[QUOTE="kuraimen"][QUOTE="Palantas"]Well that's what happens. People go with whom they trust more and with the reasoning that fits more their world view. I trust more the people who were and are against it (many of whom were government and army officials at the time) because I won't be able to ever justify how killing 200 thousand innocent people is the best or right course of action in my mind. Bias doesn't equate to right though. As for war......it tends to have a death toll don't you think?Not the government, army officials, and historians who agreed it was the best thing to do...and did it, and things turned out well (for the US). Well, I think I'll go with those guys, because their opinions fit better with my preconceived notions.
LJS9502_basic
I find this bias comment ironic. Since I didn't respond to your last post a few pages back, here it is:
Yes, of course the cold war came after ww2. Sometimes I wonder if you just say this type of thing to be offensive rather than actually try to prove a point...You keep going on about facts but you ignore what is right in front of your eyes. Do you honestly think that when we dropped the bombs we weren't thinking in the back of our minds that it would also intimidate the soviets? They were also in the race to get the bomb. If the Western Allies proved to the world that they did indeed posses nuclear capability, then they could have demanded more from the peace treaty ending the war, as their trump card would have forced the Soviets to yeild some ground. I really hat having to spell myself out three times in one thread.
As for casualties in war- yes, unavoidable, but how can you justify the strategic bombing of both Germany and Japan? It was shock and awe, if nothing else, to beat the enemy's civilian population into submission. The US tried to do daylight bombings of Germany early on, but since bomber losses were so great they decided to just do night raids, which were in turn innacurate and hit civilian targets. Dresden, for example, was completely leveled, and Hiroshima came soon after. In both these cases, the civilians were the targets. I have no objection with calling strategic bombing as war crime, but once again, history is written by the victors.
Log in to comment