Another ps3 multiplat title bites the dust: 360/ps3 Mafia 2 demo comparison pics

[QUOTE="njean777"]

Is it just me or do all these videos have something wrong with their ps3 settings? Every time i see one its the exact opposite for my tv then they are showing. My ps3 has better colors and never is washed out. But my 360 use to always have washed out colors and looked worse. I dont get it even on hdmi it looked washed out for some reason. My ps3 has never had this problem. But anyways would get on ps3 anyways thats all i have now. Well and a gaming pc but i like my consoles more lol.

Pug-Nasty

Welcome to my world, man. I always see loads of nonsense videos and screen shots that contradict the image on my TV. The ps3 has a lot of settings, and it seems more than most "journalists" care to mess with.

QFT

I often cant replicate the "Blur" effect often shown on Eurogamer stills.

[QUOTE="njean777"]

Is it just me or do all these videos have something wrong with their ps3 settings? Every time i see one its the exact opposite for my tv then they are showing. My ps3 has better colors and never is washed out. But my 360 use to always have washed out colors and looked worse. I dont get it even on hdmi it looked washed out for some reason. My ps3 has never had this problem. But anyways would get on ps3 anyways thats all i have now. Well and a gaming pc but i like my consoles more lol.

Pug-Nasty

Welcome to my world, man. I always see loads of nonsense videos and screen shots that contradict the image on my TV. The ps3 has a lot of settings, and it seems more than most "journalists" care to mess with.

Thank god im not alone lol, i have never been able to reproduce the washed out effect on my ps3 like these videos all show.

[QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

[QUOTE="njean777"]

Is it just me or do all these videos have something wrong with their ps3 settings? Every time i see one its the exact opposite for my tv then they are showing. My ps3 has better colors and never is washed out. But my 360 use to always have washed out colors and looked worse. I dont get it even on hdmi it looked washed out for some reason. My ps3 has never had this problem. But anyways would get on ps3 anyways thats all i have now. Well and a gaming pc but i like my consoles more lol.

njean777

Welcome to my world, man. I always see loads of nonsense videos and screen shots that contradict the image on my TV. The ps3 has a lot of settings, and it seems more than most "journalists" care to mess with.

Thank god im not alone lol, i have never been able to reproduce the washed out effect on my ps3 like these videos all show.

[QUOTE="njean777"]

Is it just me or do all these videos have something wrong with their ps3 settings? Every time i see one its the exact opposite for my tv then they are showing. My ps3 has better colors and never is washed out. But my 360 use to always have washed out colors and looked worse. I dont get it even on hdmi it looked washed out for some reason. My ps3 has never had this problem. But anyways would get on ps3 anyways thats all i have now. Well and a gaming pc but i like my consoles more lol.

Pug-Nasty

Welcome to my world, man. I always see loads of nonsense videos and screen shots that contradict the image on my TV. The ps3 has a lot of settings, and it seems more than most "journalists" care to mess with.

back to the conspiracy theories i see :lol:

go get dah tinfoil hats!

So how are we explaining these 'final' build shots now?

So how are we explaining these 'final' build shots now?

Jesus_on_fire

Oh, there were final build shots?

I would never have guessed that. You know, given how people are STILL discussing the pics from the FIRST PAGE. :P

just more lazy devs. Its getting to be ridiculous how lazy devs are these days...

we know its lazy devs, because teh cell is so powah!

[QUOTE="santoron"]

Gamespot hosted screenshot from the PS3 final build (Hoisted from another thread :oops: ) OMG... Grass!

...And this is why fanboys shouldn't make assumptions on poor photos of demo versions.

tonitorsi

I hereby certify that this thread has met its end.

Assuming its legit. Just saying, Devs releasing doctored photos to make one version look better before release is not a new thing, just ask SE.

[QUOTE="tonitorsi"]

[QUOTE="santoron"]

Gamespot hosted screenshot from the PS3 final build (Hoisted from another thread :oops: ) OMG... Grass!

...And this is why fanboys shouldn't make assumptions on poor photos of demo versions.

XboximusPrime

I hereby certify that this thread has met its end.

Assuming its legit. Jsut saying, Devs releasing doctored photos to make on version look better before release is not a new thing, just as SE.

[QUOTE="XboximusPrime"]

[QUOTE="tonitorsi"]

I hereby certify that this thread has met its end.

mystervj

Assuming its legit. Jsut saying, Devs releasing doctored photos to make on version look better before release is not a new thing, just as SE.

I played both versions of the demo, trust me, that video is pretty accurate of the demo quality.

needs more foilage :P

No excuses for the PS3 can be given anymore. The 360 is definitely more powerful. Developers already have ample enough time to know the PS3 hardware and still shoddy titles are produced.

bphan

I just downloaded the demo for the PS3 and other then the grass I cant see a difference at all

And who cares about grass any way?

in all honesty do anybody really cares about the differences of mulitplats from ps3/360? the ps3 looks the exact same to me.

[QUOTE="mystervj"]

[QUOTE="XboximusPrime"]

Assuming its legit. Jsut saying, Devs releasing doctored photos to make on version look better before release is not a new thing, just as SE.

XboximusPrime

I played both versions of the demo, trust me, that video is pretty accurate of the demo quality.

[QUOTE="T-razor1"]

Some more pics. I think it is now widely agreed that the ps3 simply cannot handle heavy foliage, grass etc.. Again you can make fun of "da foliage" and grass all you want but to me it greatly adds to the graphical quality of the game and adds to the overall immersive experience.

ps3

360

ps3

360

FIipMode

Did you miss the most recent posts in your thread or something?

Didn't miss a thing my friend. But my question for you is did YOU read the recent posts in the other thread??!

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=27414613&page=9

Apparantly this magical ps3 shot that supposedly shows that the ps3 can handle foliage is not legit.....and just for arguments sake even if I believed that pic was a true pic of the final ps3 build then my goodness I can't wait to see what the final build of the PC and 360 version is. :shock::)

[QUOTE="FIipMode"]

[QUOTE="T-razor1"]

Some more pics. I think it is now widely agreed that the ps3 simply cannot handle heavy foliage, grass etc.. Again you can make fun of "da foliage" and grass all you want but to me it greatly adds to the graphical quality of the game and adds to the overall immersive experience.

ps3

360

ps3

360

T-razor1

Did you miss the most recent posts in your thread or something?

Didn't miss a thing my friend. But my question for you is did YOU read the recent posts in the other thread??!

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=27414613&page=9

Apparantly this magical ps3 shot that supposedly shows that the ps3 can handle foliage is not legit.....and just for arguments sake even if I believed that pic was a true pic of the final ps3 build then my goodness I can't wait to see what the final build of the PC and 360 version is. :shock::)

After playing both demo's, here's what I think

The PS3 version is on very low settings, thats why its missing foliage and has low res textures, helps the game run better.

The 360 version is on medium to high settings

Are people really still arguing about this? It's grass people, fake grass. Grass that looks like green cardboard sticking out for green ground. Will it really break your game experience to not see tall unmowed grass in a few sections of the game? If you answer yes then maybe you should consider building a Gaming PC jus to play this game.

Are people really still arguing about this? It's grass people, fake grass. Grass that looks like green cardboard sticking out for green ground. Will it really break your game experience to not see tall unmowed grass in a few sections of the game? If you answer yes then maybe you should consider building a Gaming PC jus to play this game.

Zero_epyon

Pretty sure this is fake.

lems have lost the exclusive games war, so now they hide behind multi platform games? LMAO how cute.

[QUOTE="ratchet_usa"]

Pretty sure this is fake.

lems have lost the exclusive games war, so now they hide behind multi platform games? LMAO how cute.

donalbane

exactly. lol i remember before the ps3 came out all the fanboys were going on about how the ps3 would blow the 360 out the water in terms of graphics, it never happened. now they're arguing that these "small" differences in the inferior ps3 multiplats mean nothing. lol how times have changed...

lol at the nearest tree on the 360 version in the first pic comparison, it looks like they had to trim it down so they can add grass on the ground.

btw, i hear that the ps3 version looks alot better in motion than the 360 version, more particle effects and better physics.

[QUOTE="donalbane"][QUOTE="ratchet_usa"]

Pretty sure this is fake.

lems have lost the exclusive games war, so now they hide behind multi platform games? LMAO how cute.

lazerface216

exactly. lol i remember before the ps3 came out all the fanboys were going on about how the ps3 would blow the 360 out the water in terms of graphics, it never happened. now they're arguing that these "small" differences in the inferior ps3 multiplats mean nothing. lol how times have changed...

lol at the nearest tree on the 360 version in the first pic comparison, it looks like they had to trim it down so they can add grass on the ground.

btw, i hear that the ps3 version looks alot better in motion than the 360 version, more particle effects and better physics.

for the ppl who think that 360 holds ps3 back.if this is true then ps3 version should be something at least equel to 360(if it's much more powerful),but as you see the diffrence ps3 version lacks grass.then it's not true.I mean i'm sure if someday they bring games like uncharted 2 to 360 then I am sure 360 version was just like ps3 version with a tiny diffrence.;)

[QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"]

lol at the nearest tree on the 360 version in the first pic comparison, it looks like they had to trim it down so they can add grass on the ground.

btw, i hear that the ps3 version looks alot better in motion than the 360 version, more particle effects and better physics.

donalbane

for the ppl who think that 360 holds ps3 back.if this is true then ps3 version should be something at least equel to 360(if it's much more powerful),but as you see the diffrence ps3 version lacks grass.then it's not true.I mean i'm sure if someday they bring games like uncharted 2 to 360 then I am sure 360 version was just like ps3 version with a tiny diffrence.;)

noob-saibot2010

and pay close attention to the shadows that are casting from the trees, look how nicer and smoother are on the ps3 version.

[QUOTE="donalbane"][QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"]

lol at the nearest tree on the 360 version in the first pic comparison, it looks like they had to trim it down so they can add grass on the ground.

btw, i hear that the ps3 version looks alot better in motion than the 360 version, more particle effects and better physics.

[QUOTE="donalbane"][QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"]

lol at the nearest tree on the 360 version in the first pic comparison, it looks like they had to trim it down so they can add grass on the ground.

btw, i hear that the ps3 version looks alot better in motion than the 360 version, more particle effects and better physics.

ZoomZoom2490

isn't it sad what everybody here argues over though, and really funny...

for the ppl who think that 360 holds ps3 back.if this is true then ps3 version should be something at least equel to 360(if it's much more powerful),but as you see the diffrence ps3 version lacks grass.then it's not true.I mean i'm sure if someday they bring games like uncharted 2 to 360 then I am sure 360 version was just like ps3 version with a tiny diffrence.;)

[QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"][QUOTE="noob-saibot2010"]

for the ppl who think that 360 holds ps3 back.if this is true then ps3 version should be something at least equel to 360(if it's much more powerful),but as you see the diffrence ps3 version lacks grass.then it's not true.I mean i'm sure if someday they bring games like uncharted 2 to 360 then I am sure 360 version was just like ps3 version with a tiny diffrence.;)

donalbane

Nah, I noticed that too. Even in the shots where Vito is equidistant to the tree in each the ones in the PS3 version look fuller. Also, the draw distance looks a little more detailed in the PS3 version.

That being said, yes, the grass is a more significant difference.

See, unlike many here, I don't care about one version being better than another. I'd just be happy to see more parity in multiplatform releases.

Here's a PS3/360 video comparison.

cant really tell. neither look as good as the pics of the gamei seen last year.

its funny how nobody notices that the 360 version has no real time dynamic shadowing, pay close attention to the trees in the distance on the left, 360 version is missing shadows.

PS3:

360:

Here's a PS3/360 video comparison.

gago-gago

:lol:, so wait I thought there weren't any foliage on the PS3 version?? Did the grass just suddenly grow overtime?

Also if you look at 03:17 on that video, the 360 version side's grass are popping up (pop-up textures?).

Vitos shadow looks alot more realistic on the ps3 version than the 360 version.

its soo funy how most people here are just focusing on the grass and ignoring alot of other things.

[QUOTE="gago-gago"]

Here's a PS3/360 video comparison.

:lol:, so wait I thought there weren't any foliage on the PS3 version?? Did the grass just suddenly grow overtime?

Also if you look at 03:17 on that video, the 360 version side's grass are popping up (pop-up textures?).

[QUOTE="noob-saibot2010"]

for the ppl who think that 360 holds ps3 back.if this is true then ps3 version should be something at least equel to 360(if it's much more powerful),but as you see the diffrence ps3 version lacks grass.then it's not true.I mean i'm sure if someday they bring games like uncharted 2 to 360 then I am sure 360 version was just like ps3 version with a tiny diffrence.;)

ZoomZoom2490

and pay close attention to the shadows that are casting from the trees, look how nicer and smoother are on the ps3 version.

what do you mean 360 version's trees are the half size ps3's.that is probably for zoom or something.and look at the character as well.his size is twise in the ps3 version.that's becouse of zoom.look when they make a game they are not going to design thing(trees or buildings or mail boxes)twise(one short and the other tall) to make sure game will work properly on all platforms.one of the ways to build grass in animation is using particle system witch needs alot of prosses.(particles are used to make smoke or mist too).a games quallity on a platform is based on textures,resulotion,antialiasing and particle prosses.but they dont make trees taller.

[QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"]

[QUOTE="noob-saibot2010"]

for the ppl who think that 360 holds ps3 back.if this is true then ps3 version should be something at least equel to 360(if it's much more powerful),but as you see the diffrence ps3 version lacks grass.then it's not true.I mean i'm sure if someday they bring games like uncharted 2 to 360 then I am sure 360 version was just like ps3 version with a tiny diffrence.;)

and pay close attention to the shadows that are casting from the trees, look how nicer and smoother are on the ps3 version.

what do you mean 360 version's trees are the half size ps3's.that is probably for zoom or something.and look at the character as well.his size is twise in the ps3 version.that's becouse of zoom.look when they make a game they are not going to design thing(trees or buildings or mail boxes)twise(one short and the other tall) to make sure game will work properly on all platforms.one of the ways to build grass in animation is using particle system witch needs alot of prosses.(particles are used to make smoke or mist too).a games quallity on a platform is based on textures,resulotion,antialiasing and particle prosses.but they dont make trees taller.

Vitos shadow looks alot more realistic on the ps3 version than the 360 version.

its soo funy how most people here are just focusing on the grass and ignoring alot of other things.

ZoomZoom2490

these pictures are from different angles and ther is a zoom in ps3 version.how it comes that you notice the shadows but you don't noice zooming?(player has pushed L2 and then they took the shot.).in open world games changing cameras will affect lighting based on sun's position.this is completly obvious that 360 version looks better(more detailed acording to grass).if you don't believe me watch the video comparision on you tube and you'll see.

its funny how nobody notices that the 360 version has no real time dynamic shadowing, pay close attention to the trees in the distance on the left, 360 version is missing shadows.

PS3:

360:

ZoomZoom2490

I've played both version's the 360 is cleaner and has sharper visuals and better shadowing, see the way the shadows on the right are different looking in the grass, in the PS3 picture its just a outline shadow of the character

[QUOTE="noob-saibot2010"]

[QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"] dude, look at the tree in the first pic, the 360 version is half the size and half the leaves than the ps3 version.

and pay close attention to the shadows that are casting from the trees, look how nicer and smoother are on the ps3 version.

ZoomZoom2490

what do you mean 360 version's trees are the half size ps3's.that is probably for zoom or something.and look at the character as well.his size is twise in the ps3 version.that's becouse of zoom.look when they make a game they are not going to design thing(trees or buildings or mail boxes)twise(one short and the other tall) to make sure game will work properly on all platforms.one of the ways to build grass in animation is using particle system witch needs alot of prosses.(particles are used to make smoke or mist too).a games quallity on a platform is based on textures,resulotion,antialiasing and particle prosses.but they dont make trees taller.

it's becouse in 360 version his shadow is on grass but in ps3 it's on pure ground.how can't you notice this?compare shadows of the building and you will understand what I mean.

Too bad both pales in comparison to the PC version :D

Sollet

The comparison video was too small to even tell the difference....

wow, if everyone in this thread would put this same focus in their education the world would be a smarter place, so is this what gaming has come down to? people focusing on comparing shadows and textures of games trying to put why the game is better looking on their console of choice? guys this is sad really sad