[QUOTE="ownage_denied"][QUOTE="Cloud_Insurance"][QUOTE="DJ-Lafleur"][QUOTE="Cloud_Insurance"][QUOTE="majadamus"]Why would you need to taser a naked man? chesterocks7
Because he attacked the police? Besides, if you are on patrol and encounter a naked man who seems "out of mind" you have absolutely no idea what they might do, they could do anything.
If he was naked, and had no sort of weapon at all on him, then what could he do? It's not like he could hide it in clothes, since he had none. He could attack them with his own fists, which in that case a taser isn't necessary, 2 cops should have been able to take care of the naked man without going to extremes.
But he had a weapon. Besides the question I answered was a general question pertaining to tasering a naked man, not this specific one. If a police officer is attacked he has the right to defend himself. Its that simple. The suspect was out of his mind and attacked the officers, so they tasered him. If he didn't fall on his head, he would have been fine, and this wouldn't even be a story. And again, they only tasered him because he attacked them. If the suspect got a hold of one of the officers he could have taken him off the ledge with him.
First of all, considering he was on a ledge 10 feet above the ground, I don't think the officers were fearing for their lives. Second, in the article it says the officers tied themselves to the fire escape so they wouldn't fall when they grabbed him. Third, they could've waited a few extra minutes for the air bag to get there.
While I'm all ready posting, I might as-well go ahead and completely destroy your argument about them having the right to tase him with this quote from the article
" The NYPD quickly admitted after the Sept. 24 incident that the ESU cops violated policy when they used a Taser against someone at risk of falling."
Nice try though.
Ok now put yourself in their situation, I'm sure they were all thinking of what the textbook said on every specific circumstance it's ok to use a taser. You have no idea if they felt threatened, or if they felt they needed to subdue him. Tasers are not lethal, so it's not like they were thinking there was a great possibility that the man would fall and land on his head. You can read the textbooks and sit back in your home and make judgements all you want, but until you are put in a real life situation like that, you are in no position to judge.
If they weren't worrying about the man falling and getting hurt, why did they send for an air bag:| .
Don't you think a cop with 21 years of experience should've had better judgement than this?
Log in to comment