[QUOTE="S0lidSnake"]
[QUOTE="dvader654"]
Spoiler time
[spoiler] The story is just beyond anything I have seen in games. The emotional rollercoaster it puts you in is unmatched, you feel every swing of emotion. I was happy, sad, frightened (not because of monsters but because I could lose Ellie), then utterly disgusted. The last half of this game pulls out all the stops, the winter section being one of the greatest few hours in gaming history.
Then the start of Sping was just as good. So many little things that tugged at your emotions, you can tell Ellie is not the same. When you go to boost and she is not there, its like this game breaking moment where you expect the canned animation, removing that made it powerful. The giraffes and Ellie feeling like her old self again. I loved how you can see Joel finally opening up to her, opening talking about his daughter. You got an excellent section against the infected in the tunnel and then MEH.
You end the game with a bunch of military rejects from Uncharted. You build all these stealth mechanics, introduce all sorts of awesome monsters and you end with a gun fight. Yes you can still stealth it but the game is practically begging you to take rifles and start gunning down the place like rambo. It was one of the worst sections in terms of gameplay in the whole game. You are supposed to end with your best. The David shit might as well have been the end then. At least have one giant zombie attack, something.
In terms of story I wanted her back so badly. But I only killed one doctor, you guys are monsters, the other two did nothing. Then when you meet Marlene and you see what Joel is doing it starts to feel wrong. The car ride solidified it. He wasn't saving her for her, he was doing it cause he is a selfish monster. She represents his daughter, he found a reason to live and damn everyone who gets in the way. He even lies to her face. What a crazy turn around, I feel bad that Ellie will live this lie.
I was hoping for a bit more closure though, I kept reading how this game feels like no sequel is necessary. Nothing is resolved, you just learn that Joel is going to live a lie so he can raise the girl. Someone will come for her, or she will seek the truth and when she learns it that encounter will be nuts. The way the game just stops reminded me of No Country For Old Men. That movie won best picture so I guess people like the abrupt end stuff. [/spoiler]
Anyway the game is just fantastic. Now to try the multiplayer.
CarnageHeart
[spoiler] lol what abrupt ending? The game is about a choice. He made the choice to keep her alive. And thats pretty much the end of it. It wasnt a guarantee that they wouldve been able to find a cure. Apparently there is a recording in the Colorodo university lab where they talk about finding more people like Elle but couldnt find a cure. And then there is the state of the world. Do you really think a vaccine that makes people immune to bite will save this world? These people who have descended into madness? That was my biggest takeaway from the ending, this world doesnt deserve a cure. [/spoiler]
[spoiler] Solid, that is an interesting analysis and I mostly agree with it, but my big takeaway was that Joel could not allow another little girl he loved to die even if his choice to save her doomed the world and didn't guarantee that she would live a long, happy life. [/spoiler]
Â
[spoiler]
Oh I completely agree with that. It was selfish of him to do what he did. I was just referring to dvader's assertion that the ending leaves room for a sequel. It's ambigious, yes, but it's all there... the choice he made, why he made it and why she chooses to accept the lie. If you paid attention to the characters throughout the game, the ending makes complete sense. [/spoiler]
Log in to comment