Halo 3 is not a very mature game... which is why it doesn't appeal to me

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for ChrisSpartan117
ChrisSpartan117

4519

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#201 ChrisSpartan117
Member since 2008 • 4519 Posts

[QUOTE="angelkimne"]

[QUOTE="Tragic_Kingdom7"]

BioShock's storyline makes Halo's look silly. Halo's storyline is about on par with Killzone 2.

II-FBIsniper-II

I can safely say having completed both Halo has a FAR better story. The epic soundtrack and top quality voice actors don't hurt either. :) I mean you're free to disagree, but still..... :|

If anything I'd say Halo's story is massively underrated here, it's probably my favourite in an FPS this gen so far (par The Orange Box of course), though I haven't played Bioshock as of yet.

As a halo fan, Bioshock's story and presentation is a million times better than Halo 3's.

I just beat the game myself, and we need more games with stories like BioShock. And yes, I'm a hardcore Halo fan, but BioShock is better than any of the Halo's.

Avatar image for ManicAce
ManicAce

3267

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 26

User Lists: 0

#202 ManicAce
Member since 2009 • 3267 Posts
TC has some valid points, if you don't feel related to the story or characters it's a definite flaw in my eyes. But I'm not sure where the "maturity" comes to play, who cares, videogames in general aren't very mature, and why should they be, they are toys of sort afterall. And being mature doesn't mean much in the way of quality or enjoyment, the kind of crap my "mature" parents watch on tv I wouldn't touch with a ten feet pole, I'll take Simpsons over Dancing With The Stars any day.
Avatar image for VoodooHak
VoodooHak

15989

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 0

#203 VoodooHak
Member since 2002 • 15989 Posts

[QUOTE="VoodooHak"]

It's the basis of this whole thread, so yes, defining "mature" is entirely relevant.

As the one making the initial claim, the onus is upon you to define the parameters of your argument.

SquatsAreAwesom

Here is the thing. Something being mature is completely relative, and based on opinion. As such, defining mature on this context is not as clearcut as you make it out to be. This thread was not an attempt at labeling the game one way or another, but for me to give my opinions on the matter and to see what other's thought about the game in this respect.

Of course it's relative. But you ask for opinions and reasons behind those opinions. Yet, you provide little reasons of your own.

So I will lead by example since you failed to do so.

For me, maturity in terms of games is employing concepts and mechanics that can only be grasped through the accumulation of experience.

I don't think Halo tried to be mature. It tried to be a good game with gameplay that fit the narrative. The narrative itself contains religious allusions as well as humanism vs deism themes. Mind you, no one's going to write a book about Halo's philosophical underpinnings, but they are concepts that wouldn't resonate with someone who hasn't at least read about them.

Without that context, the game mechanics become rote.

Speaking of mechanics, there are layers to the multiplayer that allow pick-up-and-play ease, but is hard to master. Some multiplayer games types require a level or coordination and tactics that would be alien to anyone that hasn't played the game for very long.

So yes, Halo can be a mature game on literary and gameplay levels. At the same time, Halo is still inviting to anyone with enough fine motor skills to manipulate the controller (which is a physiological maturity in itself).

Avatar image for hockeyruler12
hockeyruler12

8114

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 10

User Lists: 0

#204 hockeyruler12
Member since 2005 • 8114 Posts
... in fact, had the swarm won... I would probably would have just LOL'ed. SquatsAreAwesom
ummm....have you really played Halo? the swarm?