I offer a different perspective on your dilema. I'm now in my early thirties, and I notice that several of you who feel this way are now reaching the age of around 22. The disappointing feeling you got from Twilight Princess, get used to it. It's not to say that there is really anything wrong with Twilight Princess. It's just your age, perspective and the value you place on your time has all changed from the days in which you played Ocarina of Time.
Funny though, I was 22 when Ocarina of Time came out. I remember playing through it and really enjoying it. That was the first time I had seen all of these things in 3D. But when I finished the game I was feeling a little...empty. I complained that the ending wasn't very good, and there wasn't enough emphasis put on the story. And while the compositions were good, I thought the music was a little lacking. I am aware now, though, that all of these are ridiculous arguments. But that's how I felt at the time.
Why? Because the game had been hyped up to be the greatest gaming experience ever made. For me, it didn't topple my greatest video game experience up to that point, which was Final Fantasy VI for the SNES. I'm not here to debate which is better, OoT or FF6. I don't expect anyone to understand why I felt that way, you must know that I just did.
Games are alot like music and movies. They change over time, and everyone has a different experience. For example, if you spend the first six years of your life watching crap like C.H.I.P.S. and Dukes of Hazzard, do you think seeing Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope would've blown your mind as well? If you caught those on video in the early nineties and then only saw the prequel trilogy in theatres, you'd probably wonder what the hell all the fuss is about.
Most of the games I hold most dear to me are NES and SNES titles. I wouldn't recommend my favorite games to anyone else though. No one would understand. But to this day, I enjoy those titles more than I do new ones. Back when I had time to play games. Lots of time.
The point is, for every disappointed gamer out there in regards to Twilight Princess, there is someone else playing it and being moved on a level we wish could happen to us. I envy them a bit, and if you think about it, you do too. Not that there's anything wrong with that.
I played through Twilight Princess on Gamecube. It took my around 88 hours to complete. I think all the complaints you have are valid. Yet, I do not share your disappointment. In fact, I was pleasantly surprised at the experience that was Twilight Princess. Guess I'm just easier to please in my old age.
Log in to comment