You can read the rest of the article at CMI.
The Huffington Post ran an article on Five Reasons Why Evolution Is Important by Steven Newton, Public Information Project Director for the National Center for Science Education (NCSE). It was run on 12 February 2010 to celebrate Charles Darwin's 201st birthday.
Newton gives five medical examples of natural selection and claims that proves "evolution" is important. Everyone would agree that medical care and health are paramount, and so if evolution helps medical research then people will obviously think evolution is vital.
But his argument is misleading. In fact, the confused nature of his argument has been pointed out so many times that I'm sure Steven Newton and the others at NCSE are aware of it. They have to be deliberately muddying the waters here.
Why is it confusing? Ask yourself, "What does Newton mean by 'evolution'?" He is confusing us because he is using the word in two different ways. It's a trick. Newton gives examples of change by means of "natural selection", which is one meaning of the word. Then he says those examples explain "the diversity of life on this planet". Hold on—not so fast.
Log in to comment