Your Personal 10/10's of the Gens

What were the games you would personally give a 10/10 of the 7th gen?

On my personal rating scale 10 doesn't mean perfect and it's a 10-point scale.  This rating is based on how well it was made for it's genre, in context of it's release date.

Gears of War

Bioshock

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

The Last of Us

Super Mario Galaxy

Super Mario Galaxy 2

Metroid Prime Trilogy

Red Dead Redemption

The Orange Box

Super Meat Boy

Advance Wars: Dual Strike 

Portal 2

Red Dead Redemption

Uncharted 2

The Last of Us

Super Mario Galaxy 2

The Last of Us

Fallout 3

Dark Souls

Batman Arkham Asylum

The Witcher 2

Since I don't use 9.5's and 9.7's, I have quite a number of 10's.

tomb raider - 2013

Far Cry 3

Metro Last Light

For comparison

10's of the 6th gen:

Soul-Calibur

Advance Wars

Golden Sun

Halo: Combat Evolved

Grand Theft Auto III

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

Half-Life 2

Metroid Prime

Eternal Darkness: Sanity Requiem

Shadow of the Collosus

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty

Pikmin 2

Resident Evil 4

Closest ones would be DOTA 2 and Dark Souls, but no 10/10's from me. They'd be 9.8 and 9.7. :Ptagyhag

lol so picky.  i found a 100 point scale too complicated for me.

Dota 2 lost a point from me for it's inaccessibility to new players.

For last gen, I'd have: 

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
Metroid Prime
Metroid Prime 2: Echoes
Super Smash Bros. Melee
Mario Kart Double Dash
Halo: Combat Evolved
God of War
God of War II
Halo 2
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
Rise of Nations 

The only game I agve a perfect 10 this gen was Dark souls, but even then I can point out several flaws/disappointments about the game

[QUOTE="tagyhag"]Closest ones would be DOTA 2 and Dark Souls, but no 10/10's from me. They'd be 9.8 and 9.7. :Pdrekula2

lol so picky.  i found a 100 point scale too complicated for me.

Dota 2 lost a point from me for it's inaccessibility to new players.

Gears of War 3

Halo Reach

Super Mario Galaxy

GTA IV

Left 4 Dead 2

Fable II

Super Smash Bros. Brawl

Metroid Prime 3

Assassins creed 2, Portal 2, 9 hours 9 persons 9 doors, Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney.

Closest ones would be DOTA 2 and Dark Souls, but no 10/10's from me. They'd be 9.8 and 9.7. :Ptagyhag

[QUOTE="drekula2"]

[QUOTE="tagyhag"]Closest ones would be DOTA 2 and Dark Souls, but no 10/10's from me. They'd be 9.8 and 9.7. :Ptagyhag

lol so picky.  i found a 100 point scale too complicated for me.

Dota 2 lost a point from me for it's inaccessibility to new players.

yea so like a 10 for you would have to have the impact of something like ocarina of time or a link to the past

Fire Emblem:Awakening

Demon/Dark souls

Amnesia the dark descent

Thats about it.

Super Mario Galaxy 2
Metroid Prime Trilogy
Sonic CD HD Remake
Streets of Rage Remake
Streets of Rage Vintage Collection

• Bioshock
• Bioshock Infinite
• Fallout 3
• Red Dead Redemption
• Halo 3
• Brutal Legend
• Pokemon Soulsilver
• Assassin's Creed 2
• Castle Crashers
• Max Payne 3
• Batman Arkham City
• Rock Band 3
• Left 4 Dead 2

Honerable Mentions (The so close yet so far club)

• SSX
• Black Ops
• Halo 4
• Halo Reach
• Batman Arkham Asylum
• Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
• Bioshock 2
• Fable 3

Either, I'm easily amused, or tons of great games came out

yea so like a 10 for you would have to have the impact of something like ocarina of time or a link to the past

drekula2

Yeah something like that, plus be nearly flawless. Super picky but it's an arbitrary scale so meh. :lol:

I don't give tens all that easy. A ten on a ten point scale to me is almost flawless. The orange box is about the only thing I can give a ten to.cainetao11

But you can easily give Mark Cerny a 10/10 for his design of the PS4, right?

I'd give Microsoft a 2/10 for the Xbox ONE architecture.

The Last of Us

Red Dead Redemption

Mass Effect

Skyrim

Team Fotress 2 and Dark Souls. Oh, and Bioshock 2.

I'm amazed at how generous some people are with their perfect scores. meetroid8

10 =/= perfect , in my eyes.

nothing is perfect

for me, skyward was an 8.

it felt too dragged out.  had they cut out the fluff and reduced the 45 hour adventure to about 30, it would have easily been a 10, because aside from the backtracking and repetition, everything else was awesome.

-Batman Arkham City

-Donkey Kong Country Returns

Both are absolutely superb and as close to perfection as I've seen any game reach. They are each at the top of their respective genres IMHO and that's why I feel they merit their respective scores.

The Last of Us

Metroid Prime 3: Corruption

Fallout 3

Mass Effect 2

Super Mario Galaxy

Bioshock Infinite

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

Halo 4

The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword

Silent Hill Shattered Memories 

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

Xenoblade Chronicles

There are very very few games I would give a perfect 10 but lets say 9.5-10.

The last of us

Uncharted 2

Dark Souls

Super Street Fighter 4

Batman arkham asylum

Portal 2

Shadows of the damned

If we're going by the Gamespot definition that a 10 is "Prime" and not perfect, then:

• MGS4
• SMG2
• Fallout: New Vegas
• Red Dead Redemption

• GTA: Vice City
• Metroid Prime
• Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem
• Star Wars Battlefront 2
• Resident Evil 4
• (and honesetly, I have to give sympathy for GS's choice of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3.  Maybe not Prime but almost)

Probably 5th gen would only be N64 titles :P

There are very very few games I would give a perfect 10 but lets say 9.5-10.

The last of us

Uncharted 2

Dark Souls

Super Street Fighter 4

Batman arkham asylum

Portal 2

Shadows of the damned

 

beganoo

Damn, I forgot Portal 2.  I would give that a 10 as well, but I'll just leave this comment rather than editting my other one.