*Pachter mode* Halo Reach will have a stronger opening (USA + shooter), GT5 will sell better over time (EU + Racing Sim).
This topic is locked from further discussion.
*Pachter mode* Halo Reach will have a stronger opening (USA + shooter), GT5 will sell better over time (EU + Racing Sim).
[QUOTE="Ultizer"]
quote me
"GT5 will outsell Halo reach and any 360 exclusive by the end of 2010"
unless GT5 gets delayed to december... or 2011
with no piracy on PS3, it should pull amazing sales, outselling Reach
btw i dont care about scores anymore, if a mario rehash with last gen graphics gets a 10, i just dont care.
COD Doesnt count its multi-plat, nintendo doesnt count either, this is between current gen consoles, 360 vs PS3, Wii is a lastgen console.
siddhu33
Dead Heat.
Piracy doesn't matter, most Reach fans bought Halo 3, and that sold 11 million, with half the 360's userbase.
Heck, ODST, a 60$ Expansion, sold 5.5 million copies!
GT fans already bought Prologue, so don't give me that excuse.
Also, Reach has one more month than GT5, so more sales are kinda guaranteed.
Add that with the ridiculous amount of marketing that MS will do for this game (It is their biggest game of this year), and that will makea lot of copies.
The only reason so many people bought it was because that was the first good game that came out for XBOX users..
[QUOTE="siddhu33"]
[QUOTE="Ultizer"]
quote me
"GT5 will outsell Halo reach and any 360 exclusive by the end of 2010"
unless GT5 gets delayed to december... or 2011
with no piracy on PS3, it should pull amazing sales, outselling Reach
btw i dont care about scores anymore, if a mario rehash with last gen graphics gets a 10, i just dont care.
COD Doesnt count its multi-plat, nintendo doesnt count either, this is between current gen consoles, 360 vs PS3, Wii is a lastgen console.
P-vs-P
Dead Heat.
Piracy doesn't matter, most Reach fans bought Halo 3, and that sold 11 million, with half the 360's userbase.
Heck, ODST, a 60$ Expansion, sold 5.5 million copies!
GT fans already bought Prologue, so don't give me that excuse.
Also, Reach has one more month than GT5, so more sales are kinda guaranteed.
Add that with the ridiculous amount of marketing that MS will do for this game (It is their biggest game of this year), and that will makea lot of copies.
The only reason so many people bought it was because that was the first good game that came out for XBOX users..
Yeah, so Gears of War and Oblivion didn't exist?
Rubbish excuse!
w/e you guys
it will outsell reach
PS3 will be 37-38m install base when GT5 comes out
GT5 will pull 8-9m by the end of 2010
reach will pull below 7m by the end of 2010
ODST didnt even reach 6m
i think more 360 gamers Like MW/COD more then halo now
Ultizer
You're trolling now. We both know that is impossible for GT, so you're merely doing this for attention.
I'd be pleasantly surprised if GT5 surpasses 3 million this year.
[QUOTE="penumbra13"]
Sorry, but a racing game will not beat Microsoft's flagship fps unless it is Mario Kart.
Ultizer
Mario kart sold 2x more as halo 3 dude
i guess that makes it better?
no i didnt think so....
mario kart is good yes, its a fun game, but halo 3 is much better, MUCH better
Wii has also sold three or four times more than the 360.
Quoting and bookmarking. But atleast let the game come out first. And you think every game on the 360 is pirated? Huh, even without piracy, KZ2 and UC2 only sold about half as much as Halo 3 did combined ;)quote me
"GT5 will outsell Halo reach and any 360 exclusive by the end of 2010"
unless GT5 gets delayed to december... or 2011
with no piracy on PS3, it should pull amazing sales, outselling Reach
btw i dont care about scores anymore, if a mario rehash with last gen graphics gets a 10, i just dont care.
COD Doesnt count its multi-plat, nintendo doesnt count either, this is between current gen consoles, 360 vs PS3, Wii is a lastgen console.
Ultizer
If GT5 doesnt have enough interest to garner a midnight release (which i doubt it will) than it has no chance outselling reach.bigboss5akgamestop pays $3.95 an hour and free rentals. at this point they can midnight release two worlds 2 and it not cost them anything in overhead.
LOL halo 3 sells more than 10 millions copies gears of war sells more than 5 millions and there is no ps3 exclusive that have come close to that numbers so the probability is totally zero
narog84
Your mathematical reasoning is absolute fail.
You can't be serious! A sim racer will out sell Halo Reach. I just don't see that happening. Now if you are saying that this will be the best PS3 exclusive WW ,yes. For record I don't even like Halo but I'm not going todisrepect the obvious sales monster that Halo is. It might not be the most creative game but it definitely sells to the casual and hard core gaming crowd. I won't by Halo but it is obvious a lot more people will buy that than GT5.
Im a cow but I dont understand the sales hype behind GT5, I think it will sell well, but I dont think it will sell 10 million copys the first month like every thinksRTUUMM
Hasn't EVERY full fledged Grand Turismo game sold 10 million? (not counting PSP or GT5 Prologue). Gran Turismo is easily the best selling Sony Playstation franchise all time.
I'm sure it won't come close to 10million in it's first month (wouldn't that be some sort of record?). But GT5 Prologue was the only one that didn't sell 10 million during it's lifespan, and it still sold 5million even when PS3 had almost no market saturation. I think it's realistic for GT5 to outsell Halo. Although it could really go either way. Based on hype I would say Halo:Reach should probably outsell it. I've already seen adds for Halo Reach in movie theaters and whatnot, Gran Turismo just got announced with a release date and there hasn't been any marketing campaign started yet, so probably not as much hype other than the people that have been DYING for the game for 2 years.
I don't really care. I'm definitely getting GT5 and probably getting a 360 just for Reach, Gears of War 3, and Alan Wake. I figure that finally 360 has enough exclusives it's worth getting it to go along with my PS3 and Wii.
If GT5 flops in sales and scores, it will most likely result in the biggest backlash since the Twilight Princess review.
You can't be serious! A sim racer will out sell Halo Reach. I just don't see that happening. Now if you are saying that this will be the best PS3 exclusive WW ,yes. For record I don't even like Halo but I'm not going to miss the obvious monster that Halo is.
3rdbass
Dude. Gran Turismo has always sold 10 million copies for it's "full fledged" releases. The Ps2 games combined for over 25 million copies.
As a franchise Gran Turismo is probably more than double Halo in sales. Even the Gran Turismo Prologue sold 5 million copies when Ps3 barely had any system sales, and it was marketed as a "demo for the full game". Not bad in comparison to Halo 3's 8 million copies when Halo was basically the 360's killer app.
I think both games should easily do 5 million copies, but it's hard to predict either will be massive massive sellers and reach something like 10 million. I see no way that Gran Turismo 5 will come close to it's PS2 sales numbers due to fact PS3 doesn't dominate sales like PS2 did. GT3 did like 15 million for goodness sakes!!!! But considering the sales of GT5 prologue I think it's safe to say that GT5 should do at least the same 5 million sales as the prologue. Anything short of that would be disappointing, but I would guess Sony would be hoping for more like 7+ million as a benchmark.
GT5 comes out on November 2nd in Europe and NA ...... thats excluding Japan which is GT's largest market. Nonstop-MadnessJapan? European market is Gran Turismo's biggest market I thought...
[QUOTE="Modern_Unit"][QUOTE="Zoso-8"] GT3 sold about 15 million though. GT5 could definitely outsell Reach eventually, if not this year. It's one of, (if not the most) anticipated race game(s) of all time. Also, the fact that it has Nascar (the most popular sport in the US), will give it an extra boost.Zoso-8
Good joke i needed a laugh
Feel free to prove me wrong. I'm not saying I agree with racing being a sport either, (I actually hate Nascar) but you can't deny it's popularity. I'm not saying it will outsell Reach, but it does have a chance. Either way I don't care, they will both sell over 10m.Okay, I'll give you three points.1. GT4 sold about 1/3 less than GT3.
2. Three Forza games have come out in the meantime. All have been critically acclaimed. For the first time, GT has serious competition (to copmare, only GT3 scored above a 9).
3. AFAWK, the game's NASCAR mode doesn't support a 43-car grid, so the NASCAR experience is gimped (crowded tracks and three-wides are part of the thrill), and NASCAR fans could be turned off by that fact.
Gran Turismo 5 Prologue sold nearly 5 million copies. GT5P also had 3 release dates. December 2007 in Japan, March 2008 in Europe and April 2008 in NA. When GT5P released in NA, there were 14.2 million PS3's on the market. When GT5 releases in November in NA and Europe, they'll be around 40 million PS3's on the market. GT5 could outsell Halo Reach just with EU and NA sales, excluding Japan.LOL halo 3 sells more than 10 millions copies gears of war sells more than 5 millions and there is no ps3 exclusive that have come close to that numbers so the probability is totally zero
narog84
Use your damn brain. I have all 3 game consoles and I am just stating a fact. Most gamers are not into driving simulation games nor plane simulation games and would rather play modnation/RidgeRacers/NFS series because of the excitement factor. I love driving simulation games and I got Forza3 and waiting for GT5 to release, but face it the majority of gamers would rather escape from realism.MrFamBoyLOL
Sales numbers do not compute.
Gran Turismo is the best selling playstation franchise PERIOD, across all game categories. So if people don't like driving simulators, how did it become the #1 Playstation seller of all time with over 50 million total units sold?
Also Modnation might not reach 1million sales. I wonder if this generations Ridge Racer games on PS3 and 360 even reached 100K sales apiece? Those were not the best examples to prove your point LOL.
LOL halo 3 sells more than 10 millions copies gears of war sells more than 5 millions and there is no ps3 exclusive that have come close to that numbers so the probability is totally zero
narog84
mgs4 at five million
I said "WOULD RATHER" not "ABSOLUTELY" figure out the difference than will talk. You think theirs more Driving Simulation fans than First Person Shooters? LOL Go google "Opinions of Driving Simulation games" and you will find plenty of people who arent interested in those type of games. In fact you will find plenty of people in this thread who thinks driving simulation games are boring compared to other games.MrFamBoyLOL
Again. Look at the sales numbers for the Gran Turismo series. That is real data. A google search trolling the net for "opinions" is not real data, It's not relevant at all. I'm quite sure if I searched for "Halo sucks" I would get plenty of hits as well. But what does that mean towards the sale data? Not a damn thing.
Anyway I'm not arguing it is absolute that GT5 will outsell Reach. I never said that at all (the OP did, I didn't). In fact if I had to guess I would say Reach will probably outsell it (my guess would be total sales Reach: 10 million GT5: 8 million). However it is also foolish to dismiss that possibility for a game that clearly has a history of much, much higher sales than Halo has ever achieved.
i thought the Center for Disease Control had cured Mad Cow disease?
in other News the cast of Jersey Shore will Discover WARP DRIVE, and on that same day the Messiah will return and the Middle East will Declair PEACE.
All of that has a FAR MORE Likely chance to happen than GT5 has of EVER outselling the LOWEST Xbox 360 Exclusive, LET ALONE HALO REACH.
GT5 will be awesome, but lets not get crazy here....
i thought the Center for Disease Control had cured Mad Cow disease?
in other News the cast of Jersey Shore will Discover WARP DRIVE, and on that same day the Messiah will return and the Middle East will Declair PEACE.
All of that has a FAR MORE Likely chance to happen than GT5 has of EVER outselling the LOWEST Xbox 360 Exclusive, LET ALONE HALO REACH.
GT5 will be awesome, but lets not get crazy here....
bryn8150
LOL. Even the "lowest exclusive", huh? Lets try this. Please list all the exclusives that outsold GT5:Prologue, even though that was merely a glorified demo for the epicness that will be Gran Turismo 5.
I'll give you a hint. The list is only 3 games long.
Im not just talking about GT5 in general dumbass, im talking about Racing Simulators in general. Driving simulation is not a very popular genre compared to FPS.MrFamBoyLOL
Then you are posting in the wrong thread. Seriously, before calling me "dumbass" read the thread title. Read my posts. Try to follow along. I know it's difficult for you.
"2Chalupas" said LOL. Even the "lowest exclusive", huh? Lets try this. Please list all the exclusives that outsold GT5:Prologue, even though that was merely a glorified demo for the epicness that will be Gran Turismo 5.
I'll give you a hint. The list is only 3 games long. halo 3, gears of war 3, left for dead 2, mass effect . gears of war 2 , fable 2 we could do this ALL day if youd like?
[QUOTE="MrFamBoyLOL"]Use your damn brain. I have all 3 game consoles and I am just stating a fact. Most gamers are not into driving simulation games nor plane simulation games and would rather play modnation/RidgeRacers/NFS series because of the excitement factor. I love driving simulation games and I got Forza3 and waiting for GT5 to release, but face it the majority of gamers would rather escape from realism.2Chalupas
Sales numbers do not compute.
Gran Turismo is the best selling playstation franchise PERIOD, across all game categories. So if people don't like driving simulators, how did it become the #1 Playstation seller of all time with over 50 million total units sold?
Also Modnation might not reach 1million sales. I wonder if this generations Ridge Racer games on PS3 and 360 even reached 100K sales apiece? Those were not the best examples to prove your point LOL.
Maybe it was because GT3 was packed into PS2's just as the console's sales took off like a rocket. A telling sign is what happened to its sequel, GT4, just about in every way better than GT3, and there were lots more PS2's on the market...sold 1/3 less.That's hardly three games. And didn't ODST crack 5 mil also? Forza 3's pretty close, too, last I heard (around 4 mil)."2Chalupas" said LOL. Even the "lowest exclusive", huh? Lets try this. Please list all the exclusives that outsold GT5:Prologue, even though that was merely a glorified demo for the epicness that will be Gran Turismo 5.
I'll give you a hint. The list is only 3 games long. halo 3, gears of war 3, left for dead 2, mass effect . gears of war 2 , fable 2 we could do this ALL day if youd like?
bryn8150
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment