1. NINJA GAIDEN 2

2. God Of War 3

3-5. Don't care.

I find it funny how San Andreas is the most overrated just because it has a black guy in it.

If you're looking for overrated games: Halo series, GEARS OF WAR, GTA series, Metal Gear Solid series, Resident Evil series, Jade Empire, KOTOR, Final Fantasy series, Chrono Trigger/Chrono Cross, next-gen games in general(especially 360 games), shooters in general, music oriented games, etc.

The few games that deserve their praise:

Ninja Gaiden/Black/Sigma---deserve highest honors

God Of War 1 & 2---deserve highest honors

Shenmue 1 & 2(DC)---deserve highest honors

Metroid Prime

Jet Set Radio Future(it's sort of music oriented but still good)(underrated)

Monster Rancher series(wayyy underrated)

Soul Reaver(semi-underrated)

Gran Turismo

End of list...