[QUOTE="peterw007"][QUOTE="khoofia_pika"] I've played Skyward Sword, and it deserves a 10 as much as SMG2 did. But I don't want to get into that, so I'll just sing off by saying- let's wait and watch. :)lancea34
This is true. Skyward Sword absolutely deserved a 10. The game is absolutely brilliant.
McShea just likes to be controversial so that GameSpot will get more ad revenue.
It wouldn't surprise me if the higher-ups at CBS gave McShea a bonus for reviewing Skyward Sword the way he did.
A 10 would be just pulling it. The game is brilliant and deserves more than 7.5 (I would give it a 9.5), but at the same time I can't help but admit the game isn't radicaly different from other Zelda games. It relyes too much on the same formula and some people might have gotten tired of it.Super Mario Galaxy 2 wasn't "radically different" from Super Mario Galaxy...and that still got a 10?
The whole point of sequels is to utilize the foundations set by the predecessor and make a new experience out of that.
If it was "radically different" it wouldn't be called Zelda anymore.
Regardless, McShea will score Mario Kart either 6.5 or 7.
GameSpot really has been ragging on Nintendo franchises all through this year...for no good reason.
Log in to comment