Your Personal 10/10's of the Gens

• Sin & Punishment: Star Succesor
• Super Mario Galaxy 2
• Virtua Fighter 5: Final Showdown
• Guilty Gear XX A Core Plus

I'm gonna go back in time aswell, 10/10 games from the 6th generation.

• Panzer Dragoon Orta
• Burnout 3: Takedown
• Devil May Cry 3: Special Edition

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="drekula2"]

for me, skyward was an 8.

it felt too dragged out.  had they cut out the fluff and reduced the 45 hour adventure to about 30, it would have easily been a 10, because aside from the backtracking and repetition, everything else was awesome.

Pikminmaniac

What about 9.5 for being proof of the Wii concept. I hold Skyward Sword in high regard because of how well it incorperated quality motion controls into the game. It felt like a playground to interact with 1:1. There is nothing like it on the market. At least not to the degree and quality of Skyward Sword.

I was let down when I first played the game because I was looking at it as a Zelda, but that was wrong IMHO. It something different. They took a very different approach to this game and as soon as I started looking at it for its own merits did I see how brilliant it is. No, it doesn't have certain aspects that I loved from past Zelda games, but it offers a lot of quality aspects that no other Zelda had.

I do factor in the controls as it's greatest strength.  Even though, despite having complete freedom with the controls, you were almost always restricted to slashing in certain ways, making it only superficially different than an analog stick.

These were the closest to perfection I can think of. Both were certainly "prime" if we were to go with GS's description of a 10.

Wow, you're nice.Michael0134567

Killzone 2

battlefield 3

call of duty mw2

fallout: new vegas (- the bugs)

• Sin & Punishment: Star Succesor
• Super Mario Galaxy 2
• Virtua Fighter 5: Final Showdown
• Guilty Gear XX A Core Plus

I'm gonna go back in time aswell, 10/10 games from the 6th generation.

• Panzer Dragoon Orta
• Burnout 3: Takedown
• Devil May Cry 3: Special Edition

Lucianu

I'm digging the Panzer Dragoon love!  I've got it at a 9.5 but I view it as the greatest on-rails shooter ever made.  It's a top-quality game.

Halo 3

Dark souls

Bioshock 1

Red dead dem

Oblivion

Thoses are the games that I absolutely enjoyed

I have a lot of memorable games throughout the generations. I don't go by a "score" but by how the game made me feel and or how much I played it.  Here are some of my best games and memories:

1. Super Mario Brothers-NES

2. Legend of Zelda- NES

3. Street Fighter 2-Arcade/SNES

4. Final Fight-Arcade/SNES

5. Mike Tysons Punchout-NES/Arcade

6. Super Mario 64- "Wow factor" for it's time

7. Legend of Zelda OoT- "Wow factor"

8. Halo Combat Evolved-Xbox

9. Soul Calibur-DC version. Unbelievable for it's time grahpically, gameplay..perfect.

10. Far Cry (PC) A true "Next Gen" experience in 2004

11. HL2 (PC Another "Wow factor" next gen experience in 2004 that STILL looks great today. (Played Loast Coast for fun last night and it's still beautiful)

12. Counter-Strike Source: Played this game more than probably any game I have ever had

13. FEAR PC 2005: Amazing engine and graphics for it's time and a scary game with perfect atmosphere.

14. Crysis 2007: Still a beautiful game and engine that really wasn't fully realized until years later when PCs could really play the game.  The world is so open and the environment was so destructible and could impact the way you attacked or approached a situation.  I recently downloaded and installed the 2013 release of BlackFire Mod and it only manipulates the lighting and let's you change the look on the fly with the press of a key.  It really brings out the brilliance of Crysis and makes it look damn near as good as Crysis 3 (PC version).

15. Fight Night Round 3: Sure not a great game score wise but a real showcase of  the PS3/360 when it came out with good online competition. 

16. Uncharted 2 (such an immersive game. Uncharted just was a bit boring and I wasn't wowed by the graphics as PC games were way ahead at that point.

17. Halo 3

18. L4D 1&2 (PC versions) for it's ridiculously addictive co-op and online multiplayer (survival)

19. Batman AA (PC)

20. Portal 2

21. Crysis 3- Mainly for the graphics. Just "wow." Almost didn't include this game.

22. Virtua Fighter 5: Final Showdown.  To me this is the perfect fighting game

23. Mortal Kombat 9 (PS3)

24. Killer Instinct (Arcade)

25. Killer Instinct Gold (N64)

26. Sonic the Hedgehog

27. Fight Night Champion (360 Version)

28. Elevator Action (NES) Such a great simple game for it's time

29. TMNT-SNES

30. Streets of Rage (Genesis)

31. Mortal Kombat 2 (Arcade and SNES)

32. Deus Ex: HR

I'm sure there are many more and these are in no particular order.  Just games that are memorable and or current with me that I play.  I am not big on "scores" as even if a game has many imperfections I might still be super fond of it for personal reasons.

none

Metal Gear Rising
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Assassin's Creed 2 

This gen?

Disgaea 3

Disgaea 4

ZHP

Yeah, I love NIS games :D

Metal Gear Rising
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Assassin's Creed 2 

Lord_Omikron666

I'm digging the Panzer Dragoon love!  I've got it at a 9.5 but I view it as the greatest on-rails shooter ever made.  It's a top-quality game.

NeonNinja

The quality and the replayability really is top of the line in its genre. Though the final reason why i don't hesitate at giving the game a 10/10 is that the developers really went out of their way with the content. Besides having the full original Panzer Dragoon as an unlockable (albeit aged quite a bit, it's still fun and has a fantastic soundtrack/atmosphere), there's a lot of other extra unlockables like extra bonus missions & sub-scenarios with different characters, a ton of artwork, a full encyclopedia of the Panzer Dragoon world (which is awesome for fans like me), and so on.

Easily worth buying an OG Xbox for.

euro truck simulator and sim 3

Duke Nukem forever

Ride to Hell Retribution

Fable 2

Modern Warfare 3

Haze

Well, since we're including games from previous gens as well, I'll just list the rest of my 10's.

TimeSplitters 2

Geist

Cave Story

F-Zero GX

Metroid Prime

Resident Evil (GC/Wii)

Metroid Prime 2

The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

Super Mario 64

Shadow of the Colossus

God of War II

Halo 

Halo 2

[QUOTE="Lord_Omikron666"]

Metal Gear Rising
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Assassin's Creed 2 

CJ_ofCamelot

I'm not sure I follow you

Dark Souls

Vanquish

Bayonetta

Super Mario Galaxy 2

Mass effect

The Witcher 2

Metro 2033

Deus Ex: HR

Dota 2

Starcraft 2

Gears of War

Condemened

Demon's Souls

Dark Souls

Uncharted 2

Super Mario Galaxy 1 & 2 are the only ones.

Almost: Batman Arkham Asylum/City and Bayonetta

For comparison

10's of the 6th gen:

Soul-Calibur

Advance Wars

Golden Sun

Halo: Combat Evolved

Grand Theft Auto III

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

Half-Life 2

Metroid Prime

Eternal Darkness: Sanity Requiem

Shadow of the Collosus

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty

Pikmin 2

Resident Evil 4

 

drekula2

Fine, all time:

• The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
• Final Fantasy IV
• Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings
• Rise of Nations
• The Sims 2
• The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
• Final Fantasy IX
• Pokemon Gold/Silver
• Metroid Prime
• Metroid Prime 2: Echoes
• Super Smash Bros. Melee
• Mario Kart Double Dash
• Halo: Combat Evolved
• God of War
• God of War II
• Halo 2
• Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
• Burnout 3: Takedown
• Sid Meier's Civilization V
• SimCity 3000

Tales of Graces F

Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD

Uncharted 2

Hatsune Miku

Final Fantasy XIV

Sweenix

Uncharted 2

Metal Gear Solid 4

Portal 2 came really close, but not quite.

Flash Back

MGS2: Sons of liberty

Street Fighter Alpha 2

Digital Devil Saga

Demon's Souls

Shenmue

TLOU

Grandia II

-Metal Gear Solid 4 - Pinnacle game this generation and Overall best.. everyone has that ONE fav MGS game.
-Mass Effect
-Demons Souls/Dark Souls
-Grand Theft Auto 4
-Assassins Creed 2
-Uncharted 2
-Dota 2
-Dead Space
-Gears of War
-Civ V
-Batman AC
-Command and Conquer 3
-The Last of Us
-Halo Combat Evolved
-Team Fortress 2
-RDR
-Call of Duty 4
-Infamous
-Street Fighter 4
-Little Big Planet
-Mirrors Edge
-Deus Ex HR

Best games in their respective genres, like horror, fighting, strategy, action adventure etc.
Not going back in time.

Best of the best and not for the kids but purely for the elitist gamers with superior hardware.

VRX racing simulation game
Battlefield 3 Simulator (where you feel pain when shot)

Am sure theres more.

Uncharted 2
Xenoblade Chronicles

Portal 2

Batman: Arkham City

The Walking Dead Episode 2: Starved for Help

....

- NieR -

....

foxhound_fox

• Red Dead: Redemption
• Grand Theft Auto IV
• Gone Home

You have got to be jokingGunSmith1_basic

Gears of war (original ONLY)

Left 4 Dead (Before all the stupid patches)

Dragon age Origins

[QUOTE="GunSmith1_basic"]You have got to be jokingfoxhound_fox

I'm not saying that NieR is an odd choice to enjoy.  It's just an odd choice to give a 10 to.  I wouldn't give a 10 to my favorite game of all time (Majora's Mask), because of the obvious flaws it has.

[QUOTE="NeonNinja"]

I'm digging the Panzer Dragoon love!  I've got it at a 9.5 but I view it as the greatest on-rails shooter ever made.  It's a top-quality game.

Lucianu

The quality and the replayability really is top of the line in its genre. Though the final reason why i don't hesitate at giving the game a 10/10 is that the developers really went out of their way with the content. Besides having the full original Panzer Dragoon as an unlockable (albeit aged quite a bit, it's still fun and has a fantastic soundtrack/atmosphere), there's a lot of other extra unlockables like extra bonus missions & sub-scenarios with different characters, a ton of artwork, a full encyclopedia of the Panzer Dragoon world (which is awesome for fans like me), and so on.

Easily worth buying an OG Xbox for.

Definitely.  The amount of content in Orta is ridiculous.  From the Episodeons to the side missions, and having the original Panzer Dragoon was also stellar for me.  Lots of love went into it, it's just a shame that SmileBit is no more.

I figured I would just read a few of these rather than ignore them like most people do. NieR is just such an odd choice considering that it feels like it wasn't even finished. I liked the game too. I played it through to the end. It's just got so many boring parts to it (ie travelling), parts that don't work the way they wanted to (ie sidequests), and parts that just shouldn't have existed at all (ie text adventure dungeon). I also feel like the plot had a few missed opportunities.

I'm not saying that NieR is an odd choice to enjoy.  It's just an odd choice to give a 10 to.  I wouldn't give a 10 to my favorite game of all time (Majora's Mask), because of the obvious flaws it has.

GunSmith1_basic