Then don't post in a religious thread...
I'm glad you asked that question, it is the reason I am still awake at 2am.
Consider yourself and God. For God to be omnipotent, then he would have to be able to do everything, which includes, but is not limited to, seeing into the future and seeing what you are doing in your life in 5, 10 even 20 years. Correct?
If the above statement was correct in your eyes. We are forced to accept that the future is pre-determined and your life will follow a set course. If this course is already set, nothing you can do can change it. You are destined to follow the path that was set for you. Thus eliminating any choices you can make. Following me so far?
This type of pre-determined life is what philosophers call (surprisingly) Determinism. (Interestingly, this philosophy also eliminates morality and rationality but that is not the focus of thisarguement).
Suppose that God told you that you would do something great at the expense of your loved ones. You, for your own reasons, don't want to harm your loved ones, even to do this great thing that God spoke of. In order to correct this, you elect to throw yourself in front of a bus (there are worse ways to go :P). In doing this, you would cancel out your future and would do nothing great during you life. (unless you are to do that great thing from Heaven and the pain you cause your loved ones is the expense, in which case that would be a self-fufilling prophecy, but lets assume it's not) In order for the determinism mechanism to work, some deus ex machina would have to happen to stop the bus (a jet engine falling on the front a la Donnie Darko, for instance), in order for you to fufill your destiny, otherwise God will have not seen the future accurately, and is therefore not all-powerful.
Please notice that I didn't say that free will denies the existence of God, just that he cannot be all-powerful, he might be able to do everything except see into the future because of free will, but that wouldn't make him all powerful and would be an imperfection, which would raise all sorts of questions as you can imagine.
Im off to bed now, but please take the time to read, digest, reflect and post a counter arguement and/or comment.I'll trawl through the board tomorrow to findthis topic and read your reply. (This may be one of the arguements I put forth in my Philosphy exam on friday, so capitalise without mercy on any chinks you can find in my arguement :P)
Alternatively, you could comment that my explaination and example were both utter s*** and ask me to restate them :P
Chavyneebslod
Yes, God can see what we are doing in years to come, yet due to his gift and curse of Free Will, he will not intervene if we go down the wrong path. Can he? Yes. Will he? No.
Log in to comment