Sure, it would be a wake up call for them. Never did I ever say Wasteland 2 would be a commercial success, especially when it's targeting what is increasingly a niche genre. Bioware and Bethesda have ditched RPG roots for big money (one goes third person shooter, the other includes dragons), so obviously it would be incredibly stupid for me to say it's a wake up call if the game is a commercial success.No, I didn't mean, nor will I ever mean it's a wake up call depending on the success of the product. It's a wake up call simply because there are developers making a full-blooded role-playing game, and not only that, people have paid money to have them develop it.FrozenLiquid
Like I said, they don't have to say on the back of the box 'the mother of all roleplaying games'. Don't straw man the argument here. Look at the way Bioware treated SW:TOR like it was the second coming. Look at their videos on Mass Effect 3. Look at how Bethesda described Skryim, pretending to acknowledge the faults of Oblivion but at the same time working on its action-adventure template and saying it's better than anything they've ever done. Now if Bioware don't call their games RPGs anymore, my point is invalid. And in that case, you probably shouldn't even care about it anymore, because if it isn't Bioware's concern about making RPGs anymore, it's probably not yours either.
But then you make a blunder and start saying '...but we really don't know what a RPG is, it could mean anything'. I'm sorry? You said Bioware had the balls to stop calling their games RPGs, and now you want to obscure what constitutes a RPG? Quite spineless of you, Mr. SciFI RPG fan.
Yes, yes, Mass Effect 2 is a better game than Mass Effect 1. But it ditches many RPG conventions. I'm not talking about what is a better game. I'm talking about making the better RPG.
The more I go down your argument the more I see you frame it as a commercial success argument. It's not about commercial success. I really doubt Wasteland 2 will sell more than Mass Effect or an Elder Scrolls game. Like I said, if my argument was based on commercial success, I would have been an idiot.
Lucky for me, it isn't. So go back and do your homework to see what my argument is about.
Log in to comment