So it seems Gears of War 3 failed to defeat Uncharted 2 score...

Gears has nothing to worry about, its the better game, and more people play it, and wow at the sales. If only uncharted 2 had those sales... ForzaGearsFace

uncharted 2 sold 4.5 Million and that ispretty damn impressive. :|

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"]Gears has nothing to worry about, its the better game, and more people play it, and wow at the sales. If only uncharted 2 had those sales... Lexter45

uncharted 2 sold 4.5 Million and that ispretty damn impressive. :|

[QUOTE="Lexter45"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"]Gears has nothing to worry about, its the better game, and more people play it, and wow at the sales. If only uncharted 2 had those sales... ForzaGearsFace

uncharted 2 sold 4.5 Million and that ispretty damn impressive. :|

[QUOTE="brucecambell"]

UC2 has a better score, more praise & more GOTY awards than any GOW title.GOW3 failed to beat a 2 yr old game. Its pretty sad. It was a failure before it was even released. UC3 will be another nail in the coffin

delta3074

killzone was never meant to be the answer to halo, im pretty sure resistance is the closest and probably starhawk next year

EDIT: well then again sony did want it to be the answer to halo on the ps2 :P..but resistance is probably the closest

Gears has nothing to worry about, its the better game, and more people play it, and wow at the sales. If only uncharted 2 had those sales... ForzaGearsFace

UC would have those sales too if it was the only thing that came out all year.

As cows are fond of saying standards change...gears 3 91 is like a 99 back then where as uncharted 2's 96 or whatever today is like an 81.

But since we must exclude all old 360 games and include only the newest games gears 3 outscored the majority of ps3 exclusives.

*these are the hoops that must be passed through to make out that the ps3 has a better library then the 360*

[QUOTE="brucecambell"]

UC2 has a better score, more praise & more GOTY awards than any GOW title.GOW3 failed to beat a 2 yr old game. Its pretty sad. It was a failure before it was even released. UC3 will be another nail in the coffin

delta3074

And yet no exclusive on 360 has ever beaten all the perfect scores that MGS4 has received. Come at me bro, I dare ya. :)

[QUOTE="ihsanqueen"]

Lemmings said that Gears of War 3 will be the best exclusive this gen, defeating Uncharted 2

Unfortunately in MC, Gears of War 3 only scored 91 while Uncharted 2 scored 96

And forza only scored 8.5 here

So after Gears of War 3 and Forza 4 failed to defeat Uncharted 2, is there any 360 exclusives that can defeat Uncharted 2? considering there's no 360 exclusives again this year

delta3074

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"]Gears has nothing to worry about, its the better game, and more people play it, and wow at the sales. If only uncharted 2 had those sales... Lexter45

uncharted 2 sold 4.5 Million and that ispretty damn impressive. :|

Erm, so what? Just because it has a better metascore score doesn't mean it's a better game.

Stringerboy

[QUOTE="Lexter45"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"]Gears has nothing to worry about, its the better game, and more people play it, and wow at the sales. If only uncharted 2 had those sales... ForzaGearsFace

uncharted 2 sold 4.5 Million and that ispretty damn impressive. :|

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="ihsanqueen"]

Lemmings said that Gears of War 3 will be the best exclusive this gen, defeating Uncharted 2

Unfortunately in MC, Gears of War 3 only scored 91 while Uncharted 2 scored 96

And forza only scored 8.5 here

So after Gears of War 3 and Forza 4 failed to defeat Uncharted 2, is there any 360 exclusives that can defeat Uncharted 2? considering there's no 360 exclusives again this year

ianuilliam

As cows are fond of saying standards change...gears 3 91 is like a 99 back then where as uncharted 2's 96 or whatever today is like an 81.

But since we must exclude all old 360 games and include only the newest games gears 3 outscored the majority of ps3 exclusives.

*these are the hoops that must be passed through to make out that the ps3 has a better library then the 360*

WilliamRLBaker

[QUOTE="mems_1224"]gears is better than uncharted.....razgriz_101

both are good but to be honest outside the shooting mechanic its like comparing apples and oranges.

agree, uncharted is more fast paced than gears

[QUOTE="Lexter45"]

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"]Gears has nothing to worry about, its the better game, and more people play it, and wow at the sales. If only uncharted 2 had those sales... ianuilliam

uncharted 2 sold 4.5 Million and that ispretty damn impressive. :|

[QUOTE="Lexter45"]

uncharted 2 sold 4.5 Million and that ispretty damn impressive. :|

[QUOTE="Lexter45"][QUOTE="ianuilliam"]Pretty sure they announced 4.9 a little bit back.

TH1Sx1SxSPARTA

Aggregate scores are a joke.

Aggregate scores are a joke.

DarkLink77

still agry about DNF eh

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

Aggregate scores are a joke.

r12qi

still agry about DNF eh

according to the score they are both equals :shock:

[QUOTE="r12qi"]

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

Aggregate scores are a joke.

Lexter45

still agry about DNF eh

Because of its aggregate score? :)

still managed to meet my expectations :) thats all i care !!

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="ihsanqueen"]

Lemmings said that Gears of War 3 will be the best exclusive this gen, defeating Uncharted 2

Unfortunately in MC, Gears of War 3 only scored 91 while Uncharted 2 scored 96

And forza only scored 8.5 here

So after Gears of War 3 and Forza 4 failed to defeat Uncharted 2, is there any 360 exclusives that can defeat Uncharted 2? considering there's no 360 exclusives again this year

ianuilliam

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="brucecambell"]

UC2 has a better score, more praise & more GOTY awards than any GOW title.GOW3 failed to beat a 2 yr old game. Its pretty sad. It was a failure before it was even released. UC3 will be another nail in the coffin

contracts420

And yet no exclusive on 360 has ever beaten all the perfect scores that MGS4 has received. Come at me bro, I dare ya. :)

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

Aggregate scores are a joke.

r12qi

still agry about DNF eh

[QUOTE="contracts420"]

[QUOTE="delta3074"]pretty sad that killone 3 failed to beat a 4 year old game, what now dude?delta3074

And yet no exclusive on 360 has ever beaten all the perfect scores that MGS4 has received. Come at me bro, I dare ya. :)

Well you missed the point of my post... which is exactly the point of your post. I agree that this constant arguing over such stupid things like the scores can get annoying. Enjoy what you enjoy and leave it be... right? Guess not, this is System Wars.

Uncharted 2 has more GOTYs and Gaming awards and critical acclaim than all 360 exclusives combined

I hope we can finally put this thread to bed,

*Drops Mic*

Uncharted 2 has more GOTYs and Gaming awards and critical acclaim than all 360 exclusives combined

I hope we can finally put this thread to bed,

*Drops Mic*

Zaibach

Combined? So you can prove that?

They both received the same score... :|

I wouldnt be surprised if Epic hates the Uncharted series since it's always has to be compared to it.

I wouldnt be surprised if Epic hates the Uncharted series since it's always has to be compared to it.

eboyishere

Nope theres a good cameraderie between Epic and Naughty Dog :P they had a lot of banter on twitter at UC2 launch and the Gears 3 launch aswell both praising one anothers games.

Same goes for Bungie and ND aswell, contrary to popular belief most dev studios arent fanboys like SW :P

[QUOTE="Zaibach"]

Uncharted 2 has more GOTYs and Gaming awards and critical acclaim than all 360 exclusives combined

I hope we can finally put this thread to bed,

*Drops Mic*

waltefmoney

Combined? So you can prove that?

Over 200 GOTY awards Just saying

[QUOTE="Lexter45"][QUOTE="r12qi"]

still agry about DNF eh

KiZZo1

Because of its aggregate score? :)

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

[QUOTE="Zaibach"]

Uncharted 2 has more GOTYs and Gaming awards and critical acclaim than all 360 exclusives combined

I hope we can finally put this thread to bed,

*Drops Mic*

Zaibach

Combined? So you can prove that?

Over 200 GOTY awards Just saying

So you can't prove it?

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

[QUOTE="Zaibach"]

Uncharted 2 has more GOTYs and Gaming awards and critical acclaim than all 360 exclusives combined

I hope we can finally put this thread to bed,

*Drops Mic*

Zaibach

Combined? So you can prove that?

Over 200 GOTY awards Just saying

UC2 scored today being compared to Gears 3 would likely get a 7.5 - 8.5 so UC3 has a bunch to live up to and if it fails to get the 9.5, oh my, I hope you like the taste of crow... just sayin. :twisted: :P

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

I wouldnt be surprised if Epic hates the Uncharted series since it's always has to be compared to it.

razgriz_101

Nope theres a good cameraderie between Epic and Naughty Dog :P they had a lot of banter on twitter at UC2 launch and the Gears 3 launch aswell both praising one anothers games.

Same goes for Bungie and ND aswell, contrary to popular belief most dev studios arent fanboys like SW :P

i know the devs are friendly but epic is probably getting tired of always having to compete with uncharted, i mean didnt a reviewer bring it up in his review of Gears 3? I think after awhile it gets tiring

wont let me link

http://www.gamefaqs.com/ps3/634956-uncharted-dual-pack

[QUOTE="razgriz_101"]

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

I wouldnt be surprised if Epic hates the Uncharted series since it's always has to be compared to it.

eboyishere

Nope theres a good cameraderie between Epic and Naughty Dog :P they had a lot of banter on twitter at UC2 launch and the Gears 3 launch aswell both praising one anothers games.

Same goes for Bungie and ND aswell, contrary to popular belief most dev studios arent fanboys like SW :P

i know the devs are friendly but epic is probably getting tired of always having to compete with uncharted, i mean didnt a reviewer bring it up in his review of Gears 3? I think after awhile it gets tiring

nah Cliffy B quiete enjoys it and said its good competition for them to keep building upon their product and the fact he's also said its a game he's looking forward to aswell.

If its giving both developers a goal to try and top one another and bring good games to the table then i seriously dont think its a bad thing at all, a bit of friendly competition goes a long way.

[QUOTE="Zaibach"]

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

Combined? So you can prove that?

DarkLink77

Over 200 GOTY awards Just saying