Resident Evil 4 vs Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

[QUOTE="lbjkurono23"][QUOTE="DarkLink77"] RE4 is a multiplat. It is one of the most important and innovative (and best) titles released last gen. It is being beaten by a system exclusive that merely does stuff that many other games do very well. I think it's pretty obvious why it's Cowspot.DarkLink77

Keep 'em handy, stuff is about to go down! :P

Having recently replayed both I have to say that Uncharted 2 is far better, innovation be damned

lol @ the poll. No way it should be about even.

Now, I could be wrong, but I'm guessing most of the votes for Uncharted 2 were by people that never played RE4. Just a guess.

Having recently replayed both I have to say that Uncharted 2 is far better, innovation be damned

emorainbo

I haven't played RE4 in some time, and maybe I'm putting it on a pedestal because of this, but after replaying UC2, it wasn't even close for me. RE4 was much more enjoyable.

But now that I am imagining, without RE4, UC would probably come out weird..

*Shuuders*

what's your psn id? SpeedsterCards

[QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"] what's your psn id? DarkLink77

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

[QUOTE="lbjkurono23"] I knew my tin foil horns would come in handy.lbjkurono23

Keep 'em handy, stuff is about to go down! :P

RE4 by a mile

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"][QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"] what's your psn id? SpeedsterCards

UC2. Soon to be UC3.

lol @ the poll. No way it should be about even.

Now, I could be wrong, but I'm guessing most of the votes for Uncharted 2 were by people that never played RE4. Just a guess.

Doolz2024

Lol I just noticed that Ive been using a RE4 avatar for the past year :P

Lol I just noticed that Ive been using a RE4 avatar for the past year :P

emorainbo

uc2 since its plot isnt horrible like re4.vitonemesis

jk.

[QUOTE="vitonemesis"]uc2 since its plot isnt horrible like re4.Avian005

jk.

I don't know the RE story as a whole really well (a decent bit I guess), but I thought RE4 was pretty awesome for a story. Not perfect or the best, but definitely a good one if I recall correctly.

I prefer RE4..Although Drake>Leon.

[QUOTE="Avian005"]

[QUOTE="vitonemesis"]uc2 since its plot isnt horrible like re4.NaveedLife

jk.

I don't know the RE story as a whole really well (a decent bit I guess), but I thought RE4 was pretty awesome for a story. Not perfect or the best, but definitely a good one if I recall correctly.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="Avian005"]You're right. All that happens in RE4 is Ashley constantly being kidnapped thus making Leon chase after her while doing some other less important stuff.

jk.

Avian005

I don't know the RE story as a whole really well (a decent bit I guess), but I thought RE4 was pretty awesome for a story. Not perfect or the best, but definitely a good one if I recall correctly.

Haha I know, I was just putting my 2 cents in :P. I think the presentation of the story though is really what made it so special. You don't know much and it feels so mysterious and then the **** hits the fan and its awesome. Great progression really.

uc2 since its plot isnt horrible like re4.vitonemesis

[QUOTE="Avian005"]

[QUOTE="vitonemesis"]uc2 since its plot isnt horrible like re4.NaveedLife

jk.

I don't know the RE story as a whole really well (a decent bit I guess), but I thought RE4 was pretty awesome for a story. Not perfect or the best, but definitely a good one if I recall correctly.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="Avian005"]You're right. All that happens in RE4 is Ashley constantly being kidnapped thus making Leon chase after her while doing some other less important stuff.

jk.

lbjkurono23

I don't know the RE story as a whole really well (a decent bit I guess), but I thought RE4 was pretty awesome for a story. Not perfect or the best, but definitely a good one if I recall correctly.

I played....Zero I believe lol. In the mansion with Jill and such. I actually made it pretty far I think (been many years now) and I enjoyed it at the time although the movement (at least when starting) made me quite angry lol. IDK its just one of those series I neve really got into for some strange reason. Come to think of it, what systems did it release on and such? I had always been a Nintendo Only guy until a few years ago I went to PC as well (my favorite now), and this gen I owned all the systems (sold the 360) and bought a PS2 and played some of the games I missed out on. MGS1-4 :). I regret being a Nintendo fanboy lol, but I had played games on other systems prior to owning them this gen, just not much. Anyway, sorry for the wall of text :P.

hmmm, I love both. But I feel I have to give the edge to RE4 as it revolutionised TPS and had awesome atmosphere.

To bad RE5 crashed and burned in RE4 shadow.:(

hmmm, I love both. But I feel I have to give the edge to RE4 as it revolutionised TPS and had awesome atmosphere.

To bad RE5 crashed and burned in RE4 shadow.:(

dercoo

could have been so amazing, especially with today's technology making the atmosphere even more engrossing.

Really tough choice. RE4 though.

Personally, I think RE4. Not to say Uncharted 2 isn't excellent.

RE4, there are just somethings that I don't think other TPS games do that RE4 did. Its one of the most incredible games ever period. U2 is great too but for me there isn't much of a comparison.

RE4, no contest. This is like comparing The Godfather to Scarface XDMaster_ShakeXXX

RE4, no contest. This is like comparing The Godfather to Scarface XDMaster_ShakeXXX

[QUOTE="lbjkurono23"]

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

I don't know the RE story as a whole really well (a decent bit I guess), but I thought RE4 was pretty awesome for a story. Not perfect or the best, but definitely a good one if I recall correctly.

NaveedLife

I played....Zero I believe lol. In the mansion with Jill and such. I actually made it pretty far I think (been many years now) and I enjoyed it at the time although the movement (at least when starting) made me quite angry lol. IDK its just one of those series I neve really got into for some strange reason. Come to think of it, what systems did it release on and such? I had always been a Nintendo Only guy until a few years ago I went to PC as well (my favorite now), and this gen I owned all the systems (sold the 360) and bought a PS2 and played some of the games I missed out on. MGS1-4 :). I regret being a Nintendo fanboy lol, but I had played games on other systems prior to owning them this gen, just not much. Anyway, sorry for the wall of text :P.

[QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"]RE4, no contest. This is like comparing The Godfather to Scarface XDUC3Drake

UC2, RE4 is the reason the Resident evil series has gone to crap.

I like to run and shoot in my games so I have to say UC2. RE4 didn't do anything for me but I didn't start back gaming until this gen so going backwards is tough with worst graphics and all.

Both really outstanding games...Uncharted 2 edges RE out by having great multiplayer that stands out on its own merits and remains fun to this day (unlike some other games I can name), ON TOP of having a crazily high-quality campaign that had almost no rough spots (whereas I can name a few real tedious parts in RE 4), and being one of the few games this generation to have proper cheats.

I will say that RE 4 easily has better boss fights, and a funnier story, if unintentionally so. And obviously its influence is much greater, but I'm comparing games here.

BOTH are AMAZING!

But hands down it's Resident Evil 4.

[QUOTE="UC3Drake"]

[QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"]RE4, no contest. This is like comparing The Godfather to Scarface XDMaster_ShakeXXX

UC2, RE4 is the reason the Resident evil series has gone to crap.

spookykid143

But isn't RE4 also the reason that UC2 is the way it is? Can you imagine what it would be like without RE4's influence?

[QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"][QUOTE="UC3Drake"]Arent they both regarded as one of the best movies ever made? I loved both anyway.

clone01

Film is subjective but gaming has definate revolutions. For me alls The Godfather was is a well acted mobster movie maybe ( I can't stand it though). The Godfather did not revolutionise the movie industry.

Resident Evil 4 revolutionised Survival Horror, Action Adventure, and Shooter genres. Its influence can be clearly seen in games like Gears of War (who admited its influence ) and Dead Space (who also did).