[QUOTE="Rocky32189"][QUOTE="famicommander"]There have been great Sonic games consistently since the series debuted. There have also been bad ones, but check out this list: famicommander
There has yet to be a game in the series that lives up to the Genesis games and Sonic CD. Sonic games are only getting consistently worse, not better in both the 2D and 3D series:
3D: Sonic Adventure is the best 3D Sonic game and it's been downhill since that one.
2D: The Sonic Advance games weren't as good as the Genesis/Game Gear/Sega CD games. The Sonic Rush games weren't as good as the Sonic Advance games.
Also, there's been many more crappy games in the series besides just Sonic 06 and Shadow the Hedgehog.
So a game that doesn't live up to five of the greatest games of all time is instantly bad? Seriously, which games ARE as good as Sonic 1-3, Sonic and Knuckles, and Sonic CD? I judge each game based on its own merits. NSMB and Yoshi's Island DS aren't as good as SMB 3 and SMW. Does that make them bad games? In all fairness, Yoshi's Island DS and NSMB stand as great games in their own right, whether they live up to the originals or not. Sonic games are just the complete opposite. Even if you choose not to compare them to their originals.
Log in to comment