I'm not talking about tobacco or alcohol, but illegal drugs like cocaine, meth, marijuana, etc.chrisredfield3
I see you've edited your post to say "illegal" instead of "hardcore" once people pointed out how much more deadly and addictive alcohol and tobacco are than marijuana.
But now your question makes no sense. You're asking "should illegal drugs be illegal?" Tautologically, illegal drugs must be illegal, or they are not illegal drugs at all.
So a better question might be, "how do we decide whether a drug should be legal or not?" And the answer is to compare policies throughout history, and pick the one with the greatest net benefit and the smallest net harm. If you compare the overall effects of prohibition, regulation, and complete legality, it's pretty clear that focusing on regulation (age limits, drugged driving laws, etc.), education and treatment is the best policy, even for very harmful drugs.
I would recommend that policy even for heroin and crystal meth (which I would advice everyone to competely avoid), because it yields the greatest net benefit to society. Locking people in prison for their habits is much more expensive and harmful than education and treatment. It's important to keep in mind that current US drug policies are not deterring drug use. Illegal drug use continues to increase in America, whereas it has dropped in countries (like Portugal) that have decriminalized drug posession.
If you are an idealist rather than a pragmatist, you may reject that answer and suggest that there is a moral imperative to outlaw dangerous drugs. Your question then becomes "how do we set the threshold that determines which drugs are too dangerous?" A statistician would be the best person to answer that question, but any reasonable threshold would result in marijuana being legal (zero annual deaths, overdose impossible, less physically addictive than caffeine, no major chronic diseases caused, no increase in violent behaviour) and alcohol being illegal (hundreds of thousands of annual death, overdose common, extremely severe withdrawal for addicts, major cause of liver disease, massively contributes to sexual assault, domestic abuse, homicide and suicide).
Log in to comment