@jg4xchamp said:
Just because you glossed it over, doesn't mean I'm going to dismiss the most obvious answer to your shitty topic about "dur what's the identity"
"is the xbox brand making a strong case about why it exists".
Yeah the case is pretty freakin obvious: Gamers buy it.
Glossed it over? I fucking opened the thread and punctuated the OP with the fact it sells. Xbox consoles selling means jack shit when one looks at how their brand is managed and how solid their long-term plans for it is.
@jg4xchamp said:
If it's a matter of franchises that get paraded around or praised: Halo got that. Forza got that. Gears of War got that. Both commercially and critically.
In between they still funded a Sunset Overdrive, a Toy Soldiers, an Ori, an Alan Wake, a Mark of the Ninja, Viva Pinata, and have had a ton of success with Xbox Live. Which yes deserves its knocks for the lousy shit that came with it (pay for online), but also deserves the praise for the shit it got right.
So not much at all to show off in terms of household names one associates with the brand.
@jg4xchamp said:
Their "legacy" is bringing in a more third party friendly console than anyone else on the market, which even to this day is a widely argued reality. Microsoft has always had better dev tools.
So their legacy is to make it easier for others to push their shit through their branded box? I agree. And its a shit legacy because there is very little internal effort in differentiating this box DESPITE it being good at running games other people make. Someone said earlier that the XBOX division managment has swiched hands numerous times, and it shows.
Its a muddled vision of couch gaming, being pushed by people that hope to attract content instead of also reinforcing the brand and also creating a long term legacy people can grow "attached" to after each generation.
@jg4xchamp said:
"but that brand identity hurts their cause". Yeah just like being a "kiddy" console or "old 20 year old franchises" tends to have its negative impact on Nintendo's brand, so I'm not seeing what's hard to explain here.
lool get the **** outta here with this shit. How would 20 year old IPs and family friendly games hurt the Xbox brand should they be lucky enough to have them? Nintendo failling to attract third parties is because of their most valued and well maintained assets? lol I thought its because the management seems to keep doing a shit job in reeling in third parties with wierd business decisions. But nope, its the multi-million dollar, decade long brands that hurt them.... right.
You speak as if both of these things are mutually exclusive, just to throw in some retarded, easy to digest bullshit comparison.
@jg4xchamp said:
Otherwise Microsoft has a shitty first party or a barely existing one. More at 11.
Now look who's glossing shit over. This terribly managed, short lived bursts of first party efforts are EXACTLY the type of shit that prevents their brand from having a strong, lasting legacy. You dont just throw that shit out there with a "dur hur more at 11" dumb remark".
Either you agree with that, or dont and explain why. The extraneous shit you grabbed from the bad is mostly irrelevant in the context of which the question was asked.
You asked a question that had very obvious answers, and then when you don't get one that panders to your bullshit, you want to gloss it over with what? barely a rebuttal and some limp dick attempt at a rejoinder? Please try me when you have an argument with a leg to stand on.
No. I asked a question based on a personal notion that in the end, is partially open for debate. I strongly feel one way and am interested in seeing solid arguments against the perspective I have on how strong, lasting and unique their brand is next to others in the market.
You come saying "obvious is obvious, news at 11, dur hur but wait...sales...mindeshare...kiddy nintendo...come back with a better argument" hoping to accomplish what exactly? You pointed out shit I already did and wrapped it around an aggressive reply in hopes of getting debate points. Congrats, now get your head out of your ass.
Log in to comment