Your Personal 10/10's of the Gens

-Batman Arkham City

-Donkey Kong Country Returns

Both are absolutely superb and as close to perfection as I've seen any game reach. They are each at the top of their respective genres IMHO and that's why I feel they merit their respective scores.

Pikminmaniac

Hmm, while I have REALLY loved some games this generation, there hasn't been any I could necessarily feel comfortable giving a 10 as they could have definitely been improved on.

The game I would be the most comfortable giving such an honor to would be Bioshock Infinite. Columbia is such an awesome world and that story with that ending was just spectacular.

Even with that game though there could have been some major improvements made...

In terms of sheer fun factor, Left 4 Dead 1 would also be a candidate for me. Game was very flawed but still by far the BEST multiplayer console game I have ever played. Only multiplayer games in general that I would say competed were UT2004 and WoW.

bioshock infinite to me is a 9.  the combat while really enjoyable was a bit safe.  and the vigors were just clones of each other.

for me, skyward was an 8.

it felt too dragged out.  had they cut out the fluff and reduced the 45 hour adventure to about 30, it would have easily been a 10, because aside from the backtracking and repetition, everything else was awesome.

drekula2

[QUOTE="drekula2"]

for me, skyward was an 8.

it felt too dragged out.  had they cut out the fluff and reduced the 45 hour adventure to about 30, it would have easily been a 10, because aside from the backtracking and repetition, everything else was awesome.

charizard1605

Super Mario Galaxy 2 is the only one.

These are all the 10 out of 10 scores I've given:

Chrono Trigger (1995)

Super Mario 64 (1996)

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (1997)

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1998)

Halo: Combat Evolved (2001)

Metroid Prime (2002)

Resident Evil 4 (2005)

Super Mario Galaxy 2 (2010)

Those are the titles I wouldn't change for the world (so far).  There are still a lot of games I have yet to play.

[QUOTE="drekula2"]

for me, skyward was an 8.

it felt too dragged out.  had they cut out the fluff and reduced the 45 hour adventure to about 30, it would have easily been a 10, because aside from the backtracking and repetition, everything else was awesome.

charizard1605

Ridiculous.  Game is sick.  Just finished the Silent Realm in Lanayru.  Loving every minute of it.

bioshock 

bayonetta

fable 2

I don't know if I'd classify them as 10/10's because even my most favorite games have some flaws, but the absolute gems I've experienced this gen:

• Valkyria Chronicles
• Persona 4 Golden/Persona 4
• Fallout 3
• Ni no Kuni
• 999
• SMT IV
• Pikmin 3

Mass Effect 2 
Batman Arkham City 

None, I think every game can be better, none are perfect. However the closest games I would have put to perfect where Quake III Arena, Everquest 1 ( before it was bastardised ), System Shock 2, AVP2, FFVII  and Shenmue 1/2.

Of course standards change but back when these games where released they raised the bar for my standards of what a good game should be.

There aren't really many. 

- Dark Souls

- The Last of Us

That's my complete list for this gen.

Fez

Dark Souls

The Walkind Dead

Portal 2

Halo 3

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

Super Mario Galaxy 2 is the only one.

These are all the 10 out of 10 scores I've given:

Chrono Trigger (1995)

Super Mario 64 (1996)

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (1997)

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1998)

Halo: Combat Evolved (2001)

Metroid Prime (2002)

Resident Evil 4 (2005)

Super Mario Galaxy 2 (2010)

Those are the titles I wouldn't change for the world (so far).  There are still a lot of games I have yet to play.

NeonNinja

Metal Gear Solid 4.

• Halo 3
• GTAIV
• GTAV
• Bioshock
• TLOU
• Modern Warfare

Arkham City and The Last of Us

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

Sweenix

[QUOTE="Sweenix"]

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

MacBoomStick

None. drinkerofjuice

I can think of a few 9/10's though, but all fell short of perfection.

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

Sweenix

:lol:

Uncharted 2

The Last of Us

Dark Souls

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

Sweenix

Best list I've ever seen.

[QUOTE="Sweenix"]

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

Michael0134567

Best list I've ever seen.

I've rated most of my games here on Gamespot on the 100 point scale that Gamespot originally had, and the .5 scale that they had until recently. For the thread, I'll follow you TC and show what games I'd give a 10/10 on a 10 point scale. Of course a 10 isn't a perfect game as there is no such thing, so stop being so fussy erryone. :P 

7th Gen

• Batman: Arkham City
• The Last of Us
• Super Mario Galaxy 2
• The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess (although I played this on Gamecube originally)
• Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
• Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
• Red Dead Redemption
• Journey

6th Gen

• Final Fantasy XII
• Resident Evil 4
• Super Smash Bros Melee
• Metroid Prime
• Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence

its hard for me to give a 10 to any game as there is allways SOMETHING that dissapoints me a little about every game i play...  the ones that come closest though this gen:

Dota 2

Counterstrike source (pre orangebox engine)

Fire emblem awakening

Tactics ogre

Starcraft 2

Super mario galaxy 2

havent played it yet but from what ive seen GTA 5 will be on this list too

What bothers me is gens before this My list would be much much longer...

Batman: Arkham City

Honest to god that's the only game that comes to mind that I didn't have any complaints about. It was grand. Even my favorite game from this gen, Nier, has it's fair share of flaws, but as far as I'm concerned Arkham City is basically perfect.

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

Sweenix

Arkham City, TLOUSushiglutton

My list exactly.

Batman: Arkham City

Honest to god that's the only game that comes to mind that I didn't have any complaints about. It was grand. Even my favorite game from this gen, Nier, has it's fair share of flaws, but as far as I'm concerned Arkham City is basically perfect.

Master_ShakeXXX

That's the thing about rating a game a 10. Giving a game a 10 doesn't mean a game is perfect, nor does it mean it is your favorite game. I gave MGS4 a 10 and it isn't even in my top 10 games of this gen. In fact, some of my favorites are games I've given a score below 9.0, like Nier. 

[QUOTE="Sweenix"]

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

freedomfreak

OG Final Fantasy 14 was pretty amazing. I can't for the life of me understand why everybody rated it 1s and 2s.

[QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"]

Batman: Arkham City

Honest to god that's the only game that comes to mind that I didn't have any complaints about. It was grand. Even my favorite game from this gen, Nier, has it's fair share of flaws, but as far as I'm concerned Arkham City is basically perfect.

Zassimick

That's the thing about rating a game a 10. Giving a game a 10 doesn't mean a game is perfect, nor does it mean it is your favorite game. I gave MGS4 a 10 and it isn't even in my top 10 games of this gen. In fact, some of my favorites are games I've given a score below 9.0, like Nier. 

I was mostly in the honey moon period for a lot of the games that I rated 10. I know for a fact that, if I played it today, I wouldn't give MGS4 a 10, but I did back then XD. Arkham City though, dat shit deserves a freakin 10.

[QUOTE="Sweenix"]

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

freedomfreak

Since we're apparently all going back in time

Last gen:

This gen:

Just the two Galaxy games.

Wait, are we doing just this gen or for all time?

[QUOTE="drekula2"]

for me, skyward was an 8.

it felt too dragged out.  had they cut out the fluff and reduced the 45 hour adventure to about 30, it would have easily been a 10, because aside from the backtracking and repetition, everything else was awesome.

charizard1605

What about 9.5 for being proof of the Wii concept. I hold Skyward Sword in high regard because of how well it incorperated quality motion controls into the game. It felt like a playground to interact with 1:1. There is nothing like it on the market. At least not to the degree and quality of Skyward Sword.

I was let down when I first played the game because I was looking at it as a Zelda, but that was wrong IMHO. It something different. They took a very different approach to this game and as soon as I started looking at it for its own merits did I see how brilliant it is. No, it doesn't have certain aspects that I loved from past Zelda games, but it offers a lot of quality aspects that no other Zelda had.