Hah I've never thought about that before. Good job. That does indeed match the legal definition. I'm writting this one down.[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"][QUOTE="ferret-gamer"]piracy is more akin to squatting than theft. if you purchase a game legally, then you purchase a licsence(lease) to use the software, you do not own it. pirates use the software without the liscense, it is the same as someone who is living in a house without paying rent or letting the owner know they are there. piracy is not theft, it is squatting.dc337
Are you happy to have a new poorly thought out justification for stealing the hard work of others?
In other parts of the world like SE Asia and Eastern Europe piracy is too high for a market to exist. In South Korea there are plenty of middle income earners that can afford the games but because of a culture of piracy they buy games on the streets which then makes them unappealing to software companies. As with pc gaming most of the people see no shame in doing it.
It's well established that once piracy rates get high enough software companies will exit the market. So no it isn't squatting, you're stealing the work of others and when enough people do it the companies feel the effect and change strategies. For pc gaming today that means a lot more casual and subscription games while single player exclusives like Deus Ex have become rare.
Justification? How about some critical reading. If anything, he found a legal charge that actually can be charged against pirates. You should be thanking that guy. I will reitterate myself as to why this is not stealing/theft. The fact of the matter is that for it to be theft, you must be taking and removing something from another's possession. With piracy, you're not technically removing something. All you're doing is accessing something which does not have a fungible withdraw on the part of the victim. It is squatting, and you should be happy this man has found a legal loophole to charge pirates. Because as it was, you would have been laughed out a courtroom.
Log in to comment