Wow, new Game Informer Top 200 of all time list is polarizing.

Yeah...I'm pretty bothered by the lack of Halo 3 and GTA 4 (C'mon, you gotta give Rock* some credit of making a world like that ATLEAST).

gmc2u_64

[QUOTE="cdav89"]

The fact that MGS 2 is on that list rather than MGS 3 invalidates it for me

caseypayne69

Including me. MGS3, for me, is where the series went wrong.

GTA3 is number 4?! that game got boring after like, 2 hours!

VendettaRed07

The list seems so random, I wonder how long they spent putting it together. The ratings don't seem to make much sense to me, I can't really think of a single gamer with tastes like the one suggested in the list. There's no real pattern, and nothing about it is predictable. I suppose it's the same for all lists, but it just seems as if they forgot alot and mabye should have spent more time putting it together. I mean it could be a genuinely well compiled list, and I know everyone has diffrent tastes, but it just seems so random with some of the choices and some of the games that arn't even mentioned, like some the Rare classics for example.

[QUOTE="Arach666"]

That is avery questionable list.

MajorGamer531

Im not listing all 200 obviously, but I will list some system wars favorites and some shockers(?)

Top 10

1. The legend of Zelda

2. Super Mario Bros.

3. Tetris

4. GTA3

5. Half-Life 2

6. Doom

7. Metroid

8. Final Fantasy III (Snes)

9. Super Mario 3

10. Ms. Pac Man

Now some notables...

20. OOT (and was the 3rd highest ranked zelda game in back of Link to the past at 12.

14. COD4

15. FF7 (thats gonna make a few people upset :) )

39. Halo CE

Both MGS1 (19) and MGS2 (50) fared better than MGS4 (108 ) which was also beaten on the same page by Batman AA (104)

56. Uncharted 2

54. KOTOR

58. Mass Effect

85. Metroid Prime

65. Fallout 3 and it put to shame the rest of the fallout installments.

Enjoy folks... should make for some interesting discussion.

TheEroica

Halo 3 > Everything else

This list sucks!

Chepocles

What is this I don't even-