[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"][QUOTE="GoldenElementXL"] Um no. At no point did the Plasma look better. And once again this after thinking that the plasma was going to look better after reading online reviews. The tv's were not locked in any setting...... I had 3 tv's next to each other. And the 2 Best Buy employees I have known for over a decade. They did things that they would not do for most customers. I was in the store for over 4 hours looking at tv's. The plasma was the most dull at the high end. The black was the best but from darkest to lightest it was the worst. I even thought that the DLP had a better high end than the plasma and almost bought it because of the insane screen size. (I could have bought a 73" for the price of a 55".) Plasma is a good deal but there is no way anybody with 20/20 vision can say it is the best. The fact that some of the top sites say this after my experience in quite confusing. GoldenElementXL
Actually, any professional will have a field day telling you how plasma bests LCD and LCD-LEDs.
You're let Best Buy get to you. Again, Best Buy is no where near the proper place to judge TVs. Even in their Magnolia setups its still not good enough because they fill the rooms with light. Calibrations done by professionals can take up to 4 hours, for just one TV. Yes, it gets that in-depth. You mention the plasma was the most dull. I believe its the general knowledge any calibrated display is going to look dull and washed out once light enters the room. Blacks are what kills LCDs. It doesn't transition properly where it needs to and its very obvious during dark scenes, even on Sony and Samsung TVs.
Though, depending on the amount of light in the room, the LCD might have been the better choice. Though with bright rooms you're already dragging down the actual picture quality of the TV as you need to turn up the backlight and brightness to be a good clarity. And no, sweet mother of god you would've taken the DLP back the moment you turned it on. Brightness + DLP = worse visability than an LCD without backlight. You have to have a dark room or very low amount of light or else it kills visibility. Great thing about Panasonic and now LG plasmas is that they have ISF Day and ISF Night settings, which after correct application will give the best picture during the day and night accordingly and automatically switch over (They sense the light in the room.)
Maybe its because you haven't taken it home and spent time with a plasma. I would still take a Samsung 720p plasma over our 42" LG LCD (S-IPS panel of course.) Even after calibration I'd the Samsung in torch mode.
Actually the Tv I owned before my 2 Led/lcd Sonys was the Panosonic P50S30. And when I bought the 55" Sony I judged side by side and I honestly liked the Sony better. To me it seems as if the media wants the Plasma TV to succeed since there was nothing I thought the Plasma did better. I promise you that I am a consumer reports subscriber and I do indeed do my research. There was nothing in my 27 year old eyes that the Panasonic did better. Maybe you have better vision than I do. But in my eyes I made the right choice. And the Best Buy guys are either relatives, or the best man in my wedding in less than a year. I know as much if not more about tv's than they do and I would trust their judgement more than any reviewer on any website. I did my homework and I promise you, while plasma is good, they will not be around in 2-4 years. You sound just like me, I am the same age too and have owned 4 HDTV's in my lifetime. A 720p Sony bravia, a 720p panasonic plasma, a samsung 720p dlp and my current bedroom tv a 40" samsung 1080p 120htz lcd. I had my Bravia and panasonic side by side and the sony was better, not by much but better, the colors popped more and the black were about the same (even though they were supposed to be superior on the plasma). I do my research as well and I find a lot of Sony/Samsung tvs look better than plasmas. My friend has a new 1080p panasonic plasma and he even swears my current samsung looks better than his even though AVSforum gives his panny plasma such great ratings. I calibrated all my TV's by the way with the same install disc that best buy employees use when they do it at your home, plus ive also downloaded calibration tests etc. Anyway what I am trying to say is its all personal preference, just find the LCD's I buy to have colors that really stand out. Trust me, I would have bought a new plasma if I really thought it looked better but im happy with my LCD's.
Log in to comment