People have asked me this question on more than one occasion. I am currently running 8 laptops. OK; yes, it is excessive. But I rationalize that there is a reason for each one. OK...there's not. Not in any way more than the fact that I consider myself a self-funded online journalist. Since no company is lining up to send me free gear like they do the Engadgets and CNETs of the webosphere, I have to buy my own. Each does fulfill a function in as much as I use them to learn more about laptops, mobile technology, multi-media, and other tricks that I make my sometimes admittedly poor attempts to pass on to you.
The Gateway P-6860FX is a 17" gaming rig. I bought this one because I initially attempted to upgrade the preceding gaming laptop (an Asus Z96J 15.4") with a 17" HP dv9000-series rig. The HP proved unable to handle basic gaming at times, so I sold it and got the COMPAL IFL-90. But in the short time that I owned it, I became accustomed to and fond of the 17" display. So when these Gateway's hit the market at an incredible price point and were available at retail, I almost felt obliged to pick one up just because of the price.
It is lovely to watch movies on. With its two hard drive bays now populated with double 320GB hard drives, it rocks nearly as much storage as my two desktops, and is proof of the ability to capture the same capability in a desktop replacement as a true desktop. The storage is sufficient to hold its own encoded movie archive, as well as my full iTunes archive; a feat that I can not claim about my MacBook, which is the primary managing device of that iTunes archive. The Gateway has a full keyboard with numeric keypad, which makes it excellent for working in spreadsheets, like updating my workout log. The speakers are of decent quality, certainly not Altec Lansings or Harmon Kardons, but they are of great volume, which is actually more important to me in a laptop than quality, because I know that the limited space in a mobile form factor will always limit speaker quality. But the Gateway is also huge and heavy, with a power brick that is easily heavier than some of my other laptops themselves. If I could only keep one of them, it would not be this one because I have to be mobile. And the Gateway is impossible to work on when on a plane unless the seat next to me is unoccupied and I can place it on the adjacent tray table and turn to my side to work on it.
The COMPAL IFL-90 is a pretty amazing notebook for the price I picked it up at. It is my "normal" sized gaming rig, being equipped with a 15.4" screen. As mentioned earlier, it was purchased as the true successor to the Asus Z96J that I ran as my gaming rig from July of 2006 through August of 2007. The Asus got rolled early because I have a buddy who is the primary benefactor of my superseded gear, and he was about to deploy for a few months and was in bad need of a mobile gaming rig to take with him on the ship. Being the pal that I am, I agreed to sell the Asus to him and conduct my gaming rig upgrade ahead of schedule.
The IFL-90 and I got off to a very rocky start, slightly on account of Windows Vista, but more so due to the poor initial install and configuration of Vista and other baseline drivers and apps that was done by the vendor. Since doing a complete wipe and fresh install myself, the machine runs like a charm, and I am quite pleased with it. Perhaps I am most fond of its aesthetics. Although it has a glossy plastic lid on the reverse side of the LCD, the interior is matte-black and an absolute wonder to work on. With no markings on it to give away its branding, it seems to me to hold the ultimate look of a power-user's laptop. No real hacker would have a gaudy laptop with flashing lights that attracted a bunch of attention; they would be focused on flying below the radar.
It has taken some getting used to, but the keyboard is pretty slick, although the keys seem a bit smaller than the normal 15.4" laptop keyboard. I love the fingerprint reader as it allows me to lock the laptop down without always having to reach for my phone to find the password. The display often surprises me still to this day in how crisp it is. I am usually so enamored with my MacBook Pro's display and considering it the standard, against which I judge other laptop displays, that the IFL's display gets overlooked.
I really can not say anything bad about the IFL-90, other than the bulging battery. Now, I love the battery itself. The fact that I get nearly four hours of battery life out of a gaming laptop is nothing short of staggering. And I like the fact that the battery is something that makes the IFL aesthetically distinctive. However, it creates problems with baggage, where, even though it will fit in bags I have that are spec'd for 15" laptops, sometimes I am stretching the zipper runs to fit over the battery hump, making me nervous that one of these days I will destroy the zipper on one of my (very expensive to replace) booq bags. Another knock is that the hard drive is only 120GB, which is too small to hold a good number of game installs and more importantly hold a good sized media library. As it is, this is one of the laptops that I do not run iTunes on, but rather have it only loaded with my MP3s and use Windows Media Player as my audio jukebox app; VLC Media Player handles the video. This negative gig might change the pecking order if I ever get around to upgrading the internal hard drive to a 320GB drive. For right now, though, if I could keep only one laptop, it would not be this one.
The MacBook makes a strong argument for being the last laptop to be voted off the island (or the last guy does not ever get voted off, does he?). There was a time when I always traveled with my MacBook...on every trip. I grew rather attached to it. In fact, I think it was only the eventual purchase of the MacBook Pro that broke into its consideration as my favorite laptop. Since letting the iPhone go as my primary personal cell phone, my time on the MacBook has been relegated to no more than my time with any other laptop.
Still, I love the notebook. I am still on it slightly more frequently since I always do my iTunes downloads via the MacBook. It is still the laptop that I turn to when I need immediate access to a PC and my desktops are not already running. The MacBook comes out of standby so quickly, without doing a "Restarting Windows" routine like my PCs (the MacBook Pro is frequently in standby from WindowsXP, so it is not always ready for an instant reawakening).
While I have turned to the MacBook Pro for most of my multi-media and digital content creation needs, I still use the MacBook for a fare amount of photo editing. It admittedly has one of the poorer displays of my collection, if not the worst. My Acer ASPIRE One's display is better than the MacBook's, even when running in power saver mode on battery. I might go on record, though, as saying that the MacBook has perhaps the most enjoyable keyboard to type on.
Despite it being one of my more favored laptops, I would not keep the MacBook if it was the only mobile workstation I could keep. The hard drive is too small to support all of my needs. It is 120GB, so it provides the same storage space as the IFL-90. Hence, it also cannot hold all of my music and the iTunes TV Shows that I have downloaded. As it is right now, I immediately back up any TV shows that I buy through iTunes onto the Seagate USB 2.0 external drive that is attached to the MacBook. While one could argue that external storage is expanded storage, my reality is that any laptop carrying the moniker of "primary" must have everything I might possibly need stored locally to the machine, in case I need grab the device and immediately depart. I have on more than one occasion come home with a matter of hours to get packed, and dorking around with moving files back and forth between the local drive and an external drive is a non-starter when I am trying to get out of the door. Combine that with the fact that it would have to be essential that a single notebook was capable of supporting gaming, and have a large enough screen to be enjoyable watching movies on, and the MacBook is, again, taken out of the running.
Then there is the Toshiba, which I have configured as a dual-boot of Windows Vista Home Premium 32-bit and UBUNTU LINUX Gutsy Gibbon. The Ubuntu partition is set up as the primary boot partition. For a 14" laptop, this unit has a cavernous hard drive at 250GB. That makes it large enough to permit me to run the dual-boots with the hard drive split right down the middle. Still, the Toshi has a few problems that keep it from being the only laptop I would keep. First, I have had a very hard time getting every DVD to play on the LINUX partition. My success rate is about 50%. When I hit this obstacle, I turn to the Vista side to playback DVDs.
Due to the 5 PC limit imposed for playing back iTunes protected content, this is another machine that runs Windows Media Player and I only load my MP3 files on. Perhaps the most annoying thing about it is that I can not get the speakers to completely mute when I have headphones plugged in. I figure that this is an Ubuntu driver issue with the Toshi's soundcard. When I do have the headphones plugged in, I can still faintly hear the speakers, loud enough that, in a quiet environment, someone might be able to hear them. If I wanted to tote the M305 Fusion as my only laptop, it would have to be based on having to turn to Vista to handle any need that was problematic to meet in the Ubuntu OS. That would then mean relying on a 125GB partition for my fall-back, which, as I've discussed before, is just too small. While I am very fond of the Toshi's keyboard and display, it's HD size limit, while admittedly due to my own insistence in running two OS's on it, would create a limit that I would not want to live with.
Ahhhhhh...the Dell XPX M1330...a 13.3" bundle of joy. Other than the MacBook, this laptop probably comes closest to capturing the crown, in every need that I have for a notebook short of gaming. I am still floored when I consider how much computer I got in this unit for the price that I bought it at. Spec for spec it easily outstrips even the newest version of the MacBook, and still sold for about $200 cheaper. This laptop runs Vista 64-bit and has a generous 320GB hard drive, within which I can store my entire iTunes archive, including TV shows. This laptop and the MacBook are absolutely neck-and-neck for the honors of having the most comfortable keyboard on a 13" notebook I have ever used. The XPS also has the same type of slot loading optical drive that the MacBook does. These are all heretofore luxuries that you would have never been able to get in a budget-priced 13" notebook. In fact, there really has only recently appeared such a thing. Previously, the diminutive size of a laptop like this would have pumped up the price outside of bargain basement levels, and even then it would have been straddled with anemic performance.
The XPS throws in some small accoutrements, such as a hardware Wireless switch (I always give a plus for notebooks equipped with these) and media control buttons on the chassis ribbon bar below the display. Yes, Apple notebooks have ample media-oriented shortcuts, but still, actual dedicated controls are nice. If I had to choose between the XPS and the MacBook, it would be an agonizing struggle to choose one. However, I don't have to make that choice, because the XPS' lack of ability to perform under newer games keeps it from being the one laptop I would keep.
I am extremely proud of my Acer Aspire ONE and Samsung Q1 Ultra. Mainly due to how early in their rollouts I captured each, and also because, to this day, they are still relatively rare devices to have. I will say right now that I would not give up my Q1 Ultra for much of anything. This is the closest thing on the market today (IMO) that comes close to a Star Trek Okuda-tablet. It has the full power of a Windows Operating System in it, with a tolerable amount of chug, in a relatively small form factor. There are other computing devices that have a better form factor, but most of them shoot too low in size (iPhone) or do not render a full OS (Nokia Tablets). Although (as it's currently planned) I will not be purchasing any new notebooks in 2009, my hope is that someone takes the Netbook platform and puts it into a slate format. If this happens, the current plan goes right out the window as this would be a device that I would just have to have.
The only problem that form-factor would create is that it would be forced to run Vista or WinXP Tablet. I am not sure if Microsoft is still supporting WinXP TabletPC, and netbooks are not beefy enough to run Vista well. The iPhone comes next nearest to what I would ultimately like the Samsung to be (which is everything it is now, but thinner), if Apple would just make a slate with the iPhone GUI but a screen about three to four times as large. If it were a Windows Netbook in a slate form-factor, I would actually like the screen to be about the size of my Acer Aspire ONE's (8.9").
Speaking of the Acer, it is a great machine and fills a space of use for me that the Q1 does not (see my blog post here - http://www.gearwerkz.net/techblog/index.php/2008/10/04/the-family-is-getting-bigger). But obviously it can not game; at least not with any oomph. And at the end of the day, if I were to be left with only one laptop, it would need to be equipped with an optical drive. And I am not so sure I could work every day on a keyboard this small. It's fine for a few days at a time, but not all of the time.
So, in case you had not figured it out by now, if I had to give all of my notebooks away and were only allowed to keep one, it would be my MacBook Pro. Of my laptops, I am partial to the looks, design, and feel of the Gateway, IFL-90, and XPS M1330. But the MBP takes them all hands down. It can game competently but yet is leaner than the P-6860FX and the IFL-90. It has a larger HD than the IFL-90, and of course, I could always upgrade it. It has the best display of any of my laptops. Most importantly, it easily allows me to run two OS's. As it is currently configured, I rock OS X Leopard on one partition for all of my multi-media and creative needs. On the other, I run WinXP for its gaming and consistent compatibility with games and other software apps.
I have gone through a lot of laptops in 9 years; some 21 odd or so. The MBP has definitely proven to be the favorite of every one I have gone through. I really lucked out with Apple's return policy and the fact that a MBP update came out three days after I bought mine. Without the extra 40GB of HD space that I picked up when I swapped it out, I may not have installed a WinXP partition, and I might not have flexed it as much as I have across the two OS's.
There is a good chance that I will not have to travel as much in 2009 and going forward. As such, I may not be spending as much time with my notebooks, and I certainly will not be picking up as much new mobile gear. The only thing is that each of these notebooks fills a particular specialized use-space for me. Stripping down to just one or even just two (which was what I used to run) will be more difficult. And I am not ready to start picking a single "all-purpose" notebook; not as long as I have no dependents and don't have to choose just one laptop and computing continues to be my hobby.
At any rate, I still have some time to put what I already have to good use, and I'll be continuing to bring those experiences to the web via these posts. So keep coming back from time to time. Until next time...
- Vr/Zeux..>>
"Faithless is he that says farewell when the road darkens."
- Tolkien
Log in to comment