreme way that cows are (sheep were once like this, but they've mellowed out). Cows are just in their brand loyalty meltdown phase right now (again, sheep most liely were once like this). It has nothing to do with them as people. It has more to do with their situation. The fall from dominance was brutal and it alienates them to see the tables turned, causing massive damage (points to anybody who can figure out where that phrase comes from) to the collective fanboy pysche and thus they seem to act more "extreme". Lemmings might very well act the same way in the future if they develop the same amount of brand loyalty over time.

E3 2006 Sony Press Conference...ahhh good times, good times.

The best action game(for now) of this gen is upon us.:Djg4xchamp

the game looks great, plays hreat (PS3 demo speaking) but it's a button smashing game, i dun get it the ppl who are prasing the game combos....etc while you can button smash all ur enemies till the end of the demo.

[QUOTE="dsmccracken"][QUOTE="CanYouDiglt"]I did get a little curious about that and Dragons Age review. It is interesting to see the difference and these games are not that far apart. That review got up to 51 page long.

Giancar

[QUOTE="CanYouDiglt"]

[QUOTE="Idream2010"]

i have been a reader for awhile, and I do know that if this was the other way around you would see this thread about doubled and alot more fireworks. I give Lemmings credit for that.

Idream2010

yep it is what it is. Lems deserve credit here.

Wait are you saying lems didint overreact to the score of DA:O? If so then where were you.

the game looks great, plays hreat (PS3 demo speaking) but it's a button smashing game, i dun get it the ppl who are prasing the game combos....etc while you can button smash all ur enemies till the end of the demo.

2mrw

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="ChartTopper93"]

lemmings are typically more mature than cows. you might see some cows come in whining but i doubt there will be an all out offensive on cows by lemmings. except the extreme ones.

mythrol

Yea guess you missed all those threads when the famitsu review came out about the bad ps3 version. Its pretty tame now since the bash fest has already happend.

if this game got aaa then gow3 should easily get aaaa.

if this game got aaa then gow3 should easily get aaaa.

ZoomZoom2490

my questiton is What happened to the good old days of, "hey everyone isn't this game awesome lets all enjoy it" Instead we get "MAN VERISON PWNS YOURS LAWLS SAUCE"

if this game got aaa then gow3 should easily get aaaa.

ZoomZoom2490

That's not really how it works.

Wait are you saying lems didint overreact to the score of DA:O? If so then where were you.

finalfantasy94

if this game got aaa then gow3 should easily get aaaa.

ZoomZoom2490

If GOW3 got 9.5, where Beyonetta got 9.0 on 360, that would be sufficiently higher a score. Why does it "have" to get AAAA now? :|

But then I would expect this from the same guy who believes GT5 "will" score 10, just because FM3 scored 9.5 :roll:

If GOW3 got 9.5, where Beyonetta got 9.0 on 360, that would be sufficiently higher a score. Why does it "have" to get AAAA now? :|

AdobeArtist