1up review: 360 madden vs. PS3 madden (guess who won)

[QUOTE="biggamerhk"]meh . . i was hoping that EA would resove all of these types of issues with the PS3 version, but I guess not. This is a bit of a letdown on EA's part--they couldve done better.ramey70

Why should EA work much harder to satisfy such a small userbase?

wouldnt it be right for EA to satisfy both parties equally?? if not then they would lose a huge amount of potetnial customers and since its football thats huge and the userbase istn so small anymore.

Cows pwned lolwildwild

well that proves it doesn't it. who has the inferior console now? Areola54

bu-but teh lazy devs :cry:

Cows need to just give it up, you can't argue your way out of 30FPS being better than 60FPS. Your getting the worse version of multi plat games and to top it all off you had to pay hundreds of dollars more for the privilege of being screwed by Sony. I'm sorry you guys were dumb enough to be fooled by Sony yet again, but maybe you will learn your lesson this time around. In short COWS have been totally owned, humiliated and neutered this gen, you guys are taking lumps each and every week for your poor decision of buying a PS3. All the spin in the world won't reverse this trend. Your PS3 dreams are over, you have bought this gens Gamecube now just suck it up and sell your PS3 or deal with having the #3 console this gen. swanlee

you mean give up like how microsoft gave up on xbox and screwing over the fanbase? not all multiplat games will be inferior to the ps3. atleast were not screwed into buying a faulty console and having an extended warranty to cover up the mistake and the warranty is only good for RROD and not other hardware issues. sure you lemmings have gamesbut the ps3 has some awesome games in the coming weeks and months.

you cant blame the ps3 its the developers who are still trying to figure out the specs of the hardware to try and take full advantage of the ps3.

Cows paid $600for a 30fps.... Another Cow Ownage thread.:lol:

bu bu but teh one year 360 advantage!!!:cry:

bu bu but EA is teh Biased!!!:cry:

Cows paid $600for a 30fps.... Another Cow Ownage thread.:lol:

bu bu but teh one year 360 advantage!!!:cry:

bu bu but EA is teh Biased!!!:cry:

Art_424

dude the 360 had an extra year of madden, of course it will have the advantage.

next year it wont be the case......

[QUOTE="Art_424"]

Cows paid $600for a 30fps.... Another Cow Ownage thread.:lol:

bu bu but teh one year 360 advantage!!!:cry:

bu bu but EA is teh Biased!!!:cry:

ginglejangle

dude the 360 had an extra year of madden, of course it will have the advantage.

next year it wont be the case......

Thats such a lame excuse, since the PS3 is the beefier console. its been a year out already, they should have fixed this already.

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="Art_424"]

Cows paid $600for a 30fps.... Another Cow Ownage thread.:lol:

bu bu but teh one year 360 advantage!!!:cry:

bu bu but EA is teh Biased!!!:cry:

Art_424

dude the 360 had an extra year of madden, of course it will have the advantage.

next year it wont be the case......

Thats such a lame excuse, since the PS3 is the beefier console. its been a year out already, they should have fixed this already.

So madden 07 for 360 shouldn't have had 30fps right?

[QUOTE="Art_424"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="Art_424"]

Cows paid $600for a 30fps.... Another Cow Ownage thread.:lol:

bu bu but teh one year 360 advantage!!!:cry:

bu bu but EA is teh Biased!!!:cry:

Scarletred

dude the 360 had an extra year of madden, of course it will have the advantage.

next year it wont be the case......

Thats such a lame excuse, since the PS3 is the beefier console. its been a year out already, they should have fixed this already.

So madden 07 for 360 shouldn't have had 30fps right?

Its wasnt being pushed by another console at that moment to have higher than 30fps, and it shows they improved fps to 60with the competition of PS3.

[QUOTE="Scarletred"][QUOTE="Art_424"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="Art_424"]

Cows paid $600for a 30fps.... Another Cow Ownage thread.:lol:

bu bu but teh one year 360 advantage!!!:cry:

bu bu but EA is teh Biased!!!:cry:

Art_424

dude the 360 had an extra year of madden, of course it will have the advantage.

next year it wont be the case......

Thats such a lame excuse, since the PS3 is the beefier console. its been a year out already, they should have fixed this already.

So madden 07 for 360 shouldn't have had 30fps right?

Its wasnt being pushed by another console at that moment to have higher than 30fps, and it shows they improved fps to 60with the competition of PS3.

Not being madefor another console? Wrong. Not being made for another next gen console? Right. Then again I would have still expeted them to try and optimize it for the 360 since the PS2 had such a large user-base. Also you make it sound like MS decides when they want to optimize it? If PS3 orWiididn't come out till late 07 would that have meant that Madden 08 would still have only 30fps for 360 since there was no competition?

[QUOTE="Art_424"][QUOTE="Scarletred"][QUOTE="Art_424"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="Art_424"]

Cows paid $600for a 30fps.... Another Cow Ownage thread.:lol:

bu bu but teh one year 360 advantage!!!:cry:

bu bu but EA is teh Biased!!!:cry:

Scarletred

dude the 360 had an extra year of madden, of course it will have the advantage.

next year it wont be the case......

Thats such a lame excuse, since the PS3 is the beefier console. its been a year out already, they should have fixed this already.

So madden 07 for 360 shouldn't have had 30fps right?

Its wasnt being pushed by another console at that moment to have higher than 30fps, and it shows they improved fps to 60with the competition of PS3.

Not being madefor another console? Wrong. Not being made for another next gen console? Right. Then again I would have still expeted them to try and optimize it for the 360 since the PS2 had such a large user-base. Also you make it sound like MS decides when they want to optimize it? If PS3 orWiididn't come out till late 07 would that have meant that Madden 08 would still have only 30fps for 360 since there was no competition?

Do PS2 Madden 07 look exactly like Madden 07 on 360?.....Im referring about this generation consoles, not last. Nothing was pushing the 360 to improve at the moment.

well that proves it doesn't it. who has the inferior console now? Areola54

You CAN'T be serious with that comment can you? I have both systems and in no way am i going to determine which system is better simply off the score of the latest madden. Since when does an annual football game determine a systems worth. that may be the dumbest comment i've ever heard on this board.

[QUOTE="Scarletred"][QUOTE="Art_424"][QUOTE="Scarletred"][QUOTE="Art_424"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="Art_424"]

Cows paid $600for a 30fps.... Another Cow Ownage thread.:lol:

bu bu but teh one year 360 advantage!!!:cry:

bu bu but EA is teh Biased!!!:cry:

Art_424

dude the 360 had an extra year of madden, of course it will have the advantage.

next year it wont be the case......

Thats such a lame excuse, since the PS3 is the beefier console. its been a year out already, they should have fixed this already.

So madden 07 for 360 shouldn't have had 30fps right?

Its wasnt being pushed by another console at that moment to have higher than 30fps, and it shows they improved fps to 60with the competition of PS3.

Not being madefor another console? Wrong. Not being made for another next gen console? Right. Then again I would have still expeted them to try and optimize it for the 360 since the PS2 had such a large user-base. Also you make it sound like MS decides when they want to optimize it? If PS3 orWiididn't come out till late 07 would that have meant that Madden 08 would still have only 30fps for 360 since there was no competition?

Do PS2 Madden 07 look exactly like Madden 07 on 360?.....Im referring about this generation consoles, not last. Nothing was pushing the 360 to improve at the moment.

Yea and according to you PS3 version of 08 should be running at 60fps in less than a year. So I asked "Should 07 for 360 been at 60fps". No madden 07 for ps2 does not look like 360 version. However, IMO, I would think that the fact that the PS2 version of 06 scored higher than 360 version and the fact that the PS2 had a much bigger user-base would push them to make the 360 version better to make more copies. Then again you might use the excuse that cows use (not saying that it isn't credible) and say that EA is lazy.

[QUOTE="chikenfriedrice"][QUOTE="Catpee"]

I literally cannot wait. I'm calling friends trying to get an early copy and willing to pay a premium for it.

That Indy/Colts preseason game killed me last night. I wanted to play Madden so badly after it, I couldn't go to sleep. If I had to play the PS3 version I would deal with it, but Madden on my 360 at 60 fps is going to be like heaven.

Catpee

preseason NFL is boooring

bu.. bu.. teh fvcking cell is letting us down cows! I want my motherfvcking 4d 1080p @ 120fps for fvcks sake!Taz-Bone

bu-but they need to unlock teh full paowar of teh cell :cry:

[QUOTE="thirstychainsaw"]But teh HDD limits game developers :|dracolich666

"bu bu but the blu-ray is needed!!"

"30fps and 60fps look the same!!11"

"bu but EA hates sony"

Deep down you know the PS3 is harder to develop for and that's what it boils down to. Can't we just acknowledge this without the other childish comments?

I don't care this game.

but some thing like that happens too much.

[QUOTE="dracolich666"]

[QUOTE="thirstychainsaw"]But teh HDD limits game developers :|SergeantSnitch

"bu bu but the blu-ray is needed!!"

"30fps and 60fps look the same!!11"

"bu but EA hates sony"

Deep down you know the PS3 is harder to develop for and that's what it boils down to. Can't we just acknowledge this without the other childish comments?

Oh yes, the old 'PS3 is harder to develop for' excuse. Maybe deep down PS3 is just the inferior gaming machine. You guys are making this too easy,

[QUOTE="SergeantSnitch"][QUOTE="dracolich666"]

[QUOTE="thirstychainsaw"]But teh HDD limits game developers :|DXGreat1_HGL

"bu bu but the blu-ray is needed!!"

"30fps and 60fps look the same!!11"

"bu but EA hates sony"

Deep down you know the PS3 is harder to develop for and that's what it boils down to. Can't we just acknowledge this without the other childish comments?

Oh yes, the old 'PS3 is harder to develop for' excuse. Maybe deep down PS3 is just the inferior gaming machine. You guys are making this too easy,

Nah. if it was inferior, devs wouldn't be finding ways to makesome games look better for thePS3 than the 360 version.

Because the PS3 is overpriced junk...DXGreat1_HGL

[QUOTE="SergeantSnitch"][QUOTE="dracolich666"]

[QUOTE="thirstychainsaw"]But teh HDD limits game developers :|DXGreat1_HGL

"bu bu but the blu-ray is needed!!"

"30fps and 60fps look the same!!11"

"bu but EA hates sony"

Deep down you know the PS3 is harder to develop for and that's what it boils down to. Can't we just acknowledge this without the other childish comments?

Oh yes, the old 'PS3 is harder to develop for' excuse. Maybe deep down PS3 is just the inferior gaming machine. You guys are making this too easy,

[QUOTE="DXGreat1_HGL"]Because the PS3 is overpriced junk...soulfood4

I'm just speaking facts. The PS3 isn't a garbage system, if anything, with good devs it is more powerful than the competition. But at this point, until games come out to showcase the PS3's capabilites, I guess you can get away with comments like that.

SergeantSnitch

hehe, reminded me of this post

2025, The Last Remaining PS3 Loyalists Awaiting The Awakening Of The PS3 Power

taken from some other thread

[QUOTE="Magical_Zebra"][QUOTE="Scarletred"][QUOTE="Magical_Zebra"]

Oh no you dont. You said some games look and run better on the PS3 than the 360. The burden of proof is on YOU to provide a link showing this. Again, you said it not me. :shock:

Scarletred

But it's not just gonna be one link. Hell I even said some are on here. If you don't even want to look at that then Im sorry. My main point is both systems have their pros and cons, and some games will look better or run better on one console while other will do on another. the reasoning for me saying that the PS3 isn't weaker is because if that was the case, comparisons wouldn't be saying that the PS3 is better in some games and the 360 in others.

Ok, as I suspected you cant provide a link or links to support/backup your claim. Stop while your behind dude. You cant make baseless comments w/o some sort of proof. We are suppose to go off of something "you saw"? If you saw it, then provide a link. :shock:

Some of the proof is on here. If you don't wanna take the time to go look at it, then that's your fault.

Ok lemme get this straight. You make a comment that some PS3 games look better and run better than the 360 version. Since you make the claim, I ask for proof (link). You cant provide the link, so you go on about how the information is here on GS. No **** its here on GS. Its not my job to find it, its your job since you made the claim, the burden is on you.

So in conclusion, you cant provide a link based off of something you "allegedly" saw on the forums. Nice try....but you FAIL. :D

[QUOTE="Mystery_Writer"][QUOTE="Scarletred"]

Some are on gamespot. I remember when looking for comparisons for fight night they said the PS3 version is overall better.

Scarletred

"Fight Night Round 3 was one of the first games to really show off the Xbox 360's graphics power with fantastic lighting and incredibly detailed player models. The PS3 still has great looking player models but the crowds are less detailed and the lighting effects are definitely inferior. If the graphical losses weren't enough, the PlayStation 3 version takes almost twice as long as its 360 counterpart to load into the menu screen, and a third longer to load a quickplay." - gamespot.com

I didn't say that specific review now did I?

Sorry sir, only GS reviews count. Im sure you were referring to the review in PS mag. This is the first time I have seen, Damage Control, Spin, Denial and Back Pedaling all in one sentence.

Scarletred: Bu bu but PS3 games like Fight Night look and run better than the 360 version.

Mystery Writer: GS doesnt think so...heres the link.

Scarletred: Oh noes, I wasnt talking about that review!! :shock:

Well now.

Madden on 360? Wins!

Madden as a whole?

. . . Boring.

Well now.

Madden on 360? Wins!

Madden as a whole?

. . . Boring.

The XBOX 360 version is best because it's the most popular game console where football is the most followed professional sport.

Within the United States there are about 6.5 million XBOX 360's, 4 million Wii's, and 2 million PS3's. Also somebody probably told EA Sports that there might be a few more XBOX 360's sold when Halo 3 gets closer in a few weeks.

[QUOTE="Scarletred"][QUOTE="Magical_Zebra"][QUOTE="Scarletred"][QUOTE="Magical_Zebra"]

Oh no you dont. You said some games look and run better on the PS3 than the 360. The burden of proof is on YOU to provide a link showing this. Again, you said it not me. :shock:

Magical_Zebra

But it's not just gonna be one link. Hell I even said some are on here. If you don't even want to look at that then Im sorry. My main point is both systems have their pros and cons, and some games will look better or run better on one console while other will do on another. the reasoning for me saying that the PS3 isn't weaker is because if that was the case, comparisons wouldn't be saying that the PS3 is better in some games and the 360 in others.

Ok, as I suspected you cant provide a link or links to support/backup your claim. Stop while your behind dude. You cant make baseless comments w/o some sort of proof. We are suppose to go off of something "you saw"? If you saw it, then provide a link. :shock:

Some of the proof is on here. If you don't wanna take the time to go look at it, then that's your fault.

Ok lemme get this straight. You make a comment that some PS3 games look better and run better than the 360 version. Since you make the claim, I ask for proof (link). You cant provide the link, so you go on about how the information is here on GS. No **** its here on GS. Its not my job to find it, its your job since you made the claim, the burden is on you.

So in conclusion, you cant provide a link based off of something you "allegedly" saw on the forums. Nice try....but you FAIL. :D

go back to that link you provided and look at the tiger woods one.

[QUOTE="Scarletred"][QUOTE="Mystery_Writer"][QUOTE="Scarletred"]

Some are on gamespot. I remember when looking for comparisons for fight night they said the PS3 version is overall better.

Magical_Zebra

"Fight Night Round 3 was one of the first games to really show off the Xbox 360's graphics power with fantastic lighting and incredibly detailed player models. The PS3 still has great looking player models but the crowds are less detailed and the lighting effects are definitely inferior. If the graphical losses weren't enough, the PlayStation 3 version takes almost twice as long as its 360 counterpart to load into the menu screen, and a third longer to load a quickplay." - gamespot.com

I didn't say that specific review now did I?

Sorry sir, only GS reviews count. Im sure you were referring to the review in PS mag. This is the first time I have seen, Damage Control, Spin, Denial and Back Pedaling all in one sentence.

Scarletred: Bu bu but PS3 games like Fight Night look and run better than the 360 version.

Mystery Writer: GS doesnt think so...heres the link.

Scarletred: Oh noes, I wasnt talking about that review!! :shock:

You said provide a link? nothing about only GS review count. You know what. i'll provide the link where someone said the Ps3 version looked better (in refards to the fighters) and said it improved on where the 360 was bad.

I literally cannot wait. I'm calling friends trying to get an early copy and willing to pay a premium for it.

That Indy/Colts preseason game killed me last night. I wanted to play Madden so badly after it, I couldn't go to sleep. If I had to play the PS3 version I would deal with it, but Madden on my 360 at 60 fps is going to be like heaven.

Catpee

Here's one saying the PS3 fighters looked better.

http://www.cnet.com.au/games/ps3/0,239035763,339274404,00.htm

Here's the other one:http://www.cinemablend.com/games/Fight-Night-Round-3-Ships-For-The-PS3-1915.html

Oh and I can't take other reviews and comparisons? Don't give me that crap. That was never the deal. Hell if you want go look at the pics in the other topic called "List of Justifications". You don't see me complaining when people bring up the Lair reviews from EGM.

Oh yea and sorry...but you FAIL.

Here's one saying the PS3 fighters looked better.

http://www.cnet.com.au/games/ps3/0,239035763,339274404,00.htmScarletred

That link FAILS. G A M E S P O T counts... :shock:

Here's the other one:http://www.cinemablend.com/games/Fight-Night-Round-3-Ships-For-The-PS3-1915.htmlScarletred

That link also FAILS. Read the above response.

Oh and I can't take other reviews and comparisons? Scarletred

For the third time sir, no you cant. GS scores and reviews while on GS.

Don't give me that crap. That was never the deal. Scarletred

Um... SW states that only GS scores count and GS reviews count.

Hell if you want go look at the pics in the other topic called "List of Justifications". You don't see me complaining when people bring up the Lair reviews from EGM.Scarletred

It doesnt matter, they cant use EGM for ownage either. For the umpteenth time, only GS scores are recognized here on GS.

Oh yea and sorry...but you FAIL.Scarletred

I highly doubt it. See, I too can look up non GS links to further my cause.

http://forum.pcvsconsole.com/viewthread.php?tid=20964That link says virtually every game on the 360 looks better than the PS3. Oooohhhhh.. :shock:

[QUOTE="Catpee"]

I literally cannot wait. I'm calling friends trying to get an early copy and willing to pay a premium for it.

That Indy/Colts preseason game killed me last night. I wanted to play Madden so badly after it, I couldn't go to sleep. If I had to play the PS3 version I would deal with it, but Madden on my 360 at 60 fps is going to be like heaven.

chikenfriedrice

preseason NFL is boooring

Your not a true NFL fan than.

But teh HDD limits game developers :|thirstychainsaw

On real games like Oblivion and GTA yet it does this is nothting more then sloppy porting . But hell what do you expect from a company that makes esentially the same game every year.

[QUOTE="Scarletred"]

Here's one saying the PS3 fighters looked better.

http://www.cnet.com.au/games/ps3/0,239035763,339274404,00.htmMagical_Zebra

That link FAILS. G A M E S P O T counts... :shock:

Here's the other one:http://www.cinemablend.com/games/Fight-Night-Round-3-Ships-For-The-PS3-1915.htmlScarletred

That link also FAILS. Read the above response.

Oh and I can't take other reviews and comparisons? Scarletred

For the third time sir, no you cant. GS scores and reviews while on GS.

Don't give me that crap. That was never the deal. Scarletred

Um... SW states that only GS scores count and GS reviews count.

Hell if you want go look at the pics in the other topic called "List of Justifications". You don't see me complaining when people bring up the Lair reviews from EGM.Scarletred

It doesnt matter, they cant use EGM for ownage either. For the umpteenth time, only GS scores are recognized here on GS.

Oh yea and sorry...but you FAIL.Scarletred

I highly doubt it. See, I too can look up non GS links to further my cause.

http://forum.pcvsconsole.com/viewthread.php?tid=20964That link says virtually every game on the 360 looks better than the PS3. Oooohhhhh.. :shock:

[QUOTE="Magical_Zebra"][QUOTE="Scarletred"]

Here's one saying the PS3 fighters looked better.

http://www.cnet.com.au/games/ps3/0,239035763,339274404,00.htmHeil68

That link FAILS. G A M E S P O T counts... :shock:

Here's the other one:http://www.cinemablend.com/games/Fight-Night-Round-3-Ships-For-The-PS3-1915.htmlScarletred

That link also FAILS. Read the above response.

Oh and I can't take other reviews and comparisons? Scarletred

For the third time sir, no you cant. GS scores and reviews while on GS.

Don't give me that crap. That was never the deal. Scarletred

Um... SW states that only GS scores count and GS reviews count.

Hell if you want go look at the pics in the other topic called "List of Justifications". You don't see me complaining when people bring up the Lair reviews from EGM.Scarletred

It doesnt matter, they cant use EGM for ownage either. For the umpteenth time, only GS scores are recognized here on GS.

Oh yea and sorry...but you FAIL.Scarletred

I highly doubt it. See, I too can look up non GS links to further my cause.

http://forum.pcvsconsole.com/viewthread.php?tid=20964That link says virtually every game on the 360 looks better than the PS3. Oooohhhhh.. :shock:

I swear... Im just correcting those that need to be corrected. ;)