When Title Fight fails it will prove how overrated Super Smash Bros is as a game

I love Nintendo's systems but Super Smash Bros main appeal is as a party game with all the characters together. The gameplay is not fun or fair and the balance is laughable.

No other company will be able to pull Super Smash Bros off because Super Smash Bros is only fun because the cast. Take away the cast and add another and you have a mediocre game.

True, but as long as I can have Samus, Ganon, Ness and Kirby mixing it up, its like the Expendables :cool:

Does the actual game even exist still?

Tittle Fight? never heard of itNengo_Flow

It's some rumored fighting game that started to appear as a rumor in early december.

People who say it has nothing to do with skill are usually the people losing.Eponique

[QUOTE="Eponique"]People who say it has nothing to do with skill are usually the people losing.shadowchronicle

My cousins know how to skillfully use the items in any SSB game.

Does the actual game even exist still?

super600

Pretty much... Unless some guy constructed character models of Sweet Tooth and that chick from heavenly sword and made 8 pages of interviews up lol.

Plus a dev deleted their Twitter when revealed.

Funny thing is that based off the reveal they are going to base alot of it on SSBB so when the game comes out it will show how the game is not a competitive fighter and has joke gameplay. I mean I feel bad that this developer is going to have this game on their record but it will shut the Smash Bros fans up in fighting game discussions.

Tekken, DOA, Moral Kombat, Street Fighter, or King of Fighters for the Wii U > Super Smash Bros

[QUOTE="super600"]

Does the actual game even exist still?

Banjo_Kongfooie

Pretty much... Unless some guy constructed character models of Sweet Tooth and that chick from heavenly sword and made 8 pages of interviews up lol.

Plus a dev deleted their Twitter when revealed.

Funny thing is that based off the reveal they are going to base alot of it on SSBB so when the game comes out it will show how the game is not a competitive fighter and has joke gameplay. I mean I feel bad that this developer is going to have this game on their record but it will shut the Smash Bros fans up in fighting game discussions.

Tekken, DOA, Moral Kombat, Street Fighter, or King of Fighters for the Wii U > Super Smash Bros

Wasn't there saying that the fighting style would be similar to MK rather than SSB?

[QUOTE="Eponique"]People who say it has nothing to do with skill are usually the people losing.shadowchronicle

you just suck at smash brothers is allZumaJones07

Lol you will see when this game comes out to 6 scores... Super Smash Bros gets scored based on content, nostalgia, and fun not gameplay.

The original did not do outstanding on gamespot.

Melee has the best gameplay of the series (not saying much yet Brawl outscores it because of what is reviewed).

Again Sony does not have the Nostalgia to pull off super smash and it will show how shallow the gameplay is when the game flops.

The fact that the developers are fans of the smash games and are basing it off of the smash games (essentially copying the gameplay) makes this exposation inevitable.

[QUOTE="shadowchronicle"][QUOTE="Eponique"]People who say it has nothing to do with skill are usually the people losing.HarlockJC

Wasn't there saying that the fighting style would be similar to MK rather than SSB?D4W1L4H

Wasn't there saying that the fighting style would be similar to MK rather than SSB?

D4W1L4H

Nope the dev even compares characters to Brawl characters...

Kratos - Icarus

Snake- Drake

etc.

It is actually pretty funny they do not pretend to copy it... The only thing different is basically 3 levels for the smash attacks and the smash builds up I think rather than the orb.

So there will be gameplay differences but not large enough for Smash fans to argue that the reason it will fail is not because the core gameplay and how shallow it is.

Super Smash Bros gets scored based on content, nostalgia,

Banjo_Kongfooie

I love Nintendo's systems but Super Smash Bros main appeal is as a party game with all the characters together. The gameplay is not fun or fair and the balance is laughable.

No other company will be able to pull Super Smash Bros off because Super Smash Bros is only fun because the cast. Take away the cast and add another and you have a mediocre game.

Banjo_Kongfooie

[QUOTE="Banjo_Kongfooie"] Super Smash Bros gets scored based on content, nostalgia,

HarlockJC

Not Zelda, mario, etc. Super Smash Bros. in specific.
Those other games have good gameplay... Super Smash Bros has shallow repetitive gameplay. If it was a party game I would understand the score but it claims to be a fighting game.

3 things

1: "Title Fight", not even confirmed yet.

2:"Title Fight" combat sty le not confirmed yet (or even hinted at). Could play like Tekken, Street Fighter, or Soul Caliber

3:NINTENDO NOT THE ONLY COMPANY TO EVER DO A COMPANY IP FIGHTING GAME!Tons of Japanese companies have done these. Why can't Sony

[QUOTE="super600"]

Does the actual game even exist still?

Banjo_Kongfooie

Pretty much... Unless some guy constructed character models of Sweet Tooth and that chick from heavenly sword and made 8 pages of interviews up lol.

Plus a dev deleted their Twitter when revealed.

Funny thing is that based off the reveal they are going to base alot of it on SSBB so when the game comes out it will show how the game is not a competitive fighter and has joke gameplay. I mean I feel bad that this developer is going to have this game on their record but it will shut the Smash Bros fans up in fighting game discussions.

Tekken, DOA, Moral Kombat, Street Fighter, or King of Fighters for the Wii U > Super Smash Bros

I doubt the actual game will come out anytime soon.

Again Sony does not have the Nostalgia to pull off super smash and it will show how shallow the gameplay is when the game flops.

Banjo_Kongfooie

Um what? Just because another company can't replicate Super Smash Bros. success doesn't mean that Super Smash Bros. is overrated in the least... Nintendo spends alot of time perfecting these games and brings them out when they are ready to be released. Just look how long it took to get Super Smash Bros. Brawl out the door and how much it was pushed back to make sure it is done right. Not only that but Super Smash Bros. does quite well with its own tournaments. The Super Smash Bros. series has quite abit more going for it than just the character lineup and just because another company fails to copy Nintendo's formula doesn't mean Smash Bros. is overrated. If that were true then anytime a developer tries to go for the same thing another developer did it would prove the original series was overrated and not that great which we all know isn't the case. This thread is full of fail logic.kejigoto

Of course Nintendo spent alot of time "perfecting" Brawl... Which is why the game is so balanced :P .

If one company could not replicate Super Smash Bros that would be understandable. Notice how little attempts there are?

Sony has become reckless and appearently think their characters are nostalgic enough for a compiliation... Appearently Move Heroes did not send them a message...

[QUOTE="super600"][QUOTE="shadowchronicle"] They should remove the items and then I'll start saying it requires skills.shadowchronicle

I talking about knowing how to use the items you get skillfully.My cousins know how to catch any items I throw at them in SSBB.

If it was a party game I would understand the score but it claims to be a fighting game.

Banjo_Kongfooie

Not Zelda, mario, etc. Super Smash Bros. in specific. Banjo_Kongfooie

Those other games have good gameplay... Super Smash Bros has shallow repetitive gameplay. If it was a party game I would understand the score but it claims to be a fighting game.

Banjo_Kongfooie

I have a question, why the hell did they put snake in ssbm?shadowchronicle

I have a question, why the hell did they put snake in ssbm?shadowchronicle

It was requested by the fans of the MGS games and ninty made a deal with konami to put him in the game.

I love Nintendo's systems but Super Smash Bros main appeal is as a party game with all the characters together. The gameplay is not fun or fair and the balance is laughable.

No other company will be able to pull Super Smash Bros off because Super Smash Bros is only fun because the cast. Take away the cast and add another and you have a mediocre game.

Banjo_Kongfooie

Lol you will see when this game comes out to 6 scores... Super Smash Bros gets scored based on content, nostalgia, and fun not gameplay.

The original did not do outstanding on gamespot.

Melee has the best gameplay of the series (not saying much yet Brawl outscores it because of what is reviewed).

Again Sony does not have the Nostalgia to pull off super smash and it will show how shallow the gameplay is when the game flops.

The fact that the developers are fans of the smash games and are basing it off of the smash games (essentially copying the gameplay) makes this exposation inevitable.

Banjo_Kongfooie

If Title Fight is real, I can't see it being better then SSBB. Imo, very few fighting games are as good as SSBB.

3 things

1: "Title Fight", not even confirmed yet.

2:"Title Fight" combat sty le not confirmed yet (or even hinted at). Could play like Tekken, Street Fighter, or Soul Caliber

3:NINTENDO NOT THE ONLY COMPANY TO EVER DO A COMPANY IP FIGHTING GAME!Tons of Japanese companies have done these. Why can't Sony

dercoo

Its all but officially confirmed...

There is plenty to go on and all the leaks point to Super Smash Bros.

Yes you are right but not many games have done one that plays like Super Smash where you knock your opponents off the edge and if they have then they were not successful.

I admit it is a bold move by Sony but not in the good way.

1) It is a blatant rip off of Super Smash Bros.

2) Sony does not have the history Nintendo has.

3) The core concept of Smash Bros is a shallow content heavy nostalgia fest.

Microsoft would not be able to pull it off either I admit but atleast they have masterchief...

[QUOTE="kejigoto"] Um what? Just because another company can't replicate Super Smash Bros. success doesn't mean that Super Smash Bros. is overrated in the least... Nintendo spends alot of time perfecting these games and brings them out when they are ready to be released. Just look how long it took to get Super Smash Bros. Brawl out the door and how much it was pushed back to make sure it is done right. Not only that but Super Smash Bros. does quite well with its own tournaments. The Super Smash Bros. series has quite abit more going for it than just the character lineup and just because another company fails to copy Nintendo's formula doesn't mean Smash Bros. is overrated. If that were true then anytime a developer tries to go for the same thing another developer did it would prove the original series was overrated and not that great which we all know isn't the case. This thread is full of fail logic.Banjo_Kongfooie

Of course Nintendo spent alot of time "perfecting" Brawl... Which is why the game is so balanced :P .

If one company could not replicate Super Smash Bros that would be understandable. Notice how little attempts there are?

Sony has become reckless and appearently think their characters are nostalgic enough for a compiliation... Appearently Move Heroes did not send them a message...

You're still making a huge assumption here, plus there is a very successful series in Japan that uses a similar approach as Smash Bros. called Jump Ultimate Stars. Again because one company can't replicate it doesn't mean the original is overrated. And the reason there are so few attempts is because no one really has a stable of characters to draw on like Nintendo does.The lineup is a bonus but there is still a solid game beyond that.

Again fail logic is fail.

Also it is spelled apparently.

[QUOTE="shadowchronicle"]I have a question, why the hell did they put snake in ssbm?super600

It was requested by the fans of the MGS games and ninty made a deal with konami to put him in the game.

Super Smash Brothers is fun to play. Whether or not its overated won't change that is makes a great semi competitve accessible fighter for people to play.

You're still making a huge assumption here, plus there is a very successful series in Japan that uses a similar approach as Smash Bros. called Jump Ultimate Stars. Again because one company can't replicate it doesn't mean the original is overrated. And the reason there are so few attempts is because no one really has a stable of characters to draw on like Nintendo does.The lineup is a bonus but there is still a solid game beyond that.

Again fail logic is fail.

Also it is spelled apparently.

kejigoto

TC just sucks at Smash Bros

Again Sony will perfect something that is old and repeated a 100 times. That will be the worst case scenario !!!

Banjo Kongfooie, the game is not even confirmed but you creat a topic how it will flop ?!? Banjo Kongfooie

[QUOTE="Banjo_Kongfooie"]

Not Zelda, mario, etc. Super Smash Bros. in specific. HarlockJC

Those other games have good gameplay... Super Smash Bros has shallow repetitive gameplay. If it was a party game I would understand the score but it claims to be a fighting game.

Banjo_Kongfooie

1) I never said Gamespot did alone or that they have nostalgia of Super Smash Bros.

The first one did not do stellar so why would they.

I am saying a core element of super smash is nostalgia. Just like a core element of DOAXB2 is sex appeal...

2) Not really...

1) I never said Gamespot did alone or that they have nostalgia of Super Smash Bros.

The first one did not do stellar so why would they.

I am saying a core element of super smash is nostalgia. Just like a core element of DOAXB2 is sex appeal...

2) Not really...

Banjo_Kongfooie

They should remove the items and then I'll start saying it requires skills.shadowchronicle

[QUOTE="super600"]

[QUOTE="shadowchronicle"]I have a question, why the hell did they put snake in ssbm?HarlockJC

It was requested by the fans of the MGS games and ninty made a deal with konami to put him in the game.

I never knew that part.

[QUOTE="shadowchronicle"]They should remove the items and then I'll start saying it requires skills.Miroku32

I have a question, why the hell did they put snake in ssbm?shadowchronicle

I think you mean SSBB. And Hideo Kojima asked them to put Snake in a Smash Bros. game during Melee's development.

[QUOTE="Eponique"]People who say it has nothing to do with skill are usually the people losing.shadowchronicle