The Greatest Comback In VideoGame History. Overall Quality Library PS3 vs 360.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] I was told directly by a Mod that as long as you use reasonable arguements anythings game. So please don't try to derail the thread. Gamespot's opinion is counted in this thread as they're a part of Metacritic. Gamtrix

if you're doing the metagame, as you claim, it's gs we use. :?

you're the one who said he's going along with the metagame. it's always used gamespot. it's why the spreadsheet is linked in the stickied info thread. this is cool and all but...

Hey listen up I did not go through all this trouble for a MOD to contradict another MOD and make this whole thread pointless, I did a ton of work, it's a fair thread, I've been listening and adressing all feedback. Unless theres an explicit rule saying I can't use Metacritic to make a library camparison just let this be. Otherwise it's just another arguement about Metacritic vs Gamespot all over again. This isn't a which has a better library at Gamespot thread, it's a universal thread, where we take the opinions of many sources, and Metacritic/Gamerankings is the perfect way to do that.

Gamtrix

why does it matter so much to you? and why did you link it in your sig? do you think this is some grand form of ownage?

i vote meh. because the greatest comback in video game history is nintendo with its wii

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"]

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

if you're doing the metagame, as you claim, it's gs we use. :?

CaseyWegner

you're the one who said he's going along with the metagame. it's always used gamespot. it's why the spreadsheet is linked in the stickied info thread. this is cool and all but...

I dont think its as much as a comeback as it is a falling from grace for the 360. Like seriously their first party seems really dead at this point and we havent really gotten any new insteresting games in a while. Sure alan wake was alright but that game was delayed for like 4 years,

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] Hey listen up I did not go through all this trouble for a MOD to contradict another MOD and make this whole thread pointless, I did a ton of work, it's a fair thread, I've been listening and adressing all feedback. Unless theres an explicit rule saying I can't use Metacritic to make a library camparison just let this be. Otherwise it's just another arguement about Metacritic vs Gamespot all over again. This isn't a which has a better library at Gamespot thread, it's a universal thread, where we take the opinions of many sources, and Metacritic/Gamerankings is the perfect way to do that.

Gamtrix

you're the one who said he's going along with the metagame. it's always used gamespot. it's why the spreadsheet is linked in the stickied info thread. this is cool and all but...

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] Hey listen up I did not go through all this trouble for a MOD to contradict another MOD and make this whole thread pointless, I did a ton of work, it's a fair thread, I've been listening and adressing all feedback. Unless theres an explicit rule saying I can't use Metacritic to make a library camparison just let this be. Otherwise it's just another arguement about Metacritic vs Gamespot all over again. This isn't a which has a better library at Gamespot thread, it's a universal thread, where we take the opinions of many sources, and Metacritic/Gamerankings is the perfect way to do that.

clone01

why does it matter so much to you? and why did you link it in your sig? do you think this is some grand form of ownage?

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] Hey listen up I did not go through all this trouble for a MOD to contradict another MOD and make this whole thread pointless, I did a ton of work, it's a fair thread, I've been listening and adressing all feedback. Unless theres an explicit rule saying I can't use Metacritic to make a library camparison just let this be. Otherwise it's just another arguement about Metacritic vs Gamespot all over again. This isn't a which has a better library at Gamespot thread, it's a universal thread, where we take the opinions of many sources, and Metacritic/Gamerankings is the perfect way to do that.

clone01

why does it matter so much to you? and why did you link it in your sig? do you think this is some grand form of ownage?

[QUOTE="clone01"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] Hey listen up I did not go through all this trouble for a MOD to contradict another MOD and make this whole thread pointless, I did a ton of work, it's a fair thread, I've been listening and adressing all feedback. Unless theres an explicit rule saying I can't use Metacritic to make a library camparison just let this be. Otherwise it's just another arguement about Metacritic vs Gamespot all over again. This isn't a which has a better library at Gamespot thread, it's a universal thread, where we take the opinions of many sources, and Metacritic/Gamerankings is the perfect way to do that.

Gamtrix

why does it matter so much to you? and why did you link it in your sig? do you think this is some grand form of ownage?

I dont think its as much as a comeback as it is a falling from grace for the 360. Like seriously their first party seems really dead at this point and we havent really gotten any new insteresting games in a while. Sure alan wake was alright but that game was delayed for like 4 years,

VendettaRed07

[QUOTE="VendettaRed07"]

I dont think its as much as a comeback as it is a falling from grace for the 360. Like seriously their first party seems really dead at this point and we havent really gotten any new insteresting games in a while. Sure alan wake was alright but that game was delayed for like 4 years,

clone01

[QUOTE="clone01"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] Hey listen up I did not go through all this trouble for a MOD to contradict another MOD and make this whole thread pointless, I did a ton of work, it's a fair thread, I've been listening and adressing all feedback. Unless theres an explicit rule saying I can't use Metacritic to make a library camparison just let this be. Otherwise it's just another arguement about Metacritic vs Gamespot all over again. This isn't a which has a better library at Gamespot thread, it's a universal thread, where we take the opinions of many sources, and Metacritic/Gamerankings is the perfect way to do that.

Gamtrix

why does it matter so much to you? and why did you link it in your sig? do you think this is some grand form of ownage?

ps3 has the best library, i think everyone knows that, but im glad i have both

ps3 has the best library, i think everyone knows that, but im glad i have both

YankeesNYC4life

PS3 has made an epic comback, congrats to Sony, Microsoft pretty much lost steam ever since MGS4 smacked system wars, all 360 has now is Reach, and half a year later...Gears3iMojo786_PSN

ps3 has the best library, i think everyone knows that, but im glad i have both

YankeesNYC4life

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] Hey listen up I did not go through all this trouble for a MOD to contradict another MOD and make this whole thread pointless, I did a ton of work, it's a fair thread, I've been listening and adressing all feedback. Unless theres an explicit rule saying I can't use Metacritic to make a library camparison just let this be. Otherwise it's just another arguement about Metacritic vs Gamespot all over again. This isn't a which has a better library at Gamespot thread, it's a universal thread, where we take the opinions of many sources, and Metacritic/Gamerankings is the perfect way to do that.

Gamtrix

you're the one who said he's going along with the metagame. it's always used gamespot. it's why the spreadsheet is linked in the stickied info thread. this is cool and all but...

so you decided to do it here where another metagame already exists? :?

[QUOTE="iMojo786_PSN"]PS3 has made an epic comback, congrats to Sony, Microsoft pretty much lost steam ever since MGS4 smacked system wars, all 360 has now is Reach, and half a year later...Gears3darthkirmy

[QUOTE="darthkirmy"][QUOTE="iMojo786_PSN"]PS3 has made an epic comback, congrats to Sony, Microsoft pretty much lost steam ever since MGS4 smacked system wars, all 360 has now is Reach, and half a year later...Gears3Gamtrix

[QUOTE="YankeesNYC4life"]

ps3 has the best library, i think everyone knows that, but im glad i have both

clone01

I'd have to search for it but I'm sure someone will back it up for me, this is going by official Microsoft and Sony sales figures.Gamtrix

How about the great comback that was nintendo gamecube to nintendo wii. or how about even the xbox to greatly improved and well supported 360 platform. Comparing the ps2 to the ps3, its actually a step down.

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] I'd have to search for it but I'm sure someone will back it up for me, this is going by official Microsoft and Sony sales figures.clone01

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] I'd have to search for it but I'm sure someone will back it up for me, this is going by official Microsoft and Sony sales figures.clone01

i'm a little confused about the thread title. it says overall quality library but your sig says ps3 > 360. your list shows the 360 overall library with a higher number than for the ps3.

i'm a little confused about the thread title. it says overall quality library but your sig says ps3 > 360.

CaseyWegner

prolly counting ME2 KZ3 and a bunch of other games PS# hasnt released yet

360 Halo series, Gears, Alan Wake. Mass effect 1 not 2 Forza Motorsport. Splinter Cell, Dead or Alive, Fable, Left for dead

PS3 God Of War, Killzone, Heavy Rain. Resistance, Uncharted, Little Big Planet, MGS4, Gran Turismo. SOCOM, Twisted Metal, Infamous, Ratchet&Clank

You be the judge.

[QUOTE="clone01"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] I'd have to search for it but I'm sure someone will back it up for me, this is going by official Microsoft and Sony sales figures.RogueShodown

[QUOTE="RogueShodown"][QUOTE="clone01"] so, in other words, you've made a claim, and you have no proof. also, you don't want to do the legwork to provide said proof. cool

lawlessx

thanks...that was my overall point.

This thread needs locked. The opening post is clearly biased despite the TC claiming it as fact. And whats worse is that plenty of people have gave the TC suggestions in how to make the comparison more fair, yet he's refused to do it as he knows it will work against his original point.Anjunaddict

[QUOTE="Anjunaddict"]This thread needs locked. The opening post is clearly biased despite the TC claiming it as fact. And whats worse is that plenty of people have gave the TC suggestions in how to make the comparison more fair, yet he's refused to do it as he knows it will work against his original point.Gamtrix

i do agree that A games shouldn't be listed. they're not part of the metagame.

[QUOTE="lawlessx"][QUOTE="RogueShodown"] It's not that hard to look for it. It was back sometime around E3, I think, so it's probably been widened a little due to the new S models being released and old 360 price drops.clone01

thanks...that was my overall point.

[QUOTE="clone01"]

[QUOTE="lawlessx"] that's beyond the point. Why make a claim and expect somebody else to back it up for you? Gamtrix

thanks...that was my overall point.

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"][QUOTE="Anjunaddict"]This thread needs locked. The opening post is clearly biased despite the TC claiming it as fact. And whats worse is that plenty of people have gave the TC suggestions in how to make the comparison more fair, yet he's refused to do it as he knows it will work against his original point.CaseyWegner

i do agree that A games shouldn't be listed. they're not part of the metagame.

I don't understand, why are they included in the spreadsheet then?

[QUOTE="Anjunaddict"]This thread needs locked. The opening post is clearly biased despite the TC claiming it as fact. And whats worse is that plenty of people have gave the TC suggestions in how to make the comparison more fair, yet he's refused to do it as he knows it will work against his original point.Gamtrix

[QUOTE="clone01"]

[QUOTE="lawlessx"] that's beyond the point. Why make a claim and expect somebody else to back it up for you? Gamtrix

thanks...that was my overall point.

[QUOTE="clone01"]

[QUOTE="lawlessx"] that's beyond the point. Why make a claim and expect somebody else to back it up for you? Gamtrix

thanks...that was my overall point.

and the people who care:

xbox 360=0

wii=0

ps3=you

[QUOTE="clone01"]

[QUOTE="lawlessx"] that's beyond the point. Why make a claim and expect somebody else to back it up for you? Gamtrix

thanks...that was my overall point.

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"][QUOTE="clone01"]thanks...that was my overall point.lawlessx

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"][QUOTE="clone01"]

thanks...that was my overall point.

lawlessx

[QUOTE="lawlessx"][QUOTE="Gamtrix"] So it's ok for the other poster to claim the 360 is outselling the PS3, no proof, noone questions him, but when I claim otherwise(and end up being proven that I wasn't making it up) I'm the one that's in the wrong? Plenty of people say things without proof on this forum, why are you guys picking on me? Gamtrix

you can argue all day long how "ZOMG but but teh ps3 has moar ESCLUSIVES than xbawks"

i would still say

halo reach>any ps3 exclusive

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] That's a lie, you want this locked because you don't like the results, people listed games that were missing and I added them, I've been fair from page one, you expect me to go do what I did here for all the A games too just be YOU think they should be included? Do you have ANY idea how much work that is? And how many of us disagree? Anjunaddict

i do agree that A games shouldn't be listed. they're not part of the metagame.

I don't understand, why are they included in the spreadsheet then?

the spreadsheet wasn't made for the metagame. it's a reference. we just use the spreadsheet cause it's convenient and well done. there's a note about it in the info thread.