Lets settle it: whats the over-all BEST 'Assassins Creed' game?

AC2 one of the best games of last gen

2, and it's not even close

2 is widely considered the best and rightfully so. 

Brotherhood. It has everything II has and is better. 

I guess 2

very closely followed by 3

followed by 1

I didn't really enjoy Brotherhood or Revelations much. 

it's a shame they had to add the stupid modern day storyline, which amounted to nothing basically- they could have spent all that time and effort on the historical parts. 

Probably the first one,it had the best setting as far as Im concerned and was the most immersive one,and it was actually abourt assassinations.Nanomage

Exactly. If they choose to focus on the history of Assassins that would be great but they invented their own stupid alien story.

i think AC2 made the biggest improvements from it's previous iteration than any of the other main titles. I also like the variety in the different cities (rather than brotherhood which all happened in Rome if i recall correctly) and in general i think it was just a more well crafted game. I felt like the genuinely took the time to listen to the fans and make a sequel that improves on the flaws of the original while adding more features and content, and making a story line that was very interesting. Since then they've been releasing it yearly and it's only felt like incremental upgrades and has gotten increasingly bland (i haven't played AC3 yet though). 

I skipped revelations. I havent' finished a single AC game, but I got closest to finishing Brotherhood. Overall I'd say: 

Brohood>2>1>3

i liked 1,2 and revelations.

Brotherhood was the best in my opinion. 2 is not very far behind. The added features is what put brotherhood over the top for me. But overall the series has fell back a bit due to rushing an annual release. They really need to take a creative break if they want to save this series at all, but then again they are already coming out with this year, so that kind of puts a cog in that. The annual releases is what is killing it and they need to really stop, because they are killing one of my favorite franchises this gen. :(

I voted for Ass Creed 2 because of the big changes between it and Ass Creed 1. AC1 is so bad it's not even funny. But personally i liked Brotherhood the most. 

I voted for Ass Creed 2 because of the big changes between it and Ass Creed 1. AC1 is so bad it's not even funny. But personally i liked Brotherhood the most. 

el3m2tigre

AC2.  Brotherhood and Revelations were great, but didn't push the franchise forward like AC2 did.  AC3 was just terrible.

[QUOTE="ToScA-"]

Is III better than I?

mems_1224

[QUOTE="Nanomage"]Probably the first one,it had the best setting as far as Im concerned and was the most immersive one,and it was actually abourt assassinations.zeeshanhaider

Exactly. If they choose to focus on the history of Assassins that would be great but they invented their own stupid alien story.

For me it's:

2>3>Brotherhood>>>>Revelations>1

[QUOTE="mems_1224"][QUOTE="ToScA-"]

Is III better than I?

ToScA-

AC2

It's not even close, 2 was far and away the best AC.

AC2 is one of my favorite games this gen. Blew my expectations.  All the others were good, but nowhere near 2. Revelations was a DLC that was sold as a full retail game and AC3 had way too many cutscenes.

The original, because you actually feel like you're playing as an assassin.

Master_ShakeXXX

2, no contest

1 and Brotherhood got more votes than 3, really ?

Any1 who said Assassins Creed III needs a slap.

[QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"]

The original, because you actually feel like you're playing as an assassin.

DarkLink77

The first one. You actually feel like an assassin and not some pretty boy property manager.Zeviander

Ah...yua eri eweri uf whu yua'ri egriiong woth...roght?

--------------------------

((Uh...you are aware of who you're agreeing with...right?))

I enjoyed Brotherhood the most, but I think that had a lot to do with the fact that I got to play as Raiden for the entire game.

Ah...yua eri eweri uf whu yua'ri egriiong woth...roght?

--------------------------

((Uh...you are aware of who you're agreeing with...right?))

Goyoshi12

And I agree with :the poster formerly known as foxhound_fox" all the time, yo. He is a bro of the highest order.

So... yes, I do.

the 2nd game I guess. followed by brotherhood, followed by the 1st.

dead last is 3.

Any1 who said Assassins Creed III needs a slap.

PCgameruk

[QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"]

The original, because you actually feel like you're playing as an assassin.

DarkLink77

The first one. You actually feel like an assassin and not some pretty boy property manager.Zeviander

i agree, but that game felt so repetitive and tedious. If they had a bit more variety in the missions, or at least scripted them to play out differently each time so they didn't feel like the same thing it would've been way better. I also felt like the story was slow to really proceed at times.

I personally prefer AC2, but i do agree that the first one that they really did try to make it so that you were playing the role of an assassin. 

[QUOTE="PCgameruk"]

Any1 who said Assassins Creed III needs a slap.

Kevlar101

AC2 was by far my best experience with the series. 

[QUOTE="PCgameruk"]

Any1 who said Assassins Creed III needs a slap.

Kevlar101

[QUOTE="Kevlar101"][QUOTE="PCgameruk"]

Any1 who said Assassins Creed III needs a slap.

[QUOTE="PCgameruk"]

[QUOTE="Kevlar101"] Anyone who said Revelations needs a slap..... And I said AC3..... only for gameplay. Its no debate: AC3 has the best gameplay of the series. Its not rough as hell anymore. But for story, AC2 and Brotherhood take the cake.Sushiglutton

IMHO 2 by a landslide.

[QUOTE="PCgameruk"]

[QUOTE="Kevlar101"] Anyone who said Revelations needs a slap..... And I said AC3..... only for gameplay. Its no debate: AC3 has the best gameplay of the series. Its not rough as hell anymore. But for story, AC2 and Brotherhood take the cake.Sushiglutton