[QUOTE="mjarantilla"]My objections are entirely logical. The data you provided does NOT support your arguments except very, very obliquely. So far, your argument about the size of the PC convention and tournament scene depends entirely on the assumption that the total population involved in PC conventions and tournaments equals sum of all those events' attendances. Vandalvideo
Your objections are not entirely relevant, because you haven't supplied any kind of evidence to even begin remotely backing them up. "Of course it makes it LESS social. If the PC is incapable of types of social interaction that are easily accomplished on consoles (especially newer consoles), that makes it LESS social than consoles." One of your original statements. Are you going to continue to deny you said that PC gaming is less social? I totally proved that wrong. End of story.Now who's taking arguments out of context?
Prior to that statement, I made the assertion that: "spontaneous same-room social interaction is only really possible on a console."
You agreed: "Of course, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the PC is any less social."
Given that you agreed to my statement, I drew the next obvious conclusion based on your agreement: That since the PC was incapable of one form of social interaction that consoles performed, while consoles were capable of any forms of social interaction PCs could perform, the console was therefore a more "socially capable system."
Of course, you backpedaled later and then said that PCs actually WERE capable of same-room social interaction. As it turns out, this was the right answer all along, meaning we were both wrong about PCs being incapable of offline multiplayer. Thus, that statement of mine is now no longer valid in any context of the current argument, because it has already been proven wrong by the fact that the original premise (your agreement to my assertion that PCs dont have offline multiplayer) was proven wrong.
You're addressing a long-abandoned parallel argument, which you yourself ended by proving that same-room social interaction was possible on PCs. I conceded that a hundred posts ago.
The CURRENT argument is about whether or not the participation of PC conventions and tournaments balances out the participation in local multiplayer console gaming. We have both made our assertions, but neither of us has provided sufficient data to support our assertions.
Log in to comment