MLB 11: The Show review is up -- 8.0

Was there any hype for this game?

DroidPhysX

• Few significant changes from last year
• Steep learning curve for analog hitting and throwing.

[QUOTE="fueled-system"]

I notice they are using the recycled negative alot, Hope they use this when call of duty comes out..

II_Seraphim_II

I'd be surprised if the new COD gets below 9.0.:P

[QUOTE="fueled-system"]

I notice they are using the recycled negative alot, Hope they use this when call of duty comes out..

II_Seraphim_II

Makes me fear for Gear of War 3 then.

Anyone played it with the Move? I know it's just the HR derby but, was it accurate?

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"][QUOTE="bez2083"]

No hype for it, but some people did expect it to go AAA like it usually does.

sanim02

MLB 09 got a 9.0 back in 09 Chicken.:P ... Ha! 09... 9.0... in 09...:P

It wasn't deemed as exclusive so last year, we had a debate, in a similar fashion to GRAW and it was deemed exclusive but flopped.:P

No one really mentioned it this year and it was deemed exclusive this year as well so it's basically a random AAE for the PS3.:P

Makes me fear for Gear of War 3 then.

Lionheart08

I see you got 5 trophies.:P Atta boy!:P

It has a 91 on MC, but hey, what do I care? NHL is the only sports series I like.

Anyways, since they keep hammering games with that 'recycled' negative pin, they better hammer CoD. Or I'mma be CHEESED.

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

Makes me fear for Gear of War 3 then.

sanim02

I see you got 5 trophies.:P Atta boy!:P

[QUOTE="sanim02"]

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"] Why would people expect it to score AAA here on GS when it's never reviewed that high on this site? :?W1NGMAN-

MLB 09 got a 9.0 back in 09 Chicken.:P ... Ha! 09... 9.0... in 09...:P

It wasn't deemed as exclusive so last year, we had a debate, in a similar fashion to GRAW and it was deemed exclusive but flopped.:P

No one really mentioned it this year and it was deemed exclusive this year as well so it's basically a random AAE for the PS3.:P

Man you better not be gone for too long!:cry: I'm already starting to miss ya.:( Maybe you can send me an airdrop filled with... stuff.:P

imho gs dont like sports games especially sony sports games. just a thought

[QUOTE="II_Seraphim_II"][QUOTE="fueled-system"]

I notice they are using the recycled negative alot, Hope they use this when call of duty comes out..

Lionheart08

Makes me fear for Gear of War 3 then.

[QUOTE="sanim02"]

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

Makes me fear for Gear of War 3 then.

FIipMode

I see you got 5 trophies.:P Atta boy!:P

Hey he's on his way.:P @Lionheart08, you gotta join the next game night we throw for UC2.:P You gonna let Flippy get away with that?:o

It has a 91 on MC, but hey, what do I care? NHL is the only sports series I like.

Anyways, since they keep hammering games with that 'recycled' negative pin, they better hammer CoD. Or I'mma be CHEESED.

Cheesehead9099

They won't, it seems to be the only fanchise that doesn't get that complaint, add in some new crazy killstreaks and some new guns and it's like an all new game. I don't hate COD, I even have a lot of fun with it, but the free passes it gets is crazy.

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

Makes me fear for Gear of War 3 then.

sanim02

I see you got 5 trophies.:P Atta boy!:P

I'd have more, but school has been getting in the way of gaming. I'm officially on Spring Break now though. :P

Anyone played it with the Move? I know it's just the HR derby but, was it accurate?

Namgis

imho gs dont like sports games especially sony sports games. just a thought

_SWAG_

MLB 9 got a 9 at gs a few years ago. ;)

imho gs dont like sports games especially sony sports games. just a thought

_SWAG_

Hey he's on his way.:P Lionheart, you gotta join the next game night we throw for UC2.:P You gonna let Flippy get away with that?:osanim02

Don't do it Lion, you don't want none of this.

You can't even see me.

[QUOTE="FIipMode"][QUOTE="sanim02"]

I see you got 5 trophies.:P Atta boy!:P

sanim02

Hey he's on his way.:P @Lionheart08, you gotta join the next game night we throw for UC2.:P You gonna let Flippy get away with that?:o

When is it?

[QUOTE="sanim02"]

[QUOTE="FIipMode"]lol noobLionheart08

Hey he's on his way.:P @Lionheart08, you gotta join the next game night we throw for UC2.:P You gonna let Flippy get away with that?:o

When is it?

I don't know.:P Probably next week since it's break for a lot of people but I'll send out a telegram and plan it out like last time.:) Flippy needs to seriously get owned after what he did to Cloud.:P

[QUOTE="chikenfriedrice"]

[QUOTE="nervmeister"]Cool. Just find and bump the hype thread then.sanim02

I don't care to

Yet you care enough to make such claims?:?

it wasn't a hard claim to make...took a cpl of seconds

[QUOTE="sanim02"]Hey he's on his way.:P Lionheart, you gotta join the next game night we throw for UC2.:P You gonna let Flippy get away with that?:oFIipMode

Don't do it Lion, you don't want none of this.

You can't even see me.

Yeah.. Bandwidth Exceeded, no s*** I can't see you Sherlock.:P

[QUOTE="sanim02"]

[QUOTE="chikenfriedrice"]

I don't care to

chikenfriedrice

Yet you care enough to make such claims?:?

it wasn't a hard claim to make...took a cpl of seconds

Oh no problem, we all act before thinking sometimes, human nature.:)

I notice they are using the recycled negative alot, Hope they use this when call of duty comes out..

fueled-system

lol dont even go there we all know the type of review it will get

[QUOTE="chikenfriedrice"]

[QUOTE="sanim02"]

Yet you care enough to make such claims?:?

sanim02

it wasn't a hard claim to make...took a cpl of seconds

Oh no problem, we all act before thinking sometimes, human nature.:)

good thing this is just a meaningless thread in SW

[QUOTE="FIipMode"]

[QUOTE="sanim02"]Hey he's on his way.:P Lionheart, you gotta join the next game night we throw for UC2.:P You gonna let Flippy get away with that?:osanim02

Don't do it Lion, you don't want none of this.

You can't even see me.

Yeah.. Bandwidth Exceeded, no s*** I can't see you Sherlock.:P

Fixed, PhotoB is the worst.

[QUOTE="xhawk27"]

[QUOTE="Doolz2024"]So was this even hyped or what? I don't even recall seeing a hype thread. fueled-system

Yeah it had hype at the AAA level.

It has a 91 on MC, but hey, what do I care? NHL is the only sports series I like.

Anyways, since they keep hammering games with that 'recycled' negative pin, they better hammer CoD. Or I'mma be CHEESED.

Cheesehead9099

[QUOTE="fueled-system"]

[QUOTE="xhawk27"]

Yeah it had hype at the AAA level.

WilliamRLBaker

[QUOTE="fueled-system"]

[QUOTE="xhawk27"]

Yeah it had hype at the AAA level.

WilliamRLBaker

I believe that what you have shown... Is not proof :?

[QUOTE="fueled-system"]

[QUOTE="xhawk27"]

Yeah it had hype at the AAA level.

WilliamRLBaker

best baseball game ever, every year. ps3 rules

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]According to Casey the PS3 has overtaken the 360 :o ... Now it's second to last place :PSlashkice

Really? Deathsmiles is a timed exclusive, but speaking as of today they should be tied unless I'm missing something.

best baseball game ever, every year. ps3 rules

right4dead

[QUOTE="right4dead"]

best baseball game ever, every year. ps3 rules

lbjkurono23

[QUOTE="sanim02"]Hey he's on his way.:P Lionheart, you gotta join the next game night we throw for UC2.:P You gonna let Flippy get away with that?:oFIipMode

Don't do it Lion, you don't want none of this.

You can't even see me.

Try using tinypic if you want to trash talk. :P

[QUOTE="xhawk27"]

It flopped like the Mariners hitting average last year. :lol:

getyeryayasout

Yeah sry. Lets hope they do better this year. :)

I was wrong Slash, it is a tie ... weird I was adding an extra exclusive to the PS3 :PW1NGMAN-

[QUOTE="lbjkurono23"][QUOTE="right4dead"]

best baseball game ever, every year. ps3 rules

Doolz2024

[QUOTE="Slashkice"]

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]According to Casey the PS3 has overtaken the 360 :o ... Now it's second to last place :PW1NGMAN-

Really? Deathsmiles is a timed exclusive, but speaking as of today they should be tied unless I'm missing something.

PS3 and 360 still have their AAAAE/AAAE/AAE/AE battle going on.:P

PS3 leads in AAAAE and AE while the 360 leads in AAE and both are tied for AAAE.:P

If you look at it this way, the more AAE's PS3 gets this year, the closer the two systems will be by the end of this generation.:o Closest gap in terms of quality between two consoles in terms of GS review scores ever?:P As if it wasn't close enough already.:P

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"][QUOTE="Slashkice"]

Really? Deathsmiles is a timed exclusive, but speaking as of today they should be tied unless I'm missing something.

sanim02

PS3 and 360 still have their AAAAE/AAAE/AAE/AE battle going on.:P

PS3 leads in AAAAE and AE while the 360 leads in AAE and both are tied for AAAE.:P

If you look at it this way, the more AAE's PS3 gets this year, the closer the two systems will be by the end of this generation.:o Closest gap in terms of quality between two consoles in terms of GS review scores ever?:P As if it wasn't close enough already.:P

From what I see the spreadsheet has been updated(finally) and they are tied in AAAE and AE, but PS3 takes the lead because it has an extra AAAAE against the 360's extra AAE.:shock:

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"][QUOTE="Slashkice"]

Really? Deathsmiles is a timed exclusive, but speaking as of today they should be tied unless I'm missing something.

sanim02

PS3 and 360 still have their AAAAE/AAAE/AAE/AE battle going on.:P

PS3 leads in AAAAE and AE while the 360 leads in AAE and both are tied for AAAE.:P

If you look at it this way, the more AAE's PS3 gets this year, the closer the two systems will be by the end of this generation.:o Closest gap in terms of quality between two consoles in terms of GS review scores ever?:P As if it wasn't close enough already.:P

[QUOTE="fueled-system"]

I notice they are using the recycled negative alot, Hope they use this when call of duty comes out..

Chutebox

i wonder how recycled halo3, odst and reach got away too.

watch forza 4 get another AAA score with the same old same old and nothing new to offer since the first Forza.

they are only targeting ps3 excusives with these silly standards like: we didnt like the story in this fps, mlb11 is a flop because it plays like baseball, duhhh.

Try using tinypic if you want to trash talk. :P

Lionheart08

.....This aint over.