I don't know how many of you guys have heard about PitchforkMedia.com, but basically Pitchfork Media gained its fame by being overly critical, smug, and elitist in regards to its musical preferences, and especially brutal w/ its music reviews. Up and coming bands are broken or made by a good review by that site because so many "music fans" blindly accept and follow their ridiculously pretentious musical opinions.
Basically, its elitism for the sake of elitism.
I definitely see a similar route being taken in regards to video games with this gamesite. Now, I own an XBOX 360, I'll let that be out in the open right now, but the recent overly critical, dare I even say in some cases, unrealistic expectation-laden review scores, in reviews that have been occurring at this site for the better part of the past year has left at least me scratching my head (regardless if scores were for PS#, 360, or whatever....). Whether it be Ratchet and Clank, Uncharted, Mass Effect, Metroid Prime 3, Zelda:Twilight Princess, etc.
Now, I know, there have also been some real head-scratchers that go the other way too, such as Assasins Creed, Conan, Eternal Sonata, Perfect Dark:Zero, etc. However, so many of these games that continually flop here at Gamestop are games that are highly-anticipated, flagship titles that people have been waiting for from the moment they first saw clips of the game, and often when they do come out, in the vast majority of cases they have scored VASTLY better from other HIGHLY credible gaming sources while Gamespot flops them. Why? I have a theory, but maybe its just me. My perspective may be jaded, but gamespot seems to be taking this pretentious viewpoint, trying to make some high-horse statement as if to say by flopping these games,"Yeah, we did that, we went there..." Being an elitist for the sake of being an elitist. Deliberately going against the herd, not with any definable or useful purpose, but going against the herd just for the sake of it.
So, think what you will, but I'm not blindly accepting any smug elitist review this site puts out from here on out, unless it has a legitamite and consistent manner in which to criticize these games. I've never seen so many ridiculous flip-flop statements and contradictions that actually is an asset to one game and a detriment to another from one "credible" source in my life. And for god sake, it was amusing while its lasted, but can we please be real and all just admit that the PS3 does have AAA games, and this site is just too smug with their head in the clouds to realize it.
Lock this if you must. Its off my chest.
Log in to comment