I call bullshit. There is no way they cut down the Xbox One version like this. I'm not even kidding when I say I bet Sony's cash went into that downgrade. There is no way a bit of a better GPU would draw that much more foliage for the same scene. Xbox One could handle more than that. That said, things like foliage aren't CPU bound like NPC's are. And GTA 5 won't be anywhere near as CPU intensive as AC Unity. This could be the GPU advantage at work. But that seems a bit spiteful on Rockstars part imo.
Uniform memory addressing allows for texture streaming to be very efficient if properly coded for.
I call bullshit. Just watched a comparison video. Outside of some lighting differences (that XBox One black issue), they look the same. If there was a big difference like what is shown above, I have not seen it (i went through 5 pages of google search results on "grand theft auto 5 ps4 vs Xbox one").
I call bullshit. There is no way they cut down the Xbox One version like this. I'm not even kidding when I say I bet Sony's cash went into that downgrade. There is no way a bit of a better GPU would draw that much more foliage for the same scene. Xbox One could handle more than that. That said, things like foliage aren't CPU bound like NPC's are. And GTA 5 won't be anywhere near as CPU intensive as AC Unity. This could be the GPU advantage at work. But that seems a bit spiteful on Rockstars part imo.
Is simple since the xbox one version is not shooting for 900p the GPU at 1080p is doing to much already,so the elements were scale back in order to make the game 1080p 30 FPS alto it has some drops as well in the frame rate area and lents flare appear to be missing or pull back on XBO,the game is GPU bound so there are some trade off.
I call bullshit. Just watched a comparison video. Outside of some lighting differences (that XBox One black issue), they look the same. If there was a big difference like what is shown above, I have not seen it (i went through 5 pages of google search results on "grand theft auto 5 ps4 vs Xbox one").
LMFAO! There are literally no scenes with significant foliage in any of that video.
There is still no confirmation. I looked at comparison videos and they look identicle. True there is no foliage in those comparisons, probably for those reasons lol.
That is from a poster who has both versions of the game,on neogaf if you invent stuff like that you get permaban...
@kinectthedots said:
Is there a digital Foundry opinion on any of this yet?
Not that i know off and if it real and they are covering it,it would explode on their face..hahaha
If this is true, that is a huge difference. If I pick it up for a next gen console, it'll be PS4. Most likely waiting for the PC version so i can have fun wit the mods.
Not only does the Xbone version lack the foliage, but the ground textures are horrible and the lighting/shadows are much worse. Xbone is a garbage system confirmed, even though I'd say that was confirmed a year ago.
Not only does the Xbone version lack the foliage, but the ground textures are horrible and the lighting/shadows are much worse. Xbone is a garbage system confirmed, even though I'd say that was confirmed a year ago.
Log in to comment