A 10 never meant that it was a perfect game. If you took San Andreas (which got a 10 in Gameplay, Value and Tilt) and added the graphics and sound of Resident Evil 4 (both 10s) you would have a game that would have gotten a 10.
Now, it's not even that, as you would imagine a couple games would've been rounded up under the new system.
Nonethless, it's completely unlikely that any one game would get a 10. People say LBP but really, there was no way in hell that GameSpot would've given it a 10 in Gameplay given how they marked Gameplay in the past; a game like LBP would just never be refined enough out of the box to be a 10 in Gameplay (which is basically reserved for a very small amount of games). There are always a bunch of games that could get to that super elite level but it would pretty much just be the huge outlier in the system.
Log in to comment