EDGE magazine rewards Skyward Sword a perfect 10.

Question is do you read the reviews?skrat_01

Yeah I have, how does that matter again?

[QUOTE="GD1551"]

Anyone else find it weird that when other publications give such early reviews people say bias, paid off etc etc but when edge does it it's legit? lmao

Thunderdrone

How are they any more legit than gamespot or IGN?

[QUOTE="GD1551"]

Anyone else find it weird that when other publications give such early reviews people say bias, paid off etc etc but when edge does it it's legit? lmao

AmayaPapaya

Edge is a magazine. They get games in before websites do.

Didn't stop people from saying that about OPM's 10/10 on AC.

that's just a troll review wait util the real reviewers releases their reviews.

HAZE-Unit

[QUOTE="Thunderdrone"][QUOTE="GD1551"]

Anyone else find it weird that when other publications give such early reviews people say bias, paid off etc etc but when edge does it it's legit? lmao

GD1551

How are they any more legit than gamespot or IGN?

[QUOTE="Thunderdrone"][QUOTE="GD1551"]

Anyone else find it weird that when other publications give such early reviews people say bias, paid off etc etc but when edge does it it's legit? lmao

GD1551

How are they any more legit than gamespot or IGN?

Just because a 10 here means prime and not perfect doesn't mean that it's the same for other publications.Rockman999

[QUOTE="skrat_01"] Question is do you read the reviews?GD1551

Yeah I have, how does that matter again?

Finally something decent to play on the Wii this year.

Stringerboy

[QUOTE="GD1551"]

[QUOTE="Thunderdrone"] Maybe thats because they have proven themselves as a legit reviewing source?Thunderdrone

How are they any more legit than gamespot or IGN?

Errr because if another review publication did this people would screen teh bias! Teh paid off!!!!! That was the reason for me even saying that.

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

[QUOTE="madsnakehhh"]

By EDGE standards.

Haziqonfire

They've given more 10's just this gen than GS has ever, while reviewing less games.

Never seen the appeal of the Zelda series but congrats Nintendo fans.racing1750

[QUOTE="racing1750"]Never seen the appeal of the Zelda series but congrats Nintendo fans.rasengan2552

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"][QUOTE="racing1750"]Never seen the appeal of the Zelda series but congrats Nintendo fans.nintendoboy16

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"][QUOTE="racing1750"]Never seen the appeal of the Zelda series but congrats Nintendo fans.nintendoboy16

How else would he be able to play The Legend of Zelda.

Because he obviously felt Zelda and smash were worth it?Rockman999

Not to mention, just buying a system for one or two things isn't giving the console (or company) a fair chance at all.

How else would he be able to play The Legend of Zelda.

D3dr0_0

[QUOTE="Rockman999"]Because he obviously felt Zelda and smash were worth it?nintendoboy16

How else would he be able to play The Legend of Zelda.

D3dr0_0

[QUOTE="Rockman999"]Because he obviously felt Zelda and smash were worth it?nintendoboy16

How else would he be able to play The Legend of Zelda.

D3dr0_0

There is 3D Dot Heroes and DarkSiders. I think that's it. Not really a large list to pick from. From what I have heard, neither are no where near Zelda.

No they do not. I've looked. The only game that comes close is 3D Dot Game Heroes and that plays like the NES Zelda.ActionRemix

[QUOTE="ActionRemix"]No they do not. I've looked. The only game that comes close is 3D Dot Game Heroes and that plays like the NES Zelda.nintendoboy16

[QUOTE="nintendoboy16"]

[QUOTE="ActionRemix"]No they do not. I've looked. The only game that comes close is 3D Dot Game Heroes and that plays like the NES Zelda.ActionRemix

Darksiders is closest Zelda you can get if not buy a Zelda game. That same approach with go to a dungeon, get a new key equipment/weapon to solve puzzles in the dungeon and to the beat boss and get access to new areas in the open world.

[QUOTE="ActionRemix"][QUOTE="nintendoboy16"] Um, I recall people saying Kameo: Elements of Power and Darksiders (Darksiders II is releasing soon, is it not?) Zelda clones. Not to mention, there is an HD Port of Beyond Good and Evil on PSN and XBLA. That's quite a bit of "Zelda like" games on HD systems (though I still don't see how Darksiders is anything like Zelda, but the majority does not agree with me there).

aroxx_ab

Darksiders is closest Zelda you can get if not buy a Zelda game. That same approach with go to a dungeon, get a new key equipment/weapon to solve puzzles in the dungeon and to the beat boss and get access to new areas in the open world.

Is Darksiders an adventure ? I though was an action title like GOW

[QUOTE="aroxx_ab"]

[QUOTE="ActionRemix"]Kameo and Darksiders are nothing like Zelda and I'm not going to count ports of last-gen games as alternatives to modern Zeldas.loosingENDS

Darksiders is closest Zelda you can get if not buy a Zelda game. That same approach with go to a dungeon, get a new key equipment/weapon to solve puzzles in the dungeon and to the beat boss and get access to new areas in the open world.

Is Darksiders an adventure ? I though was an action title like GOW

The first half is Hack and Slash, the second half is a Zeldalike.

[QUOTE="Haziqonfire"][QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]So easier than GameSpot's to get a perfect score...

shinrabanshou

They've given more 10's just this gen than GS has ever, while reviewing less games.

I fully agree with your first point, but, as far as EDGE reviewing fewer games, I hardly think that if they had reviewed more games they would have given more 10s. After all, there just aren't that many games that would be considered worthy of a 10/10. Even some of the games on their 10s list are disputable. I can't imagine any of the games they didn't review would have gotten close to a 10.

When can we expect scans of the review?. Same for the ONM review

[QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

[QUOTE="aroxx_ab"]

Darksiders is closest Zelda you can get if not buy a Zelda game. That same approach with go to a dungeon, get a new key equipment/weapon to solve puzzles in the dungeon and to the beat boss and get access to new areas in the open world.

Maroxad

Is Darksiders an adventure ? I though was an action title like GOW

The first half is Hack and Slash, the second half is a Zeldalike.

It is Zelda-like, but not as good at the formula as Zelda games are, and I still think it is very GOW-like. It lacks the charm, exploration, and cleverness in its boss fights and puzzles that Zelda has.

When can we expect scans of the review?. Same for the OPM reviewCrystal-Rush

I think EDGE comes out on the 25th.

"perfect 10" as in "perfect score, there is no way it could score higher".BrunoBRS

[QUOTE="Rockman999"]Because he obviously felt Zelda and smash were worth it?nintendoboy16

Not to mention, just buying a system for one or two things isn't giving the console (or company) a fair chance at all.

How else would he be able to play The Legend of Zelda.

D3dr0_0

I wouldn't say a lot all I could think about is that 3D Dot Hero for PS3 and Darksider. Both are nothing compared to the real thing.

[QUOTE="aroxx_ab"]

[QUOTE="ActionRemix"]Kameo and Darksiders are nothing like Zelda and I'm not going to count ports of last-gen games as alternatives to modern Zeldas.loosingENDS

Darksiders is closest Zelda you can get if not buy a Zelda game. That same approach with go to a dungeon, get a new key equipment/weapon to solve puzzles in the dungeon and to the beat boss and get access to new areas in the open world.

Is Darksiders an adventure ? I though was an action title like GOW

[QUOTE="BrunoBRS"]"perfect 10" as in "perfect score, there is no way it could score higher".skrat_01

[QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

[QUOTE="aroxx_ab"]

Darksiders is closest Zelda you can get if not buy a Zelda game. That same approach with go to a dungeon, get a new key equipment/weapon to solve puzzles in the dungeon and to the beat boss and get access to new areas in the open world.

BrunoBRS

Is Darksiders an adventure ? I though was an action title like GOW

[QUOTE="BrunoBRS"][QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

Is Darksiders an adventure ? I though was an action title like GOW

locopatho

I love Zelda, I really do, but I can't justify buying a system for one game. I'll probably just borrow someones wii, or maybe rent one for this game.

Still not a huge fan of motion controls, though.

[QUOTE="Rockman999"]Because he obviously felt Zelda and smash were worth it?nintendoboy16

Not to mention, just buying a system for one or two things isn't giving the console (or company) a fair chance at all.

How else would he be able to play The Legend of Zelda.

D3dr0_0

Not a single one, mate.

(Yeah Darksiders is obviously inspired by Zelda, and I even enjoyed it a lot, but its nowhere near the geniality of Zelda)

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]

[QUOTE="KiZZo1"]

Where's the sheep stampede?

waltefmoney

That's like asking for a death threat.

The rest of the scores in EDGE #234:

Uncharted 3 [9]
Batman AC [9]
Dark Souls [9]
Rage [7]
Super Mario 3D Land [8]
Forza 4 [8]
Disgaea 4 [8]
Ratchet All 4 One [6]
Ace Combat [8]
Dance Central 2 [8]

The rest of the scores in EDGE #234:

Uncharted 3 [9]
Batman AC [9]
Dark Souls [9]
Rage [7]
Super Mario 3D Land [8]
Forza 4 [8]
Disgaea 4 [8]
Ratchet All 4 One [6]
Ace Combat [8]
Dance Central 2 [8]

shinrabanshou

I love Zelda, I really do, but I can't justify buying a system for one game. I'll probably just borrow someones wii, or maybe rent one for this game.

Still not a huge fan of motion controls, though.

glimpus

You should also get Xenoblade, it's a excellent game to play if you haven't yet. If you aren't experienced with the Wii library i could recommend about 15 - 20 games to get.

It is the 3rd Wii game to get that score t must be something special.

Coming from EDGE, that's amazing! Can't wait to play the game.