Weird inconsistancies in Lemming claims... *56k no dice*

I wonder why it is that Lemmings claim that they can clearly see the "glaring" differences between multiplat titles?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4yYss7zrqqY

But many of those same keen eyed lemmings "can't tell the difference" between

Bluray

and DVD

Or they can't see why everyone thinks PS3 exclusives

Look beeter then anything on 360:

So here's the deal. Yes I own a 360 and yes the 360 has some good looking games. However for too long Lemmings have justified no bluray player, no wifi, controllers with batteries, RROD, E74, overpriced propritary hard drive and online gaming fees with a single mantra "360 has the best games". But now since the 360 hasen't had a decent non-expansion pack exclusive game in almost a year, the new focus has shifted to the completely unnoticable differences between multiplats. To me this sounds like an excuse. Wouldn't it be better if MS spent money on actually making full games instead of DLC? Shouldn't they shift focus to first party studios instead of twitter on XBL? Don't be upset because PS3 owners are enjoying all the multiplats you are in addition to a superior exclusive game lineup. Talk to Microsoft who would rather delay or outright cancel PC versions of games instead of actually spending money so the 360 can have some exclusives of it's own. Don't tell me they can't afford it.

the first few points were acctually good but when u got into the crappy pics of gears of war, everyone saw that was bs.

anyways get ur popcorn ready :D

I wonder why it is that Lemmings claim that they can clearly see the "glaring" differences between multiplat titles?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4yYss7zrqqY

MegajerkNYC

Can't.Stop.Looking.At.ARM! :|

Hey look, cherrypicked bad screenshots, I've NEVER seen this tactic used before.:roll:

I agree with the blu-ray point ya made cause nothing comes close to blu-ray quality.

Crappy pics of gears are crappy though

Can't.Stop.Looking.At.ARM! :|

W1NGMAN-

Wow. Fail. I never see anybody claiming that they really can't notice any difference between Blu-Ray and DVD. However, I see a lot of claims that the difference isn't enough to warrant an upgrade at the current prices.

And I rarely see lems claiming there are noticable differences in most games. You picked out pictures with no differences anyway. In some games, the differences are noticable.

And you picked out the worst 360 pictures you could find. Lemmings could do the same thing.

Why do you say you own all three consoles as if it makes you fair in your opinions and leanings? (Your sig). It's quite clear you're a cow.

Gears 2 looks good. But no one can deny that it has texture issues.

Like I said before, posting bad screens of a good looking game like Gears of War 2 is not a good idea, watch Lems post better screens.

Gears 2 looks good. But no one can deny that it has texture issues.

MegajerkNYC

Wow. Fail. I never see anybody claiming that they really can't notice any difference between Blu-Ray and DVD. However, I see a lot of claims that the difference isn't enough to warrant an upgrade at the current prices. And I rarely see lems claiming there are noticable differences. You picked out pictures with no differences anyway. In some games, the differences are very noticable. And you picked out the worst 360 pictures you could find. Lemmings could do the same thing. Why do you pretend to own all three consoles? (Your sig). It's quite clear you're a cow.comeonthehoops

Were you here for resi 5? it was the biggest game at the time that lems pulled over cows for slighlty better looking graphics

gears does look like that up close.

[QUOTE="comeonthehoops"]Wow. Fail. I never see anybody claiming that they really can't notice any difference between Blu-Ray and DVD. However, I see a lot of claims that the difference isn't enough to warrant an upgrade at the current prices. And I rarely see lems claiming there are noticable differences. You picked out pictures with no differences anyway. In some games, the differences are very noticable. And you picked out the worst 360 pictures you could find. Lemmings could do the same thing. Why do you pretend to own all three consoles? (Your sig). It's quite clear you're a cow.neo418

Were you here for resi 5? it was the biggest game at the time that lems pulled over cows for slighlty better looking graphics

gears does look like that up close.

ZoomZoom2490

Thats one ugly sob in gears pic you got :lol:

Try harder, I mean at least be fair when you want to get your point.

It's not like that KZ2 and UC pics you posted look remotely good anyway.

KZ2 look awesome alright...(sarcasm)

Thats one ugly sob in gears pic you got :lol:

Try harder, I mean at least be fair when you want to get your point.

Gears 2 looks good. But no one can deny that it has texture issues.

its interesting how cows seem so certain of the PS3s graphical superiority in these threads, yet have to add blur and resize screens of games like Forza 3 before criticising them, it just seems a little inconsistent to me.

Thats one ugly sob in gears pic you got :lol:

Try harder, I mean at least be fair when you want to get your point.

HAZE-Unit

I've played GeoW2 and no way does it ever come close to looking like that screenshot.

[QUOTE="comeonthehoops"]Wow. Fail. I never see anybody claiming that they really can't notice any difference between Blu-Ray and DVD. However, I see a lot of claims that the difference isn't enough to warrant an upgrade at the current prices. And I rarely see lems claiming there are noticable differences. You picked out pictures with no differences anyway. In some games, the differences are very noticable. And you picked out the worst 360 pictures you could find. Lemmings could do the same thing. Why do you pretend to own all three consoles? (Your sig). It's quite clear you're a cow.neo418

Were you here for resi 5? it was the biggest game at the time that lems pulled over cows for slighlty better looking graphics

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]

Thats one ugly sob in gears pic you got :lol:

Try harder, I mean at least be fair when you want to get your point.

W1NGMAN-

I've played GeoW2 and no way does it ever come close to looking like that screenshot.

[QUOTE="neo418"]

[QUOTE="comeonthehoops"]Wow. Fail. I never see anybody claiming that they really can't notice any difference between Blu-Ray and DVD. However, I see a lot of claims that the difference isn't enough to warrant an upgrade at the current prices. And I rarely see lems claiming there are noticable differences. You picked out pictures with no differences anyway. In some games, the differences are very noticable. And you picked out the worst 360 pictures you could find. Lemmings could do the same thing. Why do you pretend to own all three consoles? (Your sig). It's quite clear you're a cow.comeonthehoops

Were you here for resi 5? it was the biggest game at the time that lems pulled over cows for slighlty better looking graphics

The thing is cows pretend like there games are leagues better graphically, and they are not, so we retaliate. RE5 PS3 has slightly worse textures, QAA(while 360 has 4xAA), and the 360 version has a better frame rate... So you can't really tell the difference, but they are still there and they tell you things about the consoles.

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]

Thats one ugly sob in gears pic you got :lol:

Try harder, I mean at least be fair when you want to get your point.

ZoomZoom2490

Gameplay looks slightly different so here is a pic before people start whining.

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]

Thats one ugly sob in gears pic you got :lol:

Try harder, I mean at least be fair when you want to get your point.

mitu123

I've played GeoW2 and no way does it ever come close to looking like that screenshot.

It can't be gameplay especially if that's Gears 1....cause that pic blows anything I played in GeoW2 out of the water.

[QUOTE="mitu123"][QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

I've played GeoW2 and no way does it ever come close to looking like that screenshot.

W1NGMAN-

It can't be gameplay especially if that's Gears 1....cause that pic blows anything I played in GeoW2 out of the water.

Doesn't really look that different TBH.

Why are people complaining about the Gears 2 pic and not the Uncharted one?
Both are extreme close-ups that aren't relative to actual gameplay.

It's probably a screenshot from the pc version of gears1, since those big monster guys weren't in the console one.

[QUOTE="mitu123"][QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

I've played GeoW2 and no way does it ever come close to looking like that screenshot.

W1NGMAN-

It can't be gameplay especially if that's Gears 1....cause that pic blows anything I played in GeoW2 out of the water.

In many instances of multiplats, the 360 version will have better AA but the PS3 version will have far less pop-in. You won't ever hear Eurogamer ever talking about texture pop in though. But who cares what they think, they don't even try to hide their bias.

The multiplats look the same. 99.99% of the time.

Yes I prefer my PS3 but that doesn't mean I'm not rooting for great exclusive games to play on my 360. That doesn't change the fact that the 360 had a better exclusive game lineup in 2005 then it does in 2009.

[QUOTE="mitu123"][QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

I've played GeoW2 and no way does it ever come close to looking like that screenshot.

W1NGMAN-

It can't be gameplay especially if that's Gears 1....cause that pic blows anything I played in GeoW2 out of the water.

It's probably a screenshot from the pc version of gears1, since those big monster guys weren't in the console one.

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

[QUOTE="mitu123"] That screen is from Gears 1, and is only a bullshot.topgunmv

It can't be gameplay especially if that's Gears 1....cause that pic blows anything I played in GeoW2 out of the water.

That sounds much more reasonable.

MegajerkNYC, I agree that 2005 does look better than 2009 for 360 exclusives, LOL.

Cherrypicked screenshots and BR/DVD "movie" comparisons FTL

• If you're going to have a graphics argument, you pick the best screenshots from each game. It's a given all games are going to have some texture issues here and there
• Don't generalize all 360 owners, they have opinions which differ and vary

most multiplats do look better on the 360it's a fact....Bluray does look better than DVD it's a fact.....can't compare exclusives cuz I'm sure anything the ps3 can do the 360 can do and visa versa

It doesnt matter how insignifigent the graphics between the PS3 and 360 MP are. All that matters is that the cheaper console plays those MP just a tad bit better. NJ on picking terrible Gears 2 pic btw.

I'm sorry, but this thread is full of fail.

If you're going to do comparisons then pick gameplay screenshots from games, not shots set up to look their worst or best.

Thats one ugly sob in gears pic you got :lol:

Try harder, I mean at least be fair when you want to get your point.

HAZE-Unit

EVERYONE STOP, ITS SOMEHOW A TRAP DONT FALL IN IT OMG CAPS LOCK!

at topic creator: