I'm not trying to convince anyone per se, this is purely my two cents on the idol system as it stands. The Silver Idol works well enough for Caxton, in my opinion. The benefits for giving him the Gold Idol are outweighed by those of giving it to Madeleine, again... in my opinion.
I will say this though, giving him the Gold Idol only allows you easy/early access to a selection of weapons to help you prior to post-game status. After that, any and all weapons you used previously are technically useless, in comparison to the weapons that show up post-game, both in shops and through other means.
Caxton only offers up one single additional weapon for each type if given the gold idol, over being given the silver one. He offers no armor of any kind through this method. Madeleine offers curatives, weapons and armor via the idols. So, if you think you will ever even remotely use a mage, sorcerer, strider, assassin, ranger or magic archer... in my honest opinion, giving Madeleine the idol pays off a lot more. Especially since eventually she will disappear for most people, never to return, until new game plus.
If one is worried about acquiring melee gear, well... I don't know about anyone else, but I'm finding weapons and armor for Warriors and Fighters left and right. So, that doesn't seem to be a big issue in this game. However, ranged and magi gear is not as common.
So, once again... Caxton having the Gold Idol offers a very brief and insignifant bonus. I was more than happy with my Crimson Teeth, silver or gold idol, and Hunter's Bow, the latter of which I easily found in a chest. The uses of armor is far more stretched out than weapons, in my opinion. So I gave the better idol to Madeleine. xD
Log in to comment