MLB 10 The Show Review AA 8.0 ***Keep all MLB topics here****

http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/sports/mlb10/review.html

Solid score. Thoughts?

funny one con is that the computer batters are super skilled, All my games have been low scoring against the computer and I can strike them out.

but I do agree with other cons.

cows am owned

http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/sports/mlb10/review.html

Solid score. Thoughts?

wow, is that a flop? what was the official hype? navyguy21

the official hype was AAAE it flopped

wow, is that a flop? what was the official hype? navyguy21

I thought it was AA. Anyway I laughed when I was making the title. I had AAE and then I was like "better not stirr something" lol.

I honestly expected AAA, but a great score nonetheless.

Still better than the EA offerings :P

I'm both surprised and not surprised.

I could see this happening, but I don't see why it happened since by most other accounts so far this year's game is an improvement on last year's. It's not really logical.

----

Also their was no official hype.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/sports/mlb10/review.html

Solid score. Thoughts?

Funconsole

And you get to keep your pride. :P

I'm both surprised and not surprised.

I could see this happening, but I don't see why it happened since by most other accounts so far this year's game is an improvement on last year's. It's not really logical.

----

Also their was no official hype.

shinrabanshou

Improving on an old formula doesn't necessarily mean you should score the same. The standards raise with yearly installment games to keep delivering unexpected and excellent features. Being a better game doesn't alway mean deserving a better score.

MLB 10: The Flop?

So I looked at the review and it got the "punishing difficulty" demerit. I think a baseball game would grow extremely boring if every game was a blowout. Plus, the AI has "supernatural batting abilities". Has the reviewer not seen some of the roid junkines in the MLB. They are superhuman

didn't see that coming...lawlessx

Oh wow. I didn't expect that at all. So much for MLB 10 being "so much" superior to MLB 2K10. :PStevo_the_gamer

2K10 360

The Show 10

:/

Gamespot, you're more random than I thought, this was suppose to be a 9.0...

Personally dont care much for the series, or the sport of baseball at all for that matter, but is it just me or is GS cracking down on games?

:lol:Karma at its best. Another PS3 AAE added to the list. :P

Solid score but I'm pretty apathetic on baseball games.

I wonder if PS3 fans are going to campaign for this to be considered an AAE as they campaigned for 09's AAAE status last year. :P

[QUOTE="lawlessx"]didn't see that coming...IppoTenma

Pretty good for releasing the game just one year after the prequel, I wonder where the usual complaints are... you know like Madden every year sucks thing..

You forgot the E at the end ... edit please. As for the score, wow just wow. 8.0 for the best baseball game ever made?? GS is off of the average by a whole point.

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

I'm both surprised and not surprised.

I could see this happening, but I don't see why it happened since by most other accounts so far this year's game is an improvement on last year's. It's not really logical.

----

Also their was no official hype.

ActicEdge

Improving on an old formula doesn't necessarily mean you should score the same. The standards raise with yearly installment games to keep delivering unexpected and excellent features. Being a better game doesn't alway mean deserving a better score.

Damn, and after all that effort on the Cows' part to make it an exclusive. :?

Damn, and after all that effort on the Cows' part to make it an exclusive. :?

Verge_6

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Oh wow. I didn't expect that at all. So much for MLB 10 being "so much" superior to MLB 2K10. :Pshinrabanshou

2K10 360

The Show 10

:/

I didn't say it did. But being a better game usually doesn't mean scoring a point less.

shinrabanshou

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Oh wow. I didn't expect that at all. So much for MLB 10 being "so much" superior to MLB 2K10. :Pshinrabanshou

2K10 360

The Show 10

:/

[QUOTE="Verge_6"]

Damn, and after all that effort on the Cows' part to make it an exclusive. :?

lawlessx

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Oh wow. I didn't expect that at all. So much for MLB 10 being "so much" superior to MLB 2K10. :Pshinrabanshou

2K10 360

The Show 10

:/

Not surprised.

Most sequels score lower than their predecessors. 8.0 is a solid score though.

[QUOTE="Verge_6"]

Damn, and after all that effort on the Cows' part to make it an exclusive. :?

lawlessx

Another AAE is still good though. It's not like it did a WKC flop

What the? lol

Everyone says they improved on everything and it gets a full point lower than last year lol...

Oh well!

[QUOTE="Verge_6"]

Damn, and after all that effort on the Cows' part to make it an exclusive. :?

lawlessx

So chalking up another AAE title to the PS3 Library this year is a "wasted effort"? :? ... System Wars and believing AAAE titles only matter, I'll never get it.

[QUOTE="Funconsole"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/sports/mlb10/review.html

Solid score. Thoughts?

And you get to keep your pride. :P

[QUOTE="lawlessx"][QUOTE="Verge_6"]

Damn, and after all that effort on the Cows' part to make it an exclusive. :?

BPoole96

Another AAE is still good though. It's not like it did a WKC flop

MLB 10: The Flop?

So I looked at the review and it got the "punishing difficulty" demerit. I think a baseball game would grow extremely boring if every game was a blowout. Plus, the AI has "supernatural batting abilities". Has the reviewer not seen some of the roid junkines in the MLB. They are superhuman

BPoole96

[QUOTE="navyguy21"]wow, is that a flop? what was the official hype? dgo71102244

the official hype was AAAE it flopped

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Oh wow. I didn't expect that at all. So much for MLB 10 being "so much" superior to MLB 2K10. :PStevo_the_gamer

2K10 360

The Show 10

:/

[QUOTE="lawlessx"][QUOTE="Verge_6"]

Damn, and after all that effort on the Cows' part to make it an exclusive. :?

W1NGMAN-

So chalking up another AAE title to the PS3 Library this year is a "wasted effort"? :? ... System Wars and believing AAAE titles only matter, I'll never get it.

It's just that it was heavily hyped as the next AAAE for the PS3 is all.

What BS

The game is realistic and realistically enough you can't expect to be playing baseball and just swing the bat and hope to hit:|

This game actually catches the difficulty of reading a pitcher and if anything GOW 3 should swap scores with this