MLB 10 The Show Review AA 8.0 ***Keep all MLB topics here****

Just a reminder on some facts...

GS HYPE: AAA (9.0)

Exclusivity: Yes to Playstation 3

GS SCORE: AA (8.0)

GR SCORE: AAA (9.0)

So here at gamespot MLB 10: The Show is a PS3 AAE and is also a flop.

NVIDIATI

[QUOTE="TheOwnerOner"]

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

Actually it does, since the competition scored lower. Which technically makes MLB 10 The Show the "best baseball game ever"

W1NGMAN-

Then I guess you agree with me that its a flop

MLB 09 got a 9.0

Even the PSP version scored higher

HAHAHA ... so MLB 08 The Show > MLB 10 The Show, right?? HAHA ... how hard is it for people to understand how GS conducts their reviews?

09 not 08 I even game you a link

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]

Just a reminder on some facts...

GS HYPE: AAA (9.0)

Exclusivity: Yes to Playstation 3

GS SCORE: AA (8.0)

GR SCORE: AAA (9.0)

So here at gamespot MLB 10: The Show is a PS3 AAE and is also a flop.

FIipMode

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"][QUOTE="liberty71441"]

funny think is that all coments in that topic are AAAE sounda to me like someone is voting with its alt account to make it seem like a AA hype.

liberty71441

you might be right, but since we dont have factual evidence with the poll, we might just focus with the comments since they are the only reliable thing in that topic, since no one else have another evidence, lets not forget chutebox AKA the biggest cow in SW brought the link to this topic.

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

[QUOTE="TheOwnerOner"]

Then I guess you agree with me that its a flop

MLB 09 got a 9.0

Even the PSP version scored higher

TheOwnerOner

HAHAHA ... so MLB 08 The Show > MLB 10 The Show, right?? HAHA ... how hard is it for people to understand how GS conducts their reviews?

09 not 08 I even game you a link

I know but MLB 08 The Show out scored it as well ... haha, I see you're not understanding my point :lol:

Dangit even though the DC is getting funny in here I gotta go workout ... I'll have my copy of MLB 10 The Show Friday, hope to see you guys online soon.

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="lawlessx"] notice the AA votes are also growing :roll:lawlessx

[QUOTE="TheOwnerOner"]

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

HAHAHA ... so MLB 08 The Show > MLB 10 The Show, right?? HAHA ... how hard is it for people to understand how GS conducts their reviews?

W1NGMAN-

09 not 08 I even game you a link

I know but MLB 08 The Show out scored it as well ... haha, I see you're not understanding my point :lol:

If u compare it to soccer, tennis, or football; baseball is not really very demanding physically. The level required, the speed that u play at, is quite different from the sports I just mentioned. Even some professional baseball players have bellys, do u think that's very athletic? I don't think so.

GiveMeSomething

if its so easy can you pick up a bat and send a ball flying at you 85 mph+ over 400ft for a homerun let alone actually swing and make contact?

I mean, since its not that all physically demanding and all (which isn't all you need to play a sport)

can you win a million dollars on it????? if not its epic fail and should get a 1 imo

lets not forget chutebox AKA the biggest cow in SW brought the link to this topic.liberty71441

[QUOTE="FIipMode"][QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]

Just a reminder on some facts...

GS HYPE: AAA (9.0)

Exclusivity: Yes to Playstation 3

GS SCORE: AA (8.0)

GR SCORE: AAA (9.0)

So here at gamespot MLB 10: The Show is a PS3 AAE and is also a flop.

xsubtownerx

[QUOTE="GiveMeSomething"]

If u compare it to soccer, tennis, or football; baseball is not really very demanding physically. The level required, the speed that u play at, is quite different from the sports I just mentioned. Even some professional baseball players have bellys, do u think that's very athletic? I don't think so.

DanteSuikoden

if its so easy can you pick up a bat and send a ball flying at you 85 mph+ over 400ft for a homerun let alone actually swing and make contact?

I mean, since its not that all physically demanding and all (which isn't all you need to play a sport)

Baseball is not as physically demanding as say football or soccer.....HOWEVER, in terms of technique and so forth it is the MOST demanding. You're trying to hit a round object with another round object......its mystifying. Also, as so famously quoted..... "Baseball is the only sport where a man can succeed three times out of ten and be considered a good performer." Think about it....the average MAJOR LEAGUE baseball player gets a hit about 26% of the time they step into the box.....and these guys are leaps and bounds beyond the guys who are stuck in the minor leagues for all eternity. Baseball is a hard sport, anyone who thinks otherwise is a fool......and thats just from the batters end. Try throwing a 95MPH fastball, followed by a changeup at 84MPH, followed by a 12" breaking curveball, followed by a two seam fastball......all from 60 feet away from the plate, and the plate is a mere 17" wide. Again, Ridiculous to fathom the amount of technique necessary to do this regularly.

Now in regards to the game...I owned 09, and I bought 10 on day 1. This game IS better than 09 and it blows my mind that GS has this only .5 higher than 2K10. Metacritic proves that point.

[QUOTE="liberty71441"] You calling another person a fanboy, Come on :lol: and he is a PS fan...Giancar

I believe it was Stevo ..

[QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

Official hype was clearly AAA. What reason would there be to hype it any less?

Stevo_the_gamer

He's the biggest Cow I know.

[QUOTE="FIipMode"][QUOTE="xsubtownerx"] Says who?xsubtownerx

It was hyped AA in the thread that was linked, but due to manipulation, now that poll got ruined.

Either way, if we throw out the hype thread completely, then we got a game that wasn't hyped at all.

Still, why would we let cheaters win? Why would we throw out a perfectly good thread made in Early Feb due to some guys here messing with the poll?

[QUOTE="DanteSuikoden"]

if its so easy can you pick up a bat and send a ball flying at you 85 mph+ over 400ft for a homerun let alone actually swing and make contact?

I mean, since its not that all physically demanding and all (which isn't all you need to play a sport)

Uptown

Baseball is not as physically demanding as say football or soccer.....HOWEVER, in terms of technique and so forth it is the MOST demanding. You're trying to hit a round object with another round object......its mystifying. Also, as so famously quoted..... "Baseball is the only sport where a man can succeed three times out of ten and be considered a good performer." Think about it....the average MAJOR LEAGUE baseball player gets a hit about 26% of the time they step into the box.....and these guys are leaps and bounds beyond the guys who are stuck in the minor leagues for all eternity. Baseball is a hard sport, anyone who thinks otherwise is a fool......and thats just from the batters end. Try throwing a 95MPH fastball, followed by a changeup at 84MPH, followed by a 12" breaking curveball, followed by a two seam fastball......all from 60 feet away from the plate, and the plate is a mere 17" wide. Again, Ridiculous to fathom the amount of technique necessary to do this regularly.

Thanks for explaining my last point more in depth:P

lol. ouch and after so much effort was put in by cows to make this an exclusivenaval

Lets just outline this real quick. Tangible evidence of AA hype:

-Previously mentioned thread

-Poll

Tangible evidence of AAA hype:

-Some unseen posts

However, one could reasonably argue the thread for AA hype wasn't official. And it goes without saying that 'I saw some posts saying AAAE' means absolutely nothing as well. Which leaves us with utterly nothing. No hype. Without hype there cannot be a flop. So lets review. We can only have two scenarios here, due to evidence:

-AA Hype

-No Hype

Either scenario dictates the game isn't a flop. Pick whichever tickles your fancy but thats all we have to go on. So until there's some amazingly convincing evidence to the contrary can we call it a night and consider this....

...Not A Flop

[QUOTE="xsubtownerx"][QUOTE="FIipMode"] Everything is right except for the flop part, it isn't one.FIipMode

Wow the game was definitelyhyped AAAE... I love how hype changes when a game flops... Makes me want to ROFL :)

What happened to all those When GoW3 and MLB10 come out the PS3 will have more AAAE games? I guess they don't exist right?

Anyways 8.0 is a great score... I don't plan on buying it because i don't like baseball. Also with FF13, Pokemon Heart Gold and Soul Silver, and God of War 3 ill have no moneys.

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"]Well, nobody really CAN say what people were thinking this would get, officially anyway. Which means there's nothing to go on.Stevo_the_gamer

HHAHAHAHAHA and all that arguing the cows wer doing saying how mlb 10 is ps3 exclusive. LMAO, k cows you can have this game haha what a flop

Lets just outline this real quick. Tangible evidence of AA hype:

-Previously mentioned thread

-Poll

Tangible evidence of AAA hype:

-Some unseen posts

However, one could reasonably argue the thread for AA hype wasn't official. And it goes without saying that 'I saw some posts saying AAAE' means absolutely nothing as well. Which leaves us with utterly nothing. No hype. Without hype there cannot be a flop. So lets review. We can only have two scenarios here, due to evidence:

-AA Hype

-No Hype

Either scenario dictates the game isn't a flop. Pick whichever tickles your fancy but thats all we have to go on. So until there's some amazingly convincing evidence to the contrary can we call it a night and consider this....

...Not A Flop

Skittles_McGee

edit: sorry 1 person said AA

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"]

Lets just outline this real quick. Tangible evidence of AA hype:

-Previously mentioned thread

-Poll

Tangible evidence of AAA hype:

-Some unseen posts

However, one could reasonably argue the thread for AA hype wasn't official. And it goes without saying that 'I saw some posts saying AAAE' means absolutely nothing as well. Which leaves us with utterly nothing. No hype. Without hype there cannot be a flop. So lets review. We can only have two scenarios here, due to evidence:

-AA Hype

-No Hype

Either scenario dictates the game isn't a flop. Pick whichever tickles your fancy but thats all we have to go on. So until there's some amazingly convincing evidence to the contrary can we call it a night and consider this....

...Not A Flop

HarlockJC

HHAHAHAHAHA and all that arguing the cows wer doing saying how mlb 10 is ps3 exclusive. LMAO, k cows you can have this game haha what a flop

Revolution316

You used to be like High Priest Grandmaster Cow so I don't know where you get off saying something like that

[QUOTE="naval"]lol. ouch and after so much effort was put in by cows to make this an exclusiveDante2710

[QUOTE="Dante2710"][QUOTE="naval"]lol. ouch and after so much effort was put in by cows to make this an exclusiveNike_Air

Its a 9/10 imo and i dont like baseball in real life lol.

The game is awesome, this is the best baseball game ever and the best sports game this gen imo

Well, it looks like the politicing paid off........oh wait. But onto another matter at hand.....lems......how can you NOT be on to the cows' game by now? While that plea to get it labeled exclusive was an attempt to grab another AAAE, the game wasn't hyped at AAA. What they tend to do is make several threads with the "list" of exclusives that they believe will be AAA, but when and if an actual hype thread for said game pops up, they play it very safe and underhype in most cases. C'mon lems, try to keep up.

8.5 was my prediction but I sure as heck didn't expect an 8.0

W1NGMAN-

Series?

In this thread... you said...

I'm in AAA heaven this month, seriously!

• MLB 10 The Show
• BC2
• GoW3

Best month of the year so far :shock:

W1NGMAN-

From what I played the game is superior to 09 in every way, and that includes online. 09 lagged like crazy when I tried it online, but 10 runs smooth. I am surprised it did not score exactly the same.

GameSpot System Wars: MLB 2010 Review Edition

The Good:

Unexpected twist at the end

The Bad:

SW got another fuel for discussion

:p

[QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

[QUOTE="Dante2710"] Indeed, quite amusing honestly. Dante2710

From what I played the game is superior to 09 in every way, and that includes online. 09 lagged like crazy when I tried it online, but 10 runs smooth. I am surprised it did not score exactly the same.

Kahuna_1

I agree, its better then last years version in alot of ways... should be same score or better imo.

[QUOTE="GiveMeSomething"]

If u compare it to soccer, tennis, or football; baseball is not really very demanding physically. The level required, the speed that u play at, is quite different from the sports I just mentioned. Even some professional baseball players have bellys, do u think that's very athletic? I don't think so.

DanteSuikoden

if its so easy can you pick up a bat and send a ball flying at you 85 mph+ over 400ft for a homerun let alone actually swing and make contact?

I mean, since its not that all physically demanding and all (which isn't all you need to play a sport)

I play semi-professional tennis. thank you very much. I serve at 100 mph+

massive floppage and egg on the face of the cows.

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

8.5 was my prediction but I sure as heck didn't expect an 8.0

Stevo_the_gamer

Series?

In this thread... you said...

I'm in AAA heaven this month, seriously!

• MLB 10 The Show
• BC2
• GoW3

Best month of the year so far :shock:

W1NGMAN-

Just finished my ab workout, so before I hit the weights ... I'll clear things up for you by letting you know I meant those games as AAA titles by the Industries definition not SWs.

Well I don't think many of us saw this coming.

Is there hope yet for MLB2k10??

7.5 for 360, 7.0 for PS3. I could not have predicted this outcome.

this should kill the exclusive debates

:o

Is there hope yet for MLB2k10??

Meh it'll be AAAE on METACRITIC which is what I care about. I have no interest anyhow.

[QUOTE="Kahuna_1"]

From what I played the game is superior to 09 in every way, and that includes online. 09 lagged like crazy when I tried it online, but 10 runs smooth. I am surprised it did not score exactly the same.

kozzy1234

I agree, its better then last years version in alot of ways... should be same score or better imo.

Yeah this will be the first year of The Show that I will be buying. That is how much I liked the improvements.

...an obvious flop, yet cows trying to deny it, anyways keeps SW fun,

Lets just outline this real quick. Tangible evidence of AA hype:

-Previously mentioned thread

-Poll

Tangible evidence of AAA hype:

-Some unseen posts

However, one could reasonably argue the thread for AA hype wasn't official. And it goes without saying that 'I saw some posts saying AAAE' means absolutely nothing as well. Which leaves us with utterly nothing. No hype. Without hype there cannot be a flop. So lets review. We can only have two scenarios here, due to evidence:

-AA Hype

-No Hype

Either scenario dictates the game isn't a flop. Pick whichever tickles your fancy but thats all we have to go on. So until there's some amazingly convincing evidence to the contrary can we call it a night and consider this....

...Not A Flop

Skittles_McGee

This is correct. There is not much else to say.