Morgan Webb slams Zelda: SS for cartoony graphics, praises UC3 for "Adults&

http://www.g4tv.com/videos/55439/action-games-in-depth/

It's a good thing I don't take G4 seriously anymore.

I agree 100%, take that cartoony crap back to the 80's.i5750at4Ghz

Personally I wouldn't really say that UC3 is for adults only, more in the teen area in my eyes.

I agree 100%, take that cartoony crap back to the 80's.i5750at4Ghz

G4 is probably one of if not my most hated channel on t.v.

I think we got the picture that Morgan Webb doesn't like Cartoony Games back when Super Mario Galaxy 2 came out.

Heck even during E3 2009 she said she didn't want to see another Wind Waker Style Zelda Game and guess what? We got a Wind Waker Style Zelda game.

Sessler on the other hand...

Damn, after actually watching that, Morgan Webb just has the most unlikeable personality. She seem like such a fangirl elitist.

I see nothing wrong with saying facts, Zelda is indeed cartoonish looking game

I see nothing wrong with saying facts, Zelda is indeed cartoonish looking game

finalstar2007

[QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"][QUOTE="charizard1605"] Have you ever played any Zelda game?charizard1605

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"] All except for Twilight and Skyward. i5750at4Ghz

G4 is probably one of if not my most hated channel on t.v.

Jolt_counter119

This. I love Uncharted, but come on. I also love Zelda. Games would be boring if it was one of these styles or any other, all the time.

[QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"]

[QUOTE="charizard1605"] And in spite of that, you fail to see the point. :| Did The Wind Waker teach you nothing? Graphics don't matter jack, it's all about game design and mechanics, and Zelda has that on lock, it's always immaculate. There is literally no other game series that survives ONLY on the basis of pure and sheer level design like Zelda does. Graphics, especially in the case of Zelda, are a means to an end, the end being communicating said game design to the player.charizard1605

To be fair, A Link To The Past has some of the best 2D graphics IMO. I LOVE them :).

[QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"]

[QUOTE="charizard1605"] And in spite of that, you fail to see the point. :| Did The Wind Waker teach you nothing? Graphics don't matter jack, it's all about game design and mechanics, and Zelda has that on lock, it's always immaculate. There is literally no other game series that survives ONLY on the basis of pure and sheer level design like Zelda does. Graphics, especially in the case of Zelda, are a means to an end, the end being communicating said game design to the player.charizard1605

To be fair, A Link To The Past has some of the best 2D graphics IMO. I LOVE them :).

NaveedLife

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

To be fair, A Link To The Past has some of the best 2D graphics IMO. I LOVE them :).

charizard1605

TP doesn't look realistic at all..... I won't be missing anything. If I want to play a Zelda game I can simply fire up the N64.i5750at4Ghz

Me and you both know it won't be.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

To be fair, A Link To The Past has some of the best 2D graphics IMO. I LOVE them :).

charizard1605

TP doesn't look realistic at all..... I won't be missing anything. If I want to play a Zelda game I can simply fire up the N64.i5750at4Ghz

Ahhhh Super Metroid and A Link To The Past...two of the greatest games ever made! Both have stunning 2D visuals :). And I love this fan art of ALTTP. THese kind of graphics could be awesome for a 3DS title :P

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="NaveedLife"] Super Metroid was much better, IMO, and also Yoshi's Island, but if we are talking top down views, then yes, I agree with you. [QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"] TP doesn't look realistic at all..... I won't be missing anything. If I want to play a Zelda game I can simply fire up the N64.i5750at4Ghz

Me and you both know it won't be.

No you don't. I think it will be my second favorite console one, but I wont hype it TOO much, just in case. Could be the best one yet, but who knows. I have very high hopes.

I agree with the G4 crew and am glad mainstream game jounalists are being realistic about how crappy SS looks. I didn't think any would in fear of hurting peoples' feelings (sheep), like the infamous 8.5 GS gave Twilight Princess. There was a mass exodus of sheep. Lesson learned. I bet GS scores SS a 9 just to keep everyone happy while it'll reslly deserve a 7.5~8...

Me and you both know it won't be.

i5750at4Ghz

Ahhhh Super Metroid and A Link To The Past...two of the greatest games ever made! Both have stunning 2D visuals :). And I love this fan art of ALTTP. THese kind of graphics could be awesome for a 3DS title :P

NaveedLife

I agree with the G4 crew and am glad mainstream game jounalists are being realistic about how crappy SS looks. I didn't think any would in fear of hurting peoples' feelings (sheep), like the infamous 8.5 GS gave Twilight Princess. There was a mass exodus of sheep. Lesson learned. I bet GS scores SS a 9 just to keep everyone happy while it'll reslly deserve a 7.5~8...

trollop_scat

:roll:

Ahhhh Super Metroid and A Link To The Past...two of the greatest games ever made! Both have stunning 2D visuals :). And I love this fan art of ALTTP. THese kind of graphics could be awesome for a 3DS title :P

NaveedLife

Orioto's art is amazing. I use his images as wallpapers from time to time! :D

Uncharted looks cartoony, so I don't know where she is going with that. Not to mention the games are rated Teen.

I agree with the G4 crew and am glad mainstream game jounalists are being realistic about how crappy SS looks. I didn't think any would in fear of hurting peoples' feelings (sheep), like the infamous 8.5 GS gave Twilight Princess. There was a mass exodus of sheep. Lesson learned. I bet GS scores SS a 9 just to keep everyone happy while it'll reslly deserve a 7.5~8...

trollop_scat

Nah. Maybe it'll get a low score to make the haters happy while it scores a 90+ meta like they always do.

I agree with the G4 crew and am glad mainstream game jounalists are being realistic about how crappy SS looks. I didn't think any would in fear of hurting peoples' feelings (sheep), like the infamous 8.5 GS gave Twilight Princess. There was a mass exodus of sheep. Lesson learned. I bet GS scores SS a 9 just to keep everyone happy while it'll reslly deserve a 7.5~8...

trollop_scat

[QUOTE="trollop_scat"]

I agree with the G4 crew and am glad mainstream game jounalists are being realistic about how crappy SS looks. I didn't think any would in fear of hurting peoples' feelings (sheep), like the infamous 8.5 GS gave Twilight Princess. There was a mass exodus of sheep. Lesson learned. I bet GS scores SS a 9 just to keep everyone happy while it'll reslly deserve a 7.5~8...

Shinobishyguy

I will be shocked if scores less than a 9 (and it WILL deserve it).

morgan webb biggest troll on g4

When someone says Uncharted is innovative you know they are high. The game is piggybacking off Tomb Raider. Uncharted 3 is 2 on steroids and nothing more. As for Assasin's Creed well lets not even go there.

Damn, after actually watching that, Morgan Webb just has the most unlikeable personality. She seem like such a fangirl elitist.

Jolt_counter119

I always got the impression that she was just a chick paid to pretend to like games to rope in a certain demographic.

I don't agree with her here, but I am more inclined to believe her to be a gamer because she has an opinion on the matter.

SS's graphics don't seem to be a problem to me. After all, it's the Wii, and we know what to expect from it graphics-wise. To expect a crazy leap from other games on the system is ridiculous.

To me, the gameplay is what looks to be very poor. The motion control heavy combat doesn't look very fluid. If it ends up being true one-to-one swordplay, then that could be really cool or really tedious. If it's anything less than that I just don't see a point.

She said the same crap about SMG2. I'm not even sure why she's there, because it can't be for her man face.

[QUOTE="Jolt_counter119"]

Damn, after actually watching that, Morgan Webb just has the most unlikeable personality. She seem like such a fangirl elitist.

Pug-Nasty

I always got the impression that she was just a chick paid to pretend to like games to rope in a certain demographic.

I don't agree with her here, but I am more inclined to believe her to be a gamer because she has an opinion on the matter.

SS's graphics don't seem to be a problem to me. After all, it's the Wii, and we know what to expect from it graphics-wise. To expect a crazy leap from other games on the system is ridiculous.

To me, the gameplay is what looks to be very poor. The motion control heavy combat doesn't look very fluid. If it ends up being true one-to-one swordplay, then that could be really cool or really tedious. If it's anything less than that I just don't see a point.

[QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

[QUOTE="Jolt_counter119"]

Damn, after actually watching that, Morgan Webb just has the most unlikeable personality. She seem like such a fangirl elitist.

charizard1605

I always got the impression that she was just a chick paid to pretend to like games to rope in a certain demographic.

I don't agree with her here, but I am more inclined to believe her to be a gamer because she has an opinion on the matter.

SS's graphics don't seem to be a problem to me. After all, it's the Wii, and we know what to expect from it graphics-wise. To expect a crazy leap from other games on the system is ridiculous.

To me, the gameplay is what looks to be very poor. The motion control heavy combat doesn't look very fluid. If it ends up being true one-to-one swordplay, then that could be really cool or really tedious. If it's anything less than that I just don't see a point.

It is? if its confirmed from a vid, thats why i dont know about it lol. black out for me ;).

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

I always got the impression that she was just a chick paid to pretend to like games to rope in a certain demographic.

I don't agree with her here, but I am more inclined to believe her to be a gamer because she has an opinion on the matter.

SS's graphics don't seem to be a problem to me. After all, it's the Wii, and we know what to expect from it graphics-wise. To expect a crazy leap from other games on the system is ridiculous.

To me, the gameplay is what looks to be very poor. The motion control heavy combat doesn't look very fluid. If it ends up being true one-to-one swordplay, then that could be really cool or really tedious. If it's anything less than that I just don't see a point.

NaveedLife

It is? if its confirmed from a vid, thats why i dont know about it lol. black out for me ;).

Not going to bother watching the video, but did she really say Uncharted 3 and AC Revelations are innovative? LMAO what a joke.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="charizard1605"] It's confirmed to be one to one true swordplay.charizard1605

It is? if its confirmed from a vid, thats why i dont know about it lol. black out for me ;).

I remember them saying that they did not make it 1:1 as it was just too complex and required too much of a learning curve. I mean it is sort of 1:1, but you will not be peforming any completely custom slashes and such. when you slash, it slashes in that direction (of 10 or so directions i think). But if you move it slow the sword is 1:1 without slashing. Thats how I thought it worked.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="charizard1605"] It's confirmed to be one to one true swordplay.charizard1605

It is? if its confirmed from a vid, thats why i dont know about it lol. black out for me ;).

Well, I won't believe it just because they said it. It's not like the Wii has a reputation for one-to-one motion sensing, even with motion+. Like I said, that could be cool, or tedious, if true.

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

It is? if its confirmed from a vid, thats why i dont know about it lol. black out for me ;).

NaveedLife

I remember them saying that they did not make it 1:1 as it was just too complex and required too much of a learning curve. I mean it is sort of 1:1, but you will not be peforming any completely custom slashes and such. when you slash, it slashes in that direction (of 10 or so directions i think). But if you move it slow the sword is 1:1 without slashing. Thats how I thought it worked.

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

It is? if its confirmed from a vid, thats why i dont know about it lol. black out for me ;).

Pug-Nasty

Well, I won't believe it just because they said it. It's not like the Wii has a reputation for one-to-one motion sensing, even with motion+. Like I said, that could be cool, or tedious, if true.